You might remember a while ago that the VT delegation had a hearing on the new Federal Farm Bill that is currently up for reauthorization. I'd like to point you now to this piece in the NYT by Michael Pollan, author of the bestselling 'The Omnivore's Dilemma', that lays out in no uncertain terms how important the farm bill really is. It affects many levels: public health, nutrition programs, many aspects of the farming industry, and the environment.
Some of you might remember back during the so-called 'Republican Revolution', as they began to wage their war on the poor, then Senator Phil Gramm (R-TX and T&A movies) made a comment along the lines that 'America is the only country where our poor people are fat'. Now, insensitive as it was for Gramm to say so, in a sense he did have a point. As you've heard me lament before, there's something really wrong with the system where only the rich can afford to eat healthy. As Pollan writes: A few years ago, an obesity researcher at the University of Washington named Adam Drewnowski ventured into the supermarket to solve a mystery. He wanted to figure out why it is that the most reliable predictor of obesity in America today is a person’s wealth. For most of history, after all, the poor have typically suffered from a shortage of calories, not a surfeit. So how is it that today the people with the least amount of money to spend on food are the ones most likely to be overweight?
So how does this tie into the farm bill? Subsidies, baby. Subsidies, proving once again the idea of a 'free' market is nothing but a myth:
Drewnowski gave himself a hypothetical dollar to spend, using it to purchase as many calories as he possibly could. He discovered that he could buy the most calories per dollar in the middle aisles of the supermarket, among the towering canyons of processed food and soft drink. ... he found that a dollar could buy 1,200 calories of cookies or potato chips but only 250 calories of carrots. Looking for something to wash down those chips, he discovered that his dollar bought 875 calories of soda but only 170 calories of orange juice...he concluded that the rules of the food game in America are organized in such a way that if you are eating on a budget, the most rational economic strategy is to eat badly — and get fat. [The farm bill] which comes around roughly every five years and is about to do so again, sets the rules for the American food system — indeed, to a considerable extent, for the world’s food system. Among other things, it determines which crops will be subsidized and which will not, and in the case of the carrot and the Twinkie, the farm bill as currently written offers a lot more support to the cake than to the root. Like most processed foods, the Twinkie is basically a clever arrangement of carbohydrates and fats teased out of corn, soybeans and wheat — three of the five commodity crops that the farm bill supports, to the tune of some $25 billion a year. (Rice and cotton are the others.) For the last several decades ... U.S. agricultural policy has been designed in such a way as to promote the overproduction of these five commodities, especially corn and soy...The reason the least healthful calories in the supermarket are the cheapest is that those are the ones the farm bill encourages farmers to grow.
Pollan then goes on to show how the needs of big agribusiness are often contradictory to the needs of public health. It even determines what foods your kids will eat for lunch at school (ever wonder why there's always Tater Tots? - certainly not because of all the nutrition they don't have). It also affects world poverty, as well, for when we are able to sell crops for less than it costs to grow them, that often can determine the fate of Mexican corn farmers and Nigerian cotton growers, and whether they lose their farms and move to the city, exacerbating the poverty already rampant there.
You'd think something this important would be something to rally around, but due to the technical jargon and back room deals, it usually passes, unnoticed except by the few that stand to benefit the most from it (certainly not you or I).
Pollan is optimistic, however, that change may finally be around the corner, due to the increasing awareness of the environmental community, the development community, and the public health community. But most importantly, he insists that real change is not just going to come from changing our eating habits; we need to get our hands dirty and start taking notice of agricultural policies, and concentrate our activism there: A grass-roots social movement is gathering around food issues today, and while it is still somewhat inchoate, the manifestations are everywhere: in local efforts to get vending machines out of the schools and to improve school lunch; in local campaigns to fight feedlots and to force food companies to better the lives of animals in agriculture; in the spectacular growth of the market for organic food and the revival of local food systems. In great and growing numbers, people are voting with their forks for a different sort of food system. But as powerful as the food consumer is — it was that consumer, after all, who built a $15 billion organic-food industry and more than doubled the number of farmer’s markets in the last few years — voting with our forks can advance reform only so far. It can’t, for example, change the fact that the system is rigged to make the most unhealthful calories in the marketplace the only ones the poor can afford. To change that, people will have to vote with their votes as well — which is to say, they will have to wade into the muddy political waters of agricultural policy.
I've mentioned it before.. for truly radical change to happen, we need to not just 'practice' democracy, we need to start living it.
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!Monday, April 23, 2007
The New Federal Farm Bill: Why it matters.
Monday, April 16, 2007
Wal-Mart abandoning organics PR campaign
Wal-Mart has been trying really hard to get some more upscale customers, not an easy task considering they're in the news just about every other day for some hideous display of corporate abuse. And one of the things they've tried is to start selling organic produce in their supermarkets. Of course, anyone who truly follows food issues just saw it for what it was - another greenwashing PR stunt. Much of the organic stuff was big agribusiness 'organics' and some were even from China, where who the hell knows what passes for organics there.
Well, apparently it's not working. MSNBC is reporting that Wal-Mart is scaling back on its organic plans, in some instances cutting them out completely. And it seems to be failing for several reasons. First, the average organic buyer isn't falling for it, and aren't going to be lured into Wal-mart just to save a few bucks. I think it's because many people who actually take the time to learn about organic foods are well aware that it's also about the scale of the operation, and don't trust foods from China or from Dole Corporation. Social and corporate responsibility do matter to many of these consumers.
There's a ton of info on Dole out there, but this one from 'Coop-America' sums up why many organics fans aren't buying what Wal-Mart is selling:It may follow Chiquita in banana sales, but Dole is the reigning world leader in fresh fruit and vegetable production. Dole's image revolves around the health and nutrition of its food, but nowhere does the company mention the poverty and ill health suffered by agricultural workers to bring Dole goods to the world. In Central America Dole's reputation for destruction derives from the poisoning of thousands of workers by the dangerous pesticide dibromochloropropane, also known by the brand names Nemagon and Fumazone. In 1979 the chemical was banned in the US when it was suspected of causing sterility, miscarriages, birth defects, and cancer when inhaled or absorbed throught the skin. Dole and other companies allowed workers in Central America to continue using the pesticide without warning of the devastating effects. Fruit and vegetable producers suffer from low prices dictated by multinationals, and banana producers have been especially hard-hit by what is perceived as a "race to the bottom." When it comes to Dole and agriculture, Co-op America says workers and the environment need your support.
Another corporate predator. And as the MSNBC article points out, the economy of scale of many organic farms isn't fitting in with Wal-Mart's economy of scale for the cheapest possible products:Consider the case of Organic Valley Family of Farms in La Farge, Wis., one of the country's largest cooperatives of organic farmers. When demand for organic milk soared two years ago, rival Horizon Organic Dairy offered to sell to Wal-Mart for 15% below Organic Valley's price. Wal-Mart expected a similar reduction from Organic Valley, but instead the cooperative pulled out. "Looking for ever-lower costs comes at a real cost to sustainability," says George Siemon, Organic Valley's chief executive. "To have consistent supply, you have to change the paradigm of thinking and think about long-term partnerships."
Wal-Mart is never going to get the socially conscious consumer, upscale or not, because those consumers are well aware that Wal-Mart by its very nature is not a good corpoate citizen, and in order for it to continue to exist, it never can be. But perhaps if the 'Left Behind' books, NASCAR everything and the other low points of American culture weren't so achingly prominent in a visit to Wal-Mart, some of the less socially conscious upscale buyers would have a reason not to go to Target. But then Wal-Mart would lose its main demographic. So it's probably best for them to just stick with that already huge part of the pie. And I'm not saying this from some liberal elite horseshit angle, although it may sound that way. It's the very real fact that these consumers inhabit two very different worlds, and are not exactly compatible with each other from a marketing sense. It's brie vs. Velveeta.
Labels: corporations, food
Wednesday, April 4, 2007
FDA: Pasteurization? Irradiation? Same thing...
I was a vegetarian for abut eight years, but not because I think there's anything wrong with eating meat. Quite the contrary, actually. I believe it's in the natural order of things, although I do think that modern Americans a disproportionately high amount of it. My vegetarianism was moreso rooted in my opposition to factory farming and all of the bad stuff that goes with it. After I moved to the small VT town I live in presently, and was presented with a plethora of choices of locally raised meat, I got back on the carnivore wagon. Yes, I'm still suffering the effects of eating too much locally produced sausage, but my personal health is a different issue than that of factory farming.
Anyways, today I read a story that once again, emphasizes the importance of local, small-scale agriculture. MSNBC is reporting that the FDA is proposing relaxing its food labelling standards to allow irradiated meat to be called 'pasteurized', which traditionally has meant the 'process of destroying dangerous bacteria from heat and rapid cooling'. Not nuclear radiation.
Now, health concerns aside, it illustrates a larger issue: the right for consumers to know what exactly went into the making of their food. Big agribusiness fights tooth and nail everytime any kind of law is proposed that will educate a consumer about the origins of their food, whethe it be what chemicals were used, whether it's genetically modified/irradiated, whatever. From what I understand, many foreign countries have food clearly marked in this way. The industry likes to use the argument that GMO's/irradiation/rBgh whatever have not been proven to be any more harmful than those foods not with them, and by labellings the foods as such would 'harm the industry'. Now regardless of whether or not these things may be harmful (and there is much evidence pointing that way in some cases), don't you think your right to know where your food is coming from is more important than 'whether it will harm the industry'?
Even if there is nothing different in irradiated beef, I still don't want to eat it, and should have that option. That's why it's really important for us to reconnect with our food supply, and get as close to its origin as possible. I realize that's not possible in New York City. And to the free-market fundamentalists who are always opposing even the most sensible regulations and argue that the market will follow where the consumers lead it, how can we lead it when we don't know what we're getting in the first place?
The FDA is taking public comment on this issue for 90 days. Even if you do eat local, remember that there are many who don't have that choice. Call the FDA at 1-888-463-6332 and let them know your views.








