click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!
Showing posts with label global warming. Show all posts
Showing posts with label global warming. Show all posts

Thursday, April 5, 2007

National Day of Climate Action 4-14: Step It Up

Vermonters - F.Y.I.

Step it Up - A National Day of Climate Action

Don't miss a fun opportunity to get involved and participate in Montpelier's `Step it Up' climate action day.

What: Hosted by VNRC, the Association of Vermont Recyclers, National Wildlife Federation and the Vermont Public Interest Research Group, the event includes speakers, music, maple creemees, a march to the State House and appearances by U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders and state Senator Peter Shumlin.

When: Saturday, April 14, 2007

Where: Morse Farm in East Montpelier (1168 County Road), followed by a march (or shuttle bus ride) to the State House in Montpelier.

Why: To push for bold and meaningful climate change action from lawmakers locally and nationally.

For more information visit www.vnrc.org or www.stepitup2007.org or call 802-223-2328.

Also, if you'd like more details, check out this post at GMD.

Read More...

Tuesday, March 27, 2007

More on Global Warming Denial

I hope I'm not beating a dead horse here, but these people are just as brainless as the fundamentalists in their inability to think outside of themselves, past their ideology, or past What Their Leaders Tell Them To Think (regardless of all the documented evidence that refutes what they're told). And like the fundies, they really have no conception of what the scientific method entails or what 'scientific consensus' means. (this is the part where chanman or some other clueless con accuses me of parroting talking points and not thinking for myself - pardon me for listening to scientific consensus and ignoring the industry-paid shills, folks).

Another great piece at Alien and Sedition pointed me to a Washington Post article that really sums up where the problem lies. A few points:

How did it get this way? The easy answer is that Republicans are just tools of the energy industry. It's certainly true that many of them are...The truth is more complicated — and more depressing: A small number of hard-core ideologues (some, but not all, industry shills) have led the thinking for the whole conservative movement.

National Review magazine, with its popular website, is a perfect example. It has a blog dedicated to casting doubt on global warming, or solutions to global warming, or anybody who advocates a solution. Its title is "Planet Gore." The psychology at work here is pretty clear: Your average conservative may not know anything about climate science, but conservatives do know they hate Al Gore. So, hold up Gore as a hate figure and conservatives will let that dictate their thinking on the issue.
Yeah, the 'Gore agenda'. Now where have I heard that one before? Interestingly enough, the article points out how the GOP itself has taken steps to make sure the truth doesn't come out from one of their own...
Meanwhile, Republicans who do believe in global warming get shunted aside. Nicole Gaudiano of Gannett News Service recently reported that Rep. Wayne Gilchrest asked to be on the Select Committee on Energy Independence and Global Warming. House Republican leader John Boehner of Ohio refused to allow it unless Gilchrest would say that humans have not contributed to global warming. The Maryland Republican refused and was denied a seat.

Reps. Roscoe Bartlett (R-Md.) and Vernon Ehlers (R-Mich.), both research scientists, also were denied seats on the committee. Normally, relevant expertise would be considered an advantage. In this case, it was a disqualification; if the GOP allowed Republican researchers who accept the scientific consensus to sit on a global warming panel, it would kill the party's strategy of making global warming seem to be the pet obsession of Democrats and Hollywood lefties.
I really think what we're going through now is the last stages of this, they're kicking and screaming. It's kind of how those Intelligent Design people keep holding on, as history and science marches against them. Ideology is even stronger than religion in many cases, and that's what we're seeing here. And all of that money from Big Oil. And, of course, resistance from those out there for whom the idea of having to modify their behavior to accommodate the well-being of society as a whole is just blasphemous.

UPDATE: More on the Big Oil Adminsitration's efforts to keep the public in the dark and sow the seeds of doubt.

Read More...

Monday, March 19, 2007

Global warming denier and industry hack coming to UVM - and more on the 'industry of denial'

(crossposted at Green Mountain Daily)

Now, I'm not trying to be a jerk or aggressive here because I really like her personally, but Charity's blog, She's Right, has been the gift that keeps on giving lately. I read about her announcement about an S. Fred Singer, PhD, who is giving a talk at UVM on March 28th at 7 pm in the Ira Allen Chapel, called, "500-Year Natural Cycle or Disaster Of Our Own Doing? - A look at the science and politics of global warming". So considering the source and the coded wording, my bullshit detector started beeping, so it was time to dig around.

See, Dr. Singer's got quite the career of being a p.r. hack for big, harmful corporations. He first rose to prominence as a a flack for big tobacco:

Singer has been accused of conflicts of interest, most notably involving financial ties to oil and tobacco companies. In 1993 APCO, a public relations firm, sent a memo to Philip Morris to vice-president Ellen Merlo stating: "As you know, we have been working with Dr. Fred Singer and Dr. Dwight Lee, who have authored articles on junk science and indoor air quality (IAQ) respectively ..."

The 1994 AdTI report was part of an attack on EPA regulation of environmental tobacco smoke funded by the Tobacco Institute. Singer was also involved with the International Center for a Scientific Ecology, a group that was considered important in Philip Morris' plans to create a group in Europe similar to The Advancement of Sound Science Coalition (TASSC). Singer is also a Research Fellow at the Independent Institute, another recipient of Philip Morris and ExxonMobil funds.

A nonsmoker himself, Singer serves on the Science Advisory Board of the American Council on Science and Health (ACSH). The ACSH strongly opposes smoking but otherwise tends to support industry positions on health issues, for example downplaying risks associated with dioxin, asbestos, and other carcinogenic materials.

This guy's a bad dude. But there's more. His foundations and work have been funded by hard-right ideologue Richard Mellon Scaife, and also by the Rev. Sun Myung Moon's organization. He has played a pivotal role in the above mentioned TASSC, whose main purpose was to spread the idea of environmental science as being 'junk science'. He was also in the employ of the Tobacco Institute's 'Whitecoats Project', their effort to discredit the environmental risks of tobacco smoke with the use of scientists. Although it's a lengthy read, there's a huge study of this here, if you're more interested. It's amazing, the depth and breadth that these people went to do this.

So, that' s just tobacco. Singer's been at the forefront of global warming denial, not surprising, considering just about everything the man has done on the subject has been funded (here, here, and here) in one way or another by the big polluting and petrochemical companies.

But aside from that, he can't even get the science right. Contrary to the evidence, he claims that the glaciers are advancing (not retreating as they have been since about 1850). And the one article he used as a source for that information was found not to even exist, by journalist George Monbiot. Needless to say, if you read even some of what I've pointed you too, it's obvious where this man's interests really lie. His rhetoric is typical right-wing bullshit that could have come from Townhall.com or FoxNews. Also, from the above Exxon Secrets site you can get a taste... tell me if you haven't heard this all before, such as the 'Global Warming is Good For You ' argument...
And most would agree that tackling the problems of 'climate change' requires adaptation -- again best handled by overcoming poverty. There is lively scientific debate on whether the climate is really warming, whether human influence is significant, and whether a future warming is good or bad. A group of prestigious economists has already concluded that a modest greenhouse warming is on the whole beneficial and will raise standards of living. Why then allocate resources to avoid a putative warming?
Source: Wall Street Journal 05/18/04
Or the 'Al Gore's Nefarious Liberal Agenda' conspiracy (and he trusts the judgment of Bush if that tells you anything)...
"The irony is that there is no convincing evidence that the global climate is actually warming...Mr Gore and company are stirring the pot, trying to create public anxiety in order to impose a form of energy rationing on the economy - like the recently defeated Senate bill of McCain-Lieberman, which would have forced a cap on emissions, equivalent to an energy tax. President George W. Bush has termed such a policy 'fatally flawed'."
Source: "Climate concern is just a tax ruse," Financial Times 11/26/03
So his little propaganda speech may be interesting, no? Now, why do I keep bringing this up? Because one of the typical whines from the right-wingers on global warming is that we're not 'allowing a debate', similar to the argument Intelligent Design advocates make (when in actuality, there is no 'debate' in the scientific community - there's an overwhelming consensus in regards to ID not being science). But here's my point- Why is it that it seems like every single person that they present either has major ties and funding to the polluting industries, presents faulty/incorrect data, or both? Why is that?

Well, apparently, there's a whole 'industry of denial' built up around debunking global warming. In last year's 'Heat', by George Monbiot, he meticulously connects the dots and lays it all out, beginning with this:
ExxonMobil is the world's most profitable corporation. Its sales now amount to more than $1bn a day. It makes most of this money from oil, and has more to lose than any other company from efforts to tackle climate change. To safeguard its profits, ExxonMobil needs to sow doubt about whether serious action needs to be taken on climate change. But there are difficulties: it must confront a scientific consensus as strong as that which maintains that smoking causes lung cancer or that HIV causes Aids. So what's its strategy?
And part of that strategy?
On the whole, they use selection, not invention. They will find one contradictory study - such as the discovery of tropospheric cooling, which, in a garbled form, has been used by Peter Hitchens in the Mail on Sunday - and promote it relentlessly. They will continue to do so long after it has been disproved by further work. So, for example, John Christy, the author of the troposphere paper, admitted in August 2005 that his figures were incorrect, yet his initial findings are still being circulated and championed by many of these groups, as a quick internet search will show you.
He also mentions that bogus Oregon Petition that Vermont's own blowhard corporate apologist, John McLaughry, has cited as a credible source. As one who holds science as one of humanity's best accomplishments and ways of finding the truth, believe me, I really do want a scientist to come forward with a compelling argument. But it seems impossible to find one that isn't tainted in one way or another. And it bears repeating: when reality has such a tendency to contradict much of one's worldview, sometimes the only way to deal with it is to make up an alternate one. And that seems to be what many (but most definitely not all) conservatives are doing.

If you're interested more on what organizations are funded by the industry, have a look at 'Global Warming Skeptics: A Primer'.

UPDATE: Whoa, it seems there actually might be some truth to the 'Al Gore global warming conspiracy'.

Read More...

Friday, March 16, 2007

The Swindle of the 'Great Global Warming Swindle'

(crossposted at Green Mountain Daily)

It's got to be hard to be a conservative, especially nowadays. It seems like the only way they can get out of bed in the morning is to exist in some alternate reality... you know, the one where 'they attack us because they hate our freedoms', 'the Founding Fathers wanted this to be a Christian nation', 'intelligent design is real science', 'supporting the troops means keeping them in Iraq', 'George W. Bush is a fine Christian man of integrity', 'if we would just let the markets decide, everything would be fine', and the latest doozie, courtesy of Charity at 'She's Right', 'global warming is not caused by humans'.

Apparently, there was a documentary on the BBC's Channel recently, called 'The Great Global Warming Swindle', which basically says that the overwhelming scientific evidence supporting man-made global warming is a lie. Turns out, it's yet another right wing propaganda hit-piece that plays loose with the facts. Like most classic propaganda targeting right-wingers, it even plays to their sense of perpetual victimhood, driving home the point that 'you are being told lies.'

The documentary was directed by self-proclaimed 'living Marxist' (whatever the hell that is) Martin Durkin, who also directed a BBC series in 1997 called 'Against Nature', which dismisses environmentalists as anti-progress, and believe that sustainable development practices are a 'conspiracy against people'. So his ideology should be quite apparent.

The UK Independent did an investigation of the 'The Great Global Warming Swindle', and found that it:

"was based on graphs that were distorted, mislabelled or just plain wrong. The graphs were nevertheless used to attack the credibility and honesty of climate scientists.

A graph central to the programme's thesis, purporting to show variations in global temperatures over the past century, claimed to show that global warming was not linked with industrial emissions of carbon dioxide. Yet the graph was not what it seemed.

Other graphs used out-of-date information or data that was shown some years ago to be wrong. Yet the programme makers claimed the graphs demonstrated that orthodox climate science was a conspiratorial "lie" foisted on the public."

But, that's just the tip of the rapidly melting iceberg. One of the central figures in the program was MIT oceanographer Carl Wunsch, has come out strongly about how his views were edited and presented so as to give a misleading account of his actual views. He discusses it in a piece here, 'I Should Have Never Trusted Channel 4' and also in a letter to the producer:

Fundamentally, I am the one who was swindled---please read the email below that was sent to me (and re-sent by you). Based upon this email and subsequent telephone conversations, and discussions with the Director, Martin Durkin, I thought I was being asked to appear in a film that would discuss in a balanced way the complicated elements of understanding of climate change---in the best traditions of British television. Is there any indication in the email evident to an outsider that the product would be so tendentious, so unbalanced?

I spent hours in the interview describing many of the problems of understanding the ocean in climate change, and the ways in which some of the more dramatic elements get exaggerated in the media relative to more realistic, potentially truly catastrophic issues, such as the implications of the oncoming sea level rise. As I made clear, both in the preliminary discussions, and in the interview itself, I believe that global warming is a very serious threat that needs equally serious discussion and no one seeing this film could possibly deduce that.

An example where my own discussion was grossly distorted by context: I am shown explaining that a warming ocean could expel more carbon dioxide than it absorbs -- thus exacerbating the greenhouse gas buildup in the atmosphere and hence worrisome. It was used in the film, through its context, to imply that CO2 is all natural, coming from the ocean, and that therefore the human element is irrelevant. This use of my remarks, which are literally what I said, comes close to fraud.

My appearance in the "Global Warming Swindle" is deeply embarrasing, and my professional reputation has been damaged. I was duped---an uncomfortable position in which to be.
Aside from the misrepresentation of Wunsch and the almost constant use of bad data, there's a host of other faulty data in the show. Medialens has an exhaustive analysis of the mind-numbingly false and misrepresented data in the film, too much to list here, but a few nuggets just to give you an idea:

The film repeatedly gave the impression that mainstream science argues that CO2 is the sole driver of rising temperatures in the Earth's climate system. But this is not the case. Climate scientists are well aware that solar activity plays a role, though a minor one at present, as do long-term periodic changes in the Earth's orbit, known as Milankovitch cycles. (See: http://en.wikipedia.org/ wiki/Milankovitch_cycles)

The point is that there is a vast body of evidence that very strongly supports the hypothesis that greenhouse gas emissions, of which CO2 is the most important, are primarily responsible for recent global warming. The 4th and most recent scientific assessment of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) concludes:

"Most of the observed increase in globally averaged temperatures since the mid-20th century is very likely [.i.e. probability greater than 90%] due to the observed increase in anthropogenic greenhouse gas concentrations." ('Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis,' Summary for Policymakers, IPCC, February 2007, page 10; www.ipcc.ch/SPM2feb07.pdf)

We then come to one of the film's most misleading arguments. Antarctic ice cores show that rises in levels of CO2 have lagged 800 years behind temperature rises at specific times in the geological past. This, argued Durkin, +proves+ that CO2 cannot be responsible for global warming - instead global warming is responsible for increasing levels of CO2. But this was a huge howler.

What Durkin's film failed to explain was that the 800-year lag happened at the end of ice ages which occur about every 100,000 years. (See: www.realclimate.org/index.php/ archives/2004/12/co2-in-ice-cores)

I can't help but wonder if some American conservatives are so against the global warming thing just simply due to the fact that Al Gore has played such an important role in increasing its awareness. If right-wingnut Sam Brownback was extolling its dangers, I can't help but to think they wouldn't be so skeptical. I'm surprised John McLaughry hasn't referred to this film, considering his fetish-like obsession with discredited facts and such. But when reality has such a tendency to contradict much of one's worldview, sometimes the only way to deal with it is to make up an alternate one.

It's going to take a lot more than one shabby piece of factually-challenged propaganda to turn the tide of an overwhelming consensus of the world's scientists (with the exception of those on the payroll of Big Oil, of course), and there's also that major report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. I guess what you believe depends on whether your biases or your capacity for critical thinking skills are the stronger cognitive impulses in your worldview. And, no, just to cut some of you off, I'm not saying we shouldn't debate these things. And I'm not saying people don't have a right to their opinions, or even the right to spread misleading propaganda. But it would be much more helpful if the global-warming deniers would actually do their homework before coming to the table.

"Facts are stupid things." - Ronald Reagan, 1988 Republican National Convention


Read More...

Tuesday, February 6, 2007

Why the hell does anyone waste ink/oxygen on John McLaughry?

As most of you know, one of the best things about Vermont is that it's not exactly an ideal place to live if one is a conservative. And often, as in other places, outspoken conservatives in their slavish devotion to free-market fundamentalism (and in VT, sometimes-but-thankfully-rarely Bible-based social conservatism), they tend to play a bit loose with the facts. Outspoken conservatives up here are so rare that it's not hard to get attention by opening one's mouth and letting the drivel fly - there's not a lot of competition. Hence, the John McLaughry experience.

McLaughry heads the VT-based think tank called the Ethan Allen Institute:

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont's independent, nonpartisan, free-market-oriented public policy think tank. The Institute offers "Ideas for Vermont's Future" built upon a libertarian, decentralist, community-based philosophy. It is one of some 48 similar but independent state organizations associated with the State Policy Network.

Mission Statement:

The Mission of the Ethan Allen Institute is to influence public policy in Vermont by helping its people to better understand and put into practice the fundamentals of a free society: individual liberty, private property, competitive free enterprise, limited and frugal government, strong local communities, personal responsibility, and expanded opportunity for human endeavor.

It's your typical 'let the markets decide the fate of the human race; it knows what's best' organization. McClaughry's got that William-Buckley-wannabe vibe going on, and is the public face of the E.A. Institute. Come to think of it, he's pretty much the only face I ever seem to see from the institute. The board of directors includes such heavyweights(snicker) as Jack McMullen, the guy who ran against Senator Leahy a few years back and lost the primary to farmer Fred Tuttle.

McLaughry himself has a rather impressive resume, having worked in the Reagan administration, served on four presidential commissions, held office in the Vermont House and Senate, as well as has an unsuccessful run for governor under his belt. You can hear his commentaries on Vermont's contribution to the right-wing noise machine, True North Radio. And to his credit, McLaughry hasn't ever framed his positions from the theocratic angle (he is an intellectual, after all). So, all in all, he's a pretty smart guy, and I say that sincerely. So you could imagine the cognitive dissonance I was having after reading his's op-ed piece on global warming in the Times Argus a few weeks back entitled 'Warming Hysteria is Out of Whack' (subscription or payment required to view), that stated:

Virtually unnoticed by the news media, over 17,000 scientists and engineers - nearly 2,000 of them with degrees in meteorology and climatology - signed the 1997 Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine Kyoto Petition. Its punch line read: "There is no convincing scientific evidence that human release of carbon dioxide, methane or other greenhouse gases is causing or will, in the foreseeable future, cause catastrophic heating of the Earth's atmosphere and disruption of the Earth's climate."

...The post-1979 lower troposphere satellite microwave data corroborated by radiosonde balloons shows no alarming global warming trend.

See, there's a problem here, folks. McLaughry, in his fetish-like obsession with free-market fundamentalism, knows that Americans, and particularly right-wingers, are kind of lazy with checking the facts. Many see something that confirms their preconceptions, see it coming from some blowhard the represents an 'institute' (giving it an air of credibility), and then accept the premises, case closed. Too bad he's wrong, not to mention that quoting 30 year old studies on a modern, quickly-evolving problem is pretty friggin' lazy. Might as well use the Bible for a reference.

In this last Sunday's Times Argus, Dr. Alan K. Betts, a real scientist (unlike McLaughry, the political scientist) who is the president of Vermont Academy of Science and Engineering in Pittsford, contributed an article that completely demolished McLaughry's wishful thinking piece. Here are the major points:

1. McClaughry quotes "evidence" that the lower tropospheric satellite microwave data do not show an "alarming global warming trend." This is a dishonest fudge of the real scientific evidence. The data in question from Spencer and Christie (Science, 1990, and other papers that followed) were for many years inconsistent with the surface warming record, and this was widely repeated as "evidence" that warming was not occurring. A U.S. Climate Change Science Program panel was specifically set up and funded by the (skeptical) U.S. government to resolve the issue. They found the errors in the Spencer and Christie analyses, and now the data agree; and all show the warming that has occurred in the last 30 years (during which we have had satellite as well as surface data). Read their 2006 report at http://www.climatescience.gov/Library/sap/sap1-1/finalreport/sap1-1-final-execsum.pdf. Sadly, this definitive report is deliberately ignored by McClaughry, because of course the scientific evidence inconveniently disagrees with his political agenda. The repetition of false information is a well-known tool of propaganda, not science.

2. The argument that only a few percent of the greenhouse gases are from our industrial society is totally misleading. Water vapor is the biggest contributor to the greenhouse effect. Together all of the greenhouse gases warm the Earth to an average of 60 degrees Fahrenheit, which means the oceans don't freeze Fahrenheit, making life as we know it on this planet possible. It is what we are doing to this balance that matters. Although carbon dioxide contributes a smaller amount than water vapor to the greenhouse warming, carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is rising very rapidly (about 100 parts per million over the last century; and now rising at about 2 parts per million per year) driven by fossil fuel burning. The growth of other industrial gases in the atmosphere is also contributing to the greenhouse effect. The presence of water vapor, coupled with the earth's temperature, amplifies the effects of these additional greenhouse gases. McClaughry is implying that a few more degrees of warming isn't much to worry about (because he does not want carbon dioxide emissions to be regulated).

3. McClaughry points out that in 1997 thousands of scientists signed an anti-Kyoto petition (starting "We urge the United States government to reject the global warming agreement that was written in Kyoto") as part of a successful campaign by business-funded interests to stop the United States from agreeing to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions. Ten years have passed and it is now clear that we need reductions in greenhouse gases far greater than those of the Kyoto agreement, if we are to avoid huge economic costs, as recently outlined in the Stern Review by the British government.

Ouch. Perhaps McLaughry really believes those words of his anointed savior, Ronald Reagan: 'Facts are stupid things.' But it doesn't even take a scientist to see how McLaughry is piling on the bull, it just takes a little fact-checking, as evidenced by these letters to the editor in response to McLaughry's diatribe. R.D. Eno from Cabot:

Snarling and foaming, McClaughry as much as calls any climatologist who contends that manmade emissions are tilting the climate toward rapid and unnatural warming a liar. But the only evidence McClaughry cites in his surly little scree is a "petition" circulated in 1998 by the Oregon Institute of Science and Medicin that disputes the evidence for global warming, signed, says McClaughry, by 17,000 scientists, of whom 2,000 were meteriologists or climatologists. This "petition" is a hoary old hoax.

OISM is a one-man operation, much like the Ethan Allen Institute, run by Arthur Robinson, a biochemist with a sideline in books about how to survive a nuclear war. The study that the "petition" supposedly supports was written by Robinson, his son and a couple of astrophysicists, none of them climatologists. (One of the authors, Sallie L. Baliunas, is affiliated with nine ExxonMobil-funded groups, according to New Scientist.) Robinson formatted the study to mimic a National Academy of Science article and then flooded university mailboxes with copies and a card to be signed as an endorsement. But the study was never peer reviewed and has been discredited by the academy. The number of legitimate endorsements of Robinson's "petition" cannot be determined because credentials were not listed, but Scientific American, randomly sampling the signatories, estimated that "petition" supporters included only about 200 climate researchers. The OISM paper and "petition" represent flat-earth science at its worst. Trying to pass off this baloney as filet mignon might be called, to paraphrase McClaughry's bluster, ethically repellent dishonesty, but that would dignify it.

Ya' know, it takes more than the word 'institute' to have some credibility, John. How is anyone supposed to take you seriously when your cherry-picked sources are about as reliable as Dick Cheney's were for Iraq? If McLaughry's sloppily researched op-eds are the best the conservatives of Vermont have to offer, it's no wonder they're an endangered species in Vermont. But I'm not complaining.

Read More...