click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!
Showing posts with label libertarianism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label libertarianism. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 6, 2007

Why the hell does anyone waste ink/oxygen on John McLaughry?

As most of you know, one of the best things about Vermont is that it's not exactly an ideal place to live if one is a conservative. And often, as in other places, outspoken conservatives in their slavish devotion to free-market fundamentalism (and in VT, sometimes-but-thankfully-rarely Bible-based social conservatism), they tend to play a bit loose with the facts. Outspoken conservatives up here are so rare that it's not hard to get attention by opening one's mouth and letting the drivel fly - there's not a lot of competition. Hence, the John McLaughry experience.

McLaughry heads the VT-based think tank called the Ethan Allen Institute:

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont's independent, nonpartisan, free-market-oriented public policy think tank. The Institute offers "Ideas for Vermont's Future" built upon a libertarian, decentralist, community-based philosophy. It is one of some 48 similar but independent state organizations associated with the State Policy Network.

Mission Statement:

The Mission of the Ethan Allen Institute is to influence public policy in Vermont by helping its people to better understand and put into practice the fundamentals of a free society: individual liberty, private property, competitive free enterprise, limited and frugal government, strong local communities, personal responsibility, and expanded opportunity for human endeavor.

It's your typical 'let the markets decide the fate of the human race; it knows what's best' organization. McClaughry's got that William-Buckley-wannabe vibe going on, and is the public face of the E.A. Institute. Come to think of it, he's pretty much the only face I ever seem to see from the institute. The board of directors includes such heavyweights(snicker) as Jack McMullen, the guy who ran against Senator Leahy a few years back and lost the primary to farmer Fred Tuttle.

McLaughry himself has a rather impressive resume, having worked in the Reagan administration, served on four presidential commissions, held office in the Vermont House and Senate, as well as has an unsuccessful run for governor under his belt. You can hear his commentaries on Vermont's contribution to the right-wing noise machine, True North Radio. And to his credit, McLaughry hasn't ever framed his positions from the theocratic angle (he is an intellectual, after all). So, all in all, he's a pretty smart guy, and I say that sincerely. So you could imagine the cognitive dissonance I was having after reading his's op-ed piece on global warming in the Times Argus a few weeks back entitled 'Warming Hysteria is Out of Whack' (subscription or payment required to view), that stated:

Virtually unnoticed by the news media, over 17,000 scientists and engineers - nearly 2,000 of them with degrees in meteorology and climatology - signed the 1997 Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine Kyoto Petition. Its punch line read: "There is no convincing scientific evidence that human release of carbon dioxide, methane or other greenhouse gases is causing or will, in the foreseeable future, cause catastrophic heating of the Earth's atmosphere and disruption of the Earth's climate."

...The post-1979 lower troposphere satellite microwave data corroborated by radiosonde balloons shows no alarming global warming trend.

See, there's a problem here, folks. McLaughry, in his fetish-like obsession with free-market fundamentalism, knows that Americans, and particularly right-wingers, are kind of lazy with checking the facts. Many see something that confirms their preconceptions, see it coming from some blowhard the represents an 'institute' (giving it an air of credibility), and then accept the premises, case closed. Too bad he's wrong, not to mention that quoting 30 year old studies on a modern, quickly-evolving problem is pretty friggin' lazy. Might as well use the Bible for a reference.

In this last Sunday's Times Argus, Dr. Alan K. Betts, a real scientist (unlike McLaughry, the political scientist) who is the president of Vermont Academy of Science and Engineering in Pittsford, contributed an article that completely demolished McLaughry's wishful thinking piece. Here are the major points:

1. McClaughry quotes "evidence" that the lower tropospheric satellite microwave data do not show an "alarming global warming trend." This is a dishonest fudge of the real scientific evidence. The data in question from Spencer and Christie (Science, 1990, and other papers that followed) were for many years inconsistent with the surface warming record, and this was widely repeated as "evidence" that warming was not occurring. A U.S. Climate Change Science Program panel was specifically set up and funded by the (skeptical) U.S. government to resolve the issue. They found the errors in the Spencer and Christie analyses, and now the data agree; and all show the warming that has occurred in the last 30 years (during which we have had satellite as well as surface data). Read their 2006 report at http://www.climatescience.gov/Library/sap/sap1-1/finalreport/sap1-1-final-execsum.pdf. Sadly, this definitive report is deliberately ignored by McClaughry, because of course the scientific evidence inconveniently disagrees with his political agenda. The repetition of false information is a well-known tool of propaganda, not science.

2. The argument that only a few percent of the greenhouse gases are from our industrial society is totally misleading. Water vapor is the biggest contributor to the greenhouse effect. Together all of the greenhouse gases warm the Earth to an average of 60 degrees Fahrenheit, which means the oceans don't freeze Fahrenheit, making life as we know it on this planet possible. It is what we are doing to this balance that matters. Although carbon dioxide contributes a smaller amount than water vapor to the greenhouse warming, carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is rising very rapidly (about 100 parts per million over the last century; and now rising at about 2 parts per million per year) driven by fossil fuel burning. The growth of other industrial gases in the atmosphere is also contributing to the greenhouse effect. The presence of water vapor, coupled with the earth's temperature, amplifies the effects of these additional greenhouse gases. McClaughry is implying that a few more degrees of warming isn't much to worry about (because he does not want carbon dioxide emissions to be regulated).

3. McClaughry points out that in 1997 thousands of scientists signed an anti-Kyoto petition (starting "We urge the United States government to reject the global warming agreement that was written in Kyoto") as part of a successful campaign by business-funded interests to stop the United States from agreeing to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions. Ten years have passed and it is now clear that we need reductions in greenhouse gases far greater than those of the Kyoto agreement, if we are to avoid huge economic costs, as recently outlined in the Stern Review by the British government.

Ouch. Perhaps McLaughry really believes those words of his anointed savior, Ronald Reagan: 'Facts are stupid things.' But it doesn't even take a scientist to see how McLaughry is piling on the bull, it just takes a little fact-checking, as evidenced by these letters to the editor in response to McLaughry's diatribe. R.D. Eno from Cabot:

Snarling and foaming, McClaughry as much as calls any climatologist who contends that manmade emissions are tilting the climate toward rapid and unnatural warming a liar. But the only evidence McClaughry cites in his surly little scree is a "petition" circulated in 1998 by the Oregon Institute of Science and Medicin that disputes the evidence for global warming, signed, says McClaughry, by 17,000 scientists, of whom 2,000 were meteriologists or climatologists. This "petition" is a hoary old hoax.

OISM is a one-man operation, much like the Ethan Allen Institute, run by Arthur Robinson, a biochemist with a sideline in books about how to survive a nuclear war. The study that the "petition" supposedly supports was written by Robinson, his son and a couple of astrophysicists, none of them climatologists. (One of the authors, Sallie L. Baliunas, is affiliated with nine ExxonMobil-funded groups, according to New Scientist.) Robinson formatted the study to mimic a National Academy of Science article and then flooded university mailboxes with copies and a card to be signed as an endorsement. But the study was never peer reviewed and has been discredited by the academy. The number of legitimate endorsements of Robinson's "petition" cannot be determined because credentials were not listed, but Scientific American, randomly sampling the signatories, estimated that "petition" supporters included only about 200 climate researchers. The OISM paper and "petition" represent flat-earth science at its worst. Trying to pass off this baloney as filet mignon might be called, to paraphrase McClaughry's bluster, ethically repellent dishonesty, but that would dignify it.

Ya' know, it takes more than the word 'institute' to have some credibility, John. How is anyone supposed to take you seriously when your cherry-picked sources are about as reliable as Dick Cheney's were for Iraq? If McLaughry's sloppily researched op-eds are the best the conservatives of Vermont have to offer, it's no wonder they're an endangered species in Vermont. But I'm not complaining.

Read More...

Saturday, December 23, 2006

Trans-fats and Reframing the Debate on Public Health Issues

Trans-fats, or those in partially hydrogenated oils, have been in the news a lot lately. New York City has taken the bold move of banning them in restaurants and Massachusetts is considering a statewide ban. As usual, when things like this happen, we hear drivel like this:

Cities should respect local businesses and allow the free market to continue to adjust to consumer demand. Instituting a New York-style ban would needlessly shock the market, triggering higher costs for consumers and removing flexibility for restaurant owners.
Ah yes, the free-market, performer of more miracles than Jesus or the Flying Spaghetti Monster. It's done a wonderful job with healthcare and affordable housing too, hasn't it? Anyways, when public-health legislation like this pops up (such as smoking bans in public places), the free-market fundies and certain libertarians love to pile on with the 'protecting us from ourselves' argument, calls of the 'food police' and the inevitable 'Big Brother'. And sadly, a lot of people buy into this crap.

I've always been a believer in the premise that, by and large, many Americans often don't do the right thing until we have no other choice. Many of us tend to be unable to grasp a 'bigger picture' in that we seem unable to grasp how our individual actions and choices affect the world around us. Unfortunately, because of the powerful industries pulling the governmental strings, the right thing doesn't get much of a chance. Consider fuel mileage standards, for example. Every time legislation is introduced to mandate higher mileage standards, we get the typical argument from the auto industry about how 'the market' is not calling for more fuel-efficient cars. 'People love their SUV's, so they're obviously not concerned about fuel efficiency'.

Know what? They are 100% right, many people don't really give a damn. So, by that logic, the hell with global warming, mideast oil wars and such? That's when the idea of the 'common good' needs to come into play. It blows my mind that, no matter what, the right of someone to make money always seems to trump my right to clean air and water or pristine wilderness or not having every corner of my mental environment cluttered with advertising.

The Difference Between Europe and America

Ok, so back to the trans-fat debate, and the common good. Truth: Americans are a bunch of fat-asses. (disclaimer for the PC thought police: the author himself badly needs to drop twenty pounds - so said my dietician) Obesity is a major, serious health problem in this country. The Center for Disease Control:
Overweight and obesity and their associated health problems have a significant economic impact on the U.S. health care system (USDHHS, 2001). Medical costs associated with overweight and obesity may involve direct and indirect costs (Wolf and Colditz, 1998; Wolf, 1998). Direct medical costs may include preventive, diagnostic, and treatment services related to obesity. Indirect costs relate to morbidity and mortality costs. Morbidity costs are defined as the value of income lost from decreased productivity, restricted activity, absenteeism, and bed days. Mortality costs are the value of future income lost by premature death.

According to a study of national costs attributed to both overweight (BMI 25–29.9) and obesity (BMI greater than 30), medical expenses accounted for 9.1 percent of total U.S. medical expenditures in 1998 and may have reached as high as $78.5 billion ($92.6 billion in 2002 dollars) (Finkelstein, Fiebelkorn, and Wang, 2003). Approximately half of these costs were paid by Medicaid and Medicare.
So, basically you and I are paying for people to have the 'right' to stuff their faces with a Big Mac. And that is where we need to focus our public health arguments, how peoples' poor choices affect all of us. The next time a right-winger frames as a 'freedom' issue, we need to turn around with statistics like these to illustrate this important principle. First, even though people have the 'right' to make their own food choices (or car choices or whatever), statistics such as the above show that they are clearly choosing the wrong choice in terms of the things that affect all of us (even those who go out of their way to make the right choices), time and time again. So there goes their argument that people know what's best for them. Some do, some don't, and some do but just don't care. Then, it is vital to point out the economic costs of the problem, and how that is affecting my economic freedom, because I'm having to pay for someone else's poor choices. Which is the greater harm?

If framed properly, even though it's not going to convince all of the right-wingers (it's really all about the money to them anyways- their profits, not our personal incomes ), it will shift the public perception of how those issues are framed, and hopefully we can make some progress. I thoroughly support people's choices to engage in harmful behavior; I engage in it quite often myself. But I don't support having to pay for someone else's poor choices, nor do I expect you to pay for mine. And the right-wingers seem to be all about rewarding what they see as good behavior (savvy investment choices, staying off welfare, abstaining from sex until marriage. whatever). Why shouldn't they support this? Well, like I said, ultimately it's about freedom, the freedom to make money. And although important, it needs to be kicked down a few notches on the 'ladder of freedoms', certainly below the rung of public health. They have controlled the debate for so long in this country that much of their bullshit is taken as conventional wisdom and to hell with the facts. It's time for us to change that.

ADDENDUM: I didn't think of it as I was writing this morning, but in the crosspost of this over at Daily Kos, the alternative idea of taxing instead of banning came up. Of course, it would still get attacked with the same arguments as a ban, but again, could easily be justified in the sense that, sure, you have the freedom to behave badly, but you're going to pick up the tab for it, not society. I could get behind that. That's why I support cigarette tax hikes, as long as the money is used to offset the public health costs. And as far as the argument that these kinds of takes are taxes on the poor, I don't buy it. Considering that the poor have some of the highest smoking rates and obesity rates, perhaps if they couldn't afford to behave unhealthy, they would do it less.

Read More...

Wednesday, October 11, 2006

Libertarian Democrats

I've always had a bit of a problem with Libertarians, kind of the same I have with ideological Socialists; their world view doesn't seem to take into account human nature or the way the world really works. Now, I am in total agreement with social libertarianism, it's just the economic part I've had a problem with, because it goes under the assumption that the free markets will somehow do the right thing if left unhindered by regulation. We don't need a USDA; selling bad meat is bad business, so they won't do it, or so the (il)logic goes. Somehow, I wouldn't find that comforting when I get E. coli from that uninspected hamburger. I think that's starting to change, as corporations now find themselves having more power than governments.

Markos, of Daily Kos fame, wrote the featured essay at the op-ed website of the libertarian think-tank the Cato Institute, called 'The Case for the Libertarian Democrat'. In it, he lays out a compelling case for libertarian support of the Democratic party, as the Republicans have abandoned much of what libertarians hold dear, and represent a great threat to freedom, and are too in bed with the corporations to offer any kind of protection from abuses of power. There's too many good points in the article to paraphrase here, so just go check it out here.

Even more refreshing than Kos' commentary is Harold Meyerson's commentary that is a response to Kos, called, 'Democrats, Liberals, and Libertarians.' He makes the telling point of Kos' idea being 'libertarianism for the real world':

..and more particularly in 21st-century America, encroachments on privacy, personal security, and the environment are as likely, if not more likely, to come from business as they are from the state, and these are threats that require state regulation if they’re to be mitigated or dispelled...
To argue, as a classic libertarian might, that a consumer is as free to switch banks as a bank is to sell its data neglects to note that a bank that doesn’t sell its data is at a competitive disadvantage with one that does, and a consumer who can’t find a privacy-protecting bank is simply out of luck. In short, the free play of markets can be a threat to individual freedom, unless individual freedom is a term that applies only to businesses and not to their consumers or employees or the people who must breathe their pollutants. This is something that New Deal liberals and social democrats have long understood and sought to redress. Indeed, the central insight of 20th century liberalism was that freedoms conflict, that a company’s freedom to dominate the marketplace was often in conflict with a consumer’s freedom to find a product at a fair price, or a worker's freedom to find a decent job or form a union, or a citizen’s freedom to have an equal voice in the legislative process. And that to establish some parity of freedoms, the state had to take a hand...
In short, as the balance of forces in capitalism shifts entirely towards investors and executives and away from employees, the need for a state that takes the burden of economic and health security off employers who won’t pick it up and employees who can’t pick it up is increasingly urgent. It’s hard to predict what exactly the tipping point will be as our private-sector welfare state continues to contract. But at some point, the Democrats will embrace a decisively larger role for the state in these matters because the public will demand it—not because the public will suddenly identify itself as liberal, but because there will be nowhere else to turn. And at that moment, I think even the Mountain State neo-libertarians will go along. After all, the New Deal didn’t arise because Americans suddenly awakened and proclaimed themselves progressive. It arose because the unchecked power and unregulated practices of major corporations and banks and the market itself led to an economic disaster.

Admittedly, Meyerson in no dyed-in-the-wool-Cato-fellow, he's a bit of a lefty, but damn it, he makes sense. Especially to me. I'm not in favor of some big nanny-state government; I don't believe that just because you're an American, you're entitled to a good life. But the tough-shit-you're-on-your-own mentality of many Repubs and Libertarians doesn't work for me either. What we're talking about here falls somewhere in between.

Read More...