click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!
Showing posts with label skepticism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label skepticism. Show all posts

Friday, April 13, 2007

The Secret: New Age Stupidity and the 'Law' of Attraction

As I've lamented before, even though living in VT spares me the frustration of living with the sheer idiocy so prevalent in the Bible Belt, and the luxury of being to be an outspoken atheist and not having to hear people constantly ramble on about their beloved Sky Fairy, the downside is that there's a ton of hokey New Age b.s. up that is quite prominent up here. Astrology, 'energy healing', homeopathy and a host of other pseudoscientific garbage seem to be widely accepted by parts of the culture. Granted, it's not as harmful as having a bunch of dominionists running around, but it's still frustrating.

Speaking with some of these people is sometimes like speaking to a small child who hasn't developed a sense of reasoning yet. One of the common things I've heard is the power of positive vibes and thinking. Now, I don't mean metaphorically. I mean there are people that believe if you think positively about something, even something completely detached in any way from you, if enough people have those groovy thoughts, it will affect the outcome. Sure.

So I got an email today form the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry talking about some bestselling book that Oprah is plugging now, called 'Secrets', by Lisa Nichols. The article is called 'Secrets and Lies':

The problem is that neither the film nor the book has any basis in scientific reality. The Secret, Byrne states, lies in a New Age idea called the “Law of Attraction”: that similar things attract each other, so positive thoughts bring positive things and negative ones bring negative things. Of course, in physics, it is opposites that attract, but never mind that: according to Byrne, our thoughts send out vibrations that the universe (or some unspecified power) can somehow decipher and respond to. Therefore, goes the dubious logic, we have only to think very hard about the things we want, and we will get them. If you want to lose weight, Byrne writes, you’ll first have to accept that “food is not responsible for putting on weight. It is your thought that food is responsible for putting on weight that actually has food put on weight.”

If that example leaves you scratching your head, author Lisa Nichols, featured in the film, explains that “Every time you look inside your mail expecting to see a bill, guess what? It will be there. You’re expecting debt, so debt must show up. . . . Every day you confirm your thoughts. Debt is there because of the Law of Attraction. Do yourself a favor: Expect a check!” Doesn’t that make sense? According to The Secret’s economic insights, the problem is not our bills or debt; the problem is that we are expecting those pesky bills! One wonders how much time Oprah spent skimming the book before agreeing to promote this half-baked twaddle.

There’s also an ugly flipside: if you have an accident or disease, it’s your fault. There is of course a grain of truth to this: if a drunk wanders onto a highway and is hit, it’s likely his fault; if a lifelong smoker gets lung cancer, it’s likely her fault. But is everything we experience of our own making? If an airplane crashes, does that mean that one or more of the passengers brought that on himself? Do soldiers killed in Iraq simply not think enough positive thoughts?

It's crazy how these people make up their own 'laws' that usually run in direct contradiction to how scientific laws really work. Homeopathy is based on the same thing, the false notion that 'like cures like'. If a particular substance gives you hemorrhoids, ingesting a tiny, subatomic amount of it (often referred to as a 'ghost' molecule), will cure the ailment. Of course when you point this out, people just talk about some experience they had where the homeopathy 'cured' some ailment of theirs and completely disregard the placebo effect or the very distinct possibility that the symptom just went away on its own, as is the case with many ailments. Then they accuse you of working for the AMA.

The fact that this is a bestseller isn't surprising. Critical thinking skills are not really taught in the schools, and many people have an astounding lack of understanding of cause and effect, as well as the high occurrence of coincidence in our everyday lives. Instead of being aware of these things, we're stuck with people who insist that 'God must have done it/was speaking to me' or 'the positive/negative vibrations I sent out made it happen.' Looking at this really reveals why this country is in such a sorry state of existence. We have huge swaths of 13th century thinking in a 21st century universe.

Read More...

Wednesday, March 7, 2007

James Randi's Million Dollar Challenge

If you're not familiar with James Randi, you should be. He's made his life's work out of debunking paranormal hoaxes and such. He's best known for offering a prize of one million dollars to any person who can demonstrate psychic ability or paranormal activity in a controlled setting.Here's a list of phenomena, which demonstrated, would win one the money:

Dowsing. ESP. Precognition. Remote Viewing. Communicating with the Dead and/or "Channeling". Violations of Newton's Laws of Motion (Perpetual Motion Devices). Homeopathy. Chiropractic Healing (beyond back/joint problems). Faith Healing. Psychic Surgery. Astrology. Therapeutic Touch (aka "TT"). Qi Gong. Psychokinesis (aka "PK"). The Existence of Ghosts. Precognition & Prophecy. Levitation. Physiognomy. Psychometry. Pyramid Power. Reflexology. Applied Kinesiology (aka "AK"). Clairvoyance. The Existence of Auras. Graphology. Numerology. Palmistry. Phrenology.
The money's still there, if that tells you anything. Anyways, I added the James Randi Educational Foundation to the blogroll. It's a great site, where you can read about how psychics convince people that they know what they know when they really don't. Randi spent many years as a magician and a mentalist (kind of like a psychic), so he knows all of the tricks of the trade. Currently, there's a good piece on all of the 'woo-woo ideas' that seem to be on Oprah all of the time. Have a look.

Read More...

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

Science Watch: More on Magnet 'Therapy'

If you've been coming here for a while you might remember this post I did last December about bogus 'magnet therapy'. I was poking around the 'Healthy Skeptic' over at CSICOP's website, and there was a brief article about magnetic shoe insoles. Guess what? They don't work any differently than the non-magnetic variety:

In a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association in 2003, Dr. Mark Winemiller and colleagues at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota, tested magnetic and nonmagnetic insoles on 101 patients with foot pain. (Fifty-seven patients received magnetic insoles, the others received regular insoles — and neither scientist nor patient knew who was getting what.)

After wearing the insoles daily for eight weeks, both groups of patients reported pain relief, but the run-of-the-mill insoles worked just as well as the magnetic variety.

The good news about magnetic insoles is that they can ease foot pain by providing cushioning and support — just like regular insoles. "If you're going to get an insole," Winemiller says, "I wouldn't bother with a magnet."

As I pointed out in my previous post on this, there's no concrete supportive evidence that magnetic fields affect the iron in the blood, which is the basis for many of the claims of the effectiveness of magnet therapy (see that previous post of mine for more on that). I can see why some people might believe it, because on the surface, it sounds like it makes sense. But it doesn't really work that way.

Read More...

Thursday, January 18, 2007

FBC's First-ever Correction

Unlike when the Washington Post screws up and then issues a tiny correction buried in the nether regions of the newspaper (like on the 'Al Gore said he invented the internet' myth), when I screw up here, I'll make sure you know about it. A few weeks ago, I reported on a report from PEER that the Park Service at the Grand Canyon were no longer allowed to discuss the age of the Grand Canyon with park visitors so as to not offend the Christianists who believed the Sky Fairy made the Grand Canyon during Noah's flood, and that the P.S. bookstore was selling a book that told that same ridiculous story. Problem is, the first part isn't true. From the Skeptic:

Unfortunately, in our eagerness to find additional examples of the inappropriate intrusion of religion in American public life (as if we actually needed more), we accepted this claim by PEER without calling the National Park Service (NPS) or the Grand Canyon National Park (GCNP) to check it. As a testimony to the quality of our readers, however, dozens immediately phoned both NPS and GCNP, only to discover that the claim is absolutely false. Callers were told that the Grand Canyon is millions of years old, that no one is being pressured from Bush administration appointees — or by anyone else — to withhold scientific information, and all were referred to a statement by David Barna, Chief of Public Affairs, National Park Service as to the park’s official position. “Therefore, our interpretive talks, way-side exhibits, visitor center films, etc. use the following explanation for the age of the geologic features at Grand Canyon,” the document explains.

If asked the age of the Grand Canyon, our rangers use the following answer: ‘The principal consensus among geologists is that the Colorado River basin has developed in the past 40 million years and that the Grand Canyon itself is probably less than five to six million years old. The result of all this erosion is one of the most complete geologic columns on the planet.’

So, shame on me (and Skeptic) for not doing a little bit of fact-checking. Now if we could only get the Christianists to do some fact-checking as well, we might have some true progress.


Read More...

Tuesday, December 19, 2006

Confessions of a Ghost Tour Guide and Skeptic

I've often argued that some of us skeptics and atheists could do a much better job in communicating to the general public, without, shall we say, always being such a buzzkill. I'm going to point you now to a great article from CSICOP that shows you how it's done. Philip Howard is a skeptic - and a ghost tour guide in North Carolina, in Blackbeard territory. He tells a great narrative about the tours he gives to tourists. Here's the great thing at the end that some of us skeptics can learn from:

And a skeptic I am. I’ve never seen a ghost. I am convinced that spirit sightings and mysterious events can all be explained by natural causes. I live in a 150-year-old house where at least seven children died. Even so, I sleep soundly every night. When opportunity arises I speak out for critical thinking, warn against generalizing from anecdotal evidence, and challenge superstition and blind faith.

So how do I reconcile these tales and my core values? I have asked myself, am I aiding unreason and fostering pseudoscience by leading Ghost Tours? Am I encouraging people to uncritically believe in ghosts and spirits?

Finally I have come to a realization. I can simply tell the stories (they’re good tales, you know, and nothing is quite as refreshing as a good tale) and weave them together with fascinating local history (pirates, shipwrecks, war, geology, and numerous other entertaining legends).

Now and then someone will ask me, “Have you ever seen the ghost of Mad Mag?” or “Do you believe the dead can contact the living?” I’ve even had one man, with a decidedly perverse look in his eye, ask me if I thought demon spirits haunted our world.

Usually I turn the inquiry back on the questioner. “Walk back down this lane, alone, later tonight,” I say, “and let me know tomorrow what you experience.” Or, “It doesn’t really matter what I believe, does it. You need to make up your own mind. I simply relate the stories.”

For a while I toyed with the idea of handing out a disclaimer at the end of the tour. I wondered if it might assuage my conscience. But I soon thought better of that idea. There is no harm in sharing ghost stories, I decided. Anyone who can’t appreciate an Edgar Allen Poe tale, for instance, probably needs to get a life. I’ve realized that the participants in my tours are certainly able to make up their own minds. I maintain my integrity by never claiming that any of the ghost stories are evidence for the supernatural. The folks who listen to them can be the judge of that. I just tell the tales as I’ve heard them, although I agree with one wag who said, “It’s a damn poor piece of cloth that can’t take a little embroidery.”

Read More...

Thursday, December 14, 2006

Apathetic Agnosticism

Ever heard of Apathetic Agnosticism?

The position can be summarized as: "There is no proof either of God's existence or nonexistence, but since God (if there is one) appears unconcerned for the universe or the welfare of its inhabitants, the question is largely academic".
This was interesting, especially because I think many full blown atheists such as myself spend a long time in this zone before finally crossing over to the bright side.

Read More...

Never, EVER Question the Existence of Leprechauns

Unbelievable. An atheist art student expelled for questioning the existence of leprechauns:

In the classroom that day, Averill says one young woman was talking about her belief in energy layers and astral beings.

"I jokingly asked her if she believed in leprechauns. It turns out, she does. They live on another energy layer," Averill wrote in notes to himself later that day. "In the interest of bringing my own view to the discussion, I began to ask her how she knew these things. Again I know all too well that people can be sensitive about their spiritual beliefs, so I was pretty much walking on glass as I did so."

Averill says he wasn't trying to disprove the other student's religious beliefs, but "to convince her not to insist that they were scientifically proven."

The student, apparently offended, complained to the teacher. Averill was called into a meeting that evening, he says, with the Art Institute's dean of education, associate dean, and the dean of student affairs.

...and was soon expelled for questioning some fruit loop about the existence of leprechauns. Jebus forbid if someone questions your belief system. Political correctness rears its ugly head yet again.

Read More...

Tuesday, December 5, 2006

Science Watch: Cannibalistic Neanderthals and Bogus Magnet Therapy

Time for a bit 'o science today. First up, it seems there's some new evidence that Neanderthals might have been a bit cannibalistic at times (and, no, in case you were wondering, I'm not referring to GOP inter-party squabbling - I mean those other Neanderthals):

Neanderthals suffered periods of starvation and may have supplemented their diet through cannibalism, according to a study of remains from northwest Spain.

Paleobiologists studied samples from eight 43,000-year-old Neanderthal skeletons excavated from an underground cave in El SidrĂ³n, Spain since 2000. The study sheds light on how Neanderthals lived before the arrival of modern humans in Europe.

Researchers found cut marks and evidence that bones had been torn apart, which they say could indicate cannibalism.

"There is strong evidence suggesting that these Neanderthals were eaten," said the study's lead author, Antonio Rosas of the Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales in Madrid. "That is, long bones and the skull were broken for extraction of the marrow, [which] is very nutritious."

Now, living in Vermont, let's just say that I see that certain segments of the population are entranced by magical therapies under the guise of 'alternative medicine'. Now, before some of you bite my head off, I am in no way discrediting all forms of non-Western medicine such as chiropracty or some herbalism, but there is also a lot of bullshit stuff out there, and some Vermonters seem to love it, more than other places I've been to, seemingly because some peoples' minds are so open that a bit of their brains seem to have fallen out onto the floor and inadvertently kicked under the table and forgotten about. A big one we hear about in the news is 'magnet therapy'. Now, I can understand why some people might think there's some merit to it; on the surface it sounds scientific. But a great article at the Skeptical Inquirer from a few months back calls the bullshit:

Is there anything in the human body that is affected by magnetic fields? Surprisingly, the answer appears to be no. This seems counterintuitive since most people know that oxygen in our blood is carried by hemoglobin and that hemoglobin contains iron. This is why iron tablets are often recommended for the treatment of anemia. However, the iron in hemoglobin is not ferromagnetic . If hemoglobin contained ferromagnetic iron it would be simple to separate red blood cells from other bloods cells with a magnet. Several studies have shown that static magnetic fields do not affect blood flow . Perhaps more important, if hemoglobin contained ferromagnetic iron people might explode or be flung across the room when exposed to the extraordinarily powerful magnetic field of a MRI scan.

However, for the sake of argument, what if some effect of magnets on human tissue could be demonstrated? What is the likelihood that it would be a therapeutic or healing effect? Probably slim to nil. By analogy, consider chemical compounds. The number of known chemical compounds is on the order of ten million. However, only a handful have ever been shown to have any therapeutic effects. Yet millions are toxic. It would be most unwise to eat or drink anything found on the shelves of a typical chemistry lab. If a magnet had an effect on human tissue, there is no reason to believe that it would necessarily be a healing effect.

The article also points out some of the ridiculousness, such as a magnetic grid you can buy for your bed that will cure cancer. Have a read. Also, for a laugh, have a look at this page that shows what happens when people aren't careful around MRI machines.

Read More...

Thursday, October 12, 2006

Interview with Richard Dawkins

Excellent BBC interview with Richard Dawkins about his new 'God Delusion' book. He really knows how to hold his own. Check it out.

Read More...

Sunday, August 27, 2006

B.S. Patrol

(This piece isn't intended to give anymore unworthy attention to the JonBenet case, it's more to point out how easily people are swayed by bullshit, especially when it involves a 'psychic'.Since I started writing this piece, it turns out the Karr guy wasn't the killer after all, which just bolsters the case I make even more.)

Now, although I don't have a T.V., the impression I've been getting is that this JonBenet horseshit is dominating the airwaves, keeping the country even dumber. Unfortunately, we're in a time in our nation when critical thinking and focus on the real issues are more important than ever. Oh well.

Anyways, like most sane people, I couldn't give a rat's patoot about the DeadChildBeautyQueenDiversion. I've been ignoring it as much as possible, but one thing that caught my attention was how a psychic supposedly aided in an accurate police sketch. Now, not to get into a rant, but I'm not really a believer in psychics. I know all about cold reading/ignoring misses and remembering hits, and all the other tricks of the trade. So of course, my B.S. meter went off when hearing about it, but soon forgot about it.

So, it turns out that that so called 'accurate police sketch' is hardly accurate at all. Joe Nickell, a skeptic over at CSICOP (Committee for the Scientific Investigation of the Paranormal) deconstructs the falsehood, and by doing a serious analysis and comparison of the figures, shows hardly any resemblace at all, in his 'Shame on Shamus Sham'. If you check out the piece, you'll first off see that the police sketch really doesn't resemble Karr at all, it just looks like yet another generic white guy. Here's more from Nickell:

"In addition to the envisioned portrait, Allison predicted the killer would have "connections" to Germany and Georgia, and gave additional details. However, just as a New Jersey police captain had said of her other "cases," Allison's predictions "were difficult to verify when initially given." Allison followed the formula utilized by other reputed psychic sleuths: take advantage of the publicity engendered by a high-profile case, and make numerous pronouncements, such that-when the true facts are subsequently established-the statements can be interpreted accordingly. (For example, "water" can later be identified with a nearby stream, lake, water tower, etc.) This clever technique of after-the-fact matching is called retrofitting, and it has fooled even seasoned detectives."
It also makes me wonder of the power of the media and suggestion. They tell us it looks like the guy, it obviously doesn't, yet because it plants the nugget that it does in our minds, we tend to believe it anyways (kind of like the idea that Dubya is just another cowboy). I didn't use the images because of permissions, but if you look at the site, you can see in Nickell's 'forensic caricaturing', that the suspect and the drawing look nothing like each other.

As I noted, turns out he wasn't the guy. More importantly Aravosis points out all of the things the press neglected while covering this oh-so-not important story.

Read More...