click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!
Showing posts with label sirota. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sirota. Show all posts

Friday, February 23, 2007

Senator Lieberman, Don't let the door hit you on the ass on the way out.

Seems like there's more buzz on the possibility of Bush's favorite Senator, Joe Lieberman (CT-Party of One) picking up his toys and jumping the fence to join the Repugs (officially, that is - Joe's been unofficially one for a long time). Joe's been filling up a diaper load on a daily basis with his obsessive love of all things Iraq, not giving two shits to the overwhelming majority of his constituents who oppose the war.

The panic line seems to be that if Holy Joe jumps ship, he'll 'return control of the Senate to the Republicans'. Not completely true. At that point, it would be a 50-50 Senate, with Dickhead Cheney breaking any tied votes. But a point to ponder... considering the way the Senate has voted lately, and with Repubs jumping ship on Iraq quickly, the chance of 50-50 votes on anything is becoming extremely unlikely. The other concern is that if he did, there would have to be some new kind of power sharing agreement in regards to committees and such, as there was when Sen. Jim Jeffords left the Repubs a few years back. I can't remember where I read this, but I think that once the Senate rules are in place and agreed upon at the beginning of the term, they can not be changed, short of a supermajority. If anyone has more details on this, please leave something in the comments and I'll update it. But if that is indeed true, him leaving the Dems won't really do much in terms of shifting the power.

There are a lot of reasons for him not to make the switch. If indeed, the Senate rules stay in place, it's a damn good bet that he'll lose his chairmanship of the Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee. Considering it's the committee responsible for overseeing his buddy in the executive branch, nothing would be better than to get him out of there. He seems intent on not overseeing the President on anything, as evidenced by his response to investigating the Katrina debacle.

It's amazing how the mainstream media is spinning this, as evidenced by the garbage Time put out today on the matter:

If he were to jump ship, the ensuing shift of power to Republicans would scramble the politics of the war in Iraq, undercut the Democrats' national agenda and potentially weaken their hopes for the White House in 2008.
What kinda horseshit is that? Lieberman has recently made it his life's work to undercut the Democratic agenda. By what stretch of the imagination would he somehow undercut it more in the GOP? And potentially 'weaken their hopes for the WH in 2008'? How? I thought that was Hillary's job. If the implication is that a McCain-Lieberman ticket would somehow have some chance in hell of winning, then methinks someone at Time's been spending too much time with the crack pipe.

David Sirota has a good take on how Joe jumping ship works out to be a positive for the Dems:
Democrats control the House, and as we've seen on the Iraq debate, a narrow majority in the Senate effectively stops that institution from doing anything. Thus, we have basic gridlock right now. Additionally, most believe that President Bush will veto any good legislation that manages to get out of Congress right now - meaning that gridlock is ensured by the White House. Throwing the Senate to the Republicans by one vote wouldn't change this gridlocked situation at all. Democrats would still have the House and filibuster-ready Senators to stop anything awful from getting to Bush's desk. Meanwhile, Democrats would still have investigatory/oversight power from their House chairmen...

So, to sum up: I hope Lieberman switches because A) it would be advantageous for Democrats in the long-term B) it wouldn't hurt Democrats or progressives in the short-term, if Senate Democrats developed the spine to filibuster horrible nominees (admittedly an "if") and C) while he already is politically irrelevant in terms of actual power, Lieberman's switch would, finally, make him widely perceived as irrelevant, meaning that he would cease to have any effect on the national debate and that his melting, Emperor-from-Star-Wars face would stop appearing on my television set and freaking out my dog, Monty.
So those of you who are frettin' over this, don't. He's nothing but a liability to you Democrats. Him leaving would just hasten his demise into political irrelevancy. So relax. Heck, send him flowers if he does it. He'll need all the friends he can get at that point.

UPDATE: This on Media Matters:

As The Washington Post reported on January 5, Republicans would not be able to automatically reorganize the Senate if Sen. Tim Johnson (D-SD) were replaced with a Republican, effectively the same scenario as Lieberman caucusing with the Republicans:

Republican leaders decided not to seek special language spelling out the terms of a transition in case of a power shift -- say, if Johnson vacates his post and his state's GOP governor appoints a Republican to replace him. Under that scenario, power would effectively shift to Republicans, because Cheney would provide the tiebreaking 51st vote. But for Republicans to take parliamentary control, the Senate would have to vote for new organizational rules, a move Democrats could filibuster.

A similar scenario unfolded in January 2001, when a 50-50 Senate convened. In 2001, Democrats demanded a "kick-out clause" in organizing negotiations that would automatically scrap agreements on committee ratios and funding levels and force new organizational rules. But Republicans decided this month against a confrontation that would come from demanding a similar clause.

Read More...

Tuesday, December 5, 2006

Sirota's on a roll lately...

David Sirota's been writing some really good stuff lately. Last week it was his 'Barack Obama is the Almighty', which deconstructed the current love-fest on the left with Sen. Barack Obama. Sirota received quite a bit of flack for pointing out that other than the fact that Obama is highly charismatic, there's not really much there in terms of progressiveness to be excited about, and that he hasn't really shown the leadership we're badly needing, while not precluding something happening to change that. Amen to that, brother. As I see it, so far the only plus about Obama is that he's not Hillary or Kerry. Once again, I'm thoroughly depressed about the potential '08 Dem prez candidates. It seems that once again, we're stuck with a 'lesser of two evils' roster, just like every other election I've voted in. And that sucks, big time. But I have also acknowledged that a candidate who would be sensible and progressive enough for my liking wouldn't have a chance of getting elected in this day and age.

Anyways, Sirota nails it again, this time going after the unchallenged free-market fundamentalism that is the current paradigm in this country, and responsible for a lot of the economic disparity nowadays, in his 'Flattening the Great Education Myth and the Free Market Fundamentalists'. There's just too much good stuff in the article to paraphrase here, just check it out for yourself. One of the most telling points is an account of a dialogue between students and a free-market professor, where the students question his premises and he doesn't exactly have any good answers. That's the big problem with all of this; we've just heard so many times that an unfettered free-market, and its 'market-based solutions' are the answer to everything, when often they are part of the problem. And this continues to be accepted as unquestioned truth, regardless of all of the evidence to the contrary. If Sirota is right, maybe that will start changing. Let's hope so.

Read More...