click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!
Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts

Friday, March 30, 2007

Chocolate Jesus

No, it's not a blaxploitation flick, although I could just hear the promotion for it...'He's back, he's black, and he's gonna put some Holy Spirit in whitey's ass!'

Actually, from the best I could gather, it's about two chocolate Jesuses (or is it 'Jesi'?). There are two art exhibits opening up, one in the UK and one in NYC, during Holy Week (when the alleged resurrection of 'zombie Jesus' is celebrated). Both of them exhibits feature life-size sculptures of Jesus, made out of chocolate.

Of course, there's the obligatory Catholic outrage from none other than blowhard Bill Donohue, of the uber-conservative Catholic League. You may remember him as the one that started attacking John Edwards a few months back for hiring some bloggers who said some nasty things about Catholicism on their blogs. Of the chocolate Jesus, he whined,"This is one of the worst assaults on Christian sensibilities ever." Now putting aside for a minute the silliness of the words 'sensible', 'Christian', and 'Bill Donohue' all appearing in the same sentence, has he forgotten, is this really more of an assault than the Romans feeding Christians to the lions? And also, Catholics eat Jesus every Sunday at Holy Communion. What's the difference if they were eating Chocolate Jesus instead of that little piece of cardboard 'bread'? Heck, maybe if they were serving Chocolate Jesus, I would have gone to church more as a kid.

Seriously, I'm amazed at how quickly the Catholics love to whine even more than the fundies do with these things (perhaps it's because there's no sex involved). For a religion that used to pretty much literally rule the world, they really seem to be awfully insecure, whining with sanctimonious outrage every time something comes out which puts Jesus in a non-traditional perspective.

And is this chocolate Jesus-

any more offensive than this inflatable Jesus?

Nobody has complained about this chocolate Jesus. Are those little flecks of crisped rice? Blasphemy!:

Or what about Catholic Supply's hoops and football playing (and super Causcasian/Irish hippie) Jesuses? Isn't using God-magic cheating? C'mon, Jeez, they're only kids, fer Crissake.


Now here's a great idea for Easter: 'White Chocolate Jesus with Liquid Cherry Center.' Kids can prick the hands and feet to make their very own stigmata!

Oh, I get it... putting Jesus in ridiculous situations to make money from religious people... good, putting Jesus in a non-traditional context to make an artistic statement that may not be so nice... bad. Hypocrisy and lack of consistency seems to be the norm with a lot of these folks. I think that the artist of the UK Jesus, George Heslop, puts it best:
"Surely all the real human suffering in the world should be far more important than some argument about a chocolate effigy. But somehow these abstract symbols are treated with more respect than real world events."
Indeed.

Read More...

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

Christofascist Idiot Watch Update! Late Feb. edition

Is it just me or is the Religious Right a bit quieter since the November elections? Not quiet enough. A legislator in Tennessee is trying to force the creation vs. evolution debate into the forefront again, this time by having the state Education Commissioner answer, once and for all, whether there is a 'Supreme Being' that created the universe.

As the resolution is written, if Seivers does answer no to the first question - stating that the universe was not created by a Supreme Being - she would be offered "the General Assembly's admiration for being able to decide conclusively a question that has long perplexed and occupied the attention of scientists, philosophers, theologians, educators and others."

But if she answers yes, or states that the answer to the creation of the universe is uncertain, then there is a follow-up question that must also be answered: Why is creationism not being taught in Tennessee schools?

Wow, how clever. They still haven't gotten over that monkey trial thing down there, apparently. Or grasped the definition of the word, "science", for that matter:

Finney said there is no doubt in his own mind that everything in the universe, including human beings, was created by a Supreme Being.

"There has never been any proof offered that Darwin's theory of evolution is correct," he said.

Uh, okay. If you say so. Curious how the article also gives us the intertwining of the words 'creationism' and 'intelligent design'. I thought ID wasn't religious? Who knew?

Next up, WorldNut Daily is reporting of the heads exploding over the James Cameron documentary about the alleged Jesus tomb thing. Brent Bozell, head of the right-wing crybaby media watch group, Media Research Center:

"Now it's the 'tomb' of Jesus," Bozell said. "What they're really doing is attacking Christianity. The title of the documentary ought to be 'Discovery Channel Says Christianity Is a Fraud' – but they don't have the guts to say it."

Knight told WND that the danger is that people will believe what they see. "We saw this with the 'Da Vinci Code.' People bought into the alleged historical accuracy of claims, made even in a work of fiction, so when a documentary comes along, posing as objective critical analysis, that means more people will buy into the absurd and unproven premise that Jesus was just a man and that his earthly remains have been found."

He noted that the "leap" of logic the film forces viewers to make is beyond belief. "All they can tell us is that two of the caskets in the crypt held remains that were unrelated maternally, then they take the giant leap of logic that these two people were married and they were Jesus and Mary Magdalene."

Apparently , Bozell fails to mention the 'leap' of logic it requires to believe the 'unproven premises' such as a man was born of a virgin and subsequently rose from the dead. And the idea that somehow Christianity is immune to criticism and ridicule is par for the course, as well. Seeing how true believers are reacting to this makes me wonder out loud... what piece of irrefutable proof that solidly debunks the Christian mythology would ever be believed by these people? I'm not implying the tomb is the one, but I think no matter how compelling the evidence may be on these kinds of things, there is no way that people will ever accept them, for their worlds would come crashing down if they did.

Finally, over at Smirking Chimp, Mel Seesholtz has a rundown on fundamentalist homophobia and hypocrisy, 'ex-gay' therapy, the 'Left Behind' video game (where players get to kill the non-believers in bloody displays of Christian love and tolerance), and a host of other things that are indicating a lot of trouble in the ranks of the Religious Right, including their ever-diminishing influence. It's quite an extensive good read, so check it out: 'The Hypocritical Christian Right is being "Left Behind"

Happy Wednesday, everybody.

Read More...

Monday, February 26, 2007

The path to finding Jesus....


...may actually have been found, in an archaeological site in the Holy Land.

Although the evidence contained in the film and book is hardly definitive, it is compelling. Inscribed in Hebrew, Latin or Greek, six boxes — taken from a 2,000-year-old cave discovered in March, 1980, during excavation for a housing project in Talpiyot, south of Jerusalem — bear the names: Yeshua (Jesus) bar Yosef (son of Joseph); Maria (the Latin version of Miriam, which is the English Mary); Matia (the Hebrew equivalent of Matthew, a name common in the lineage of both Mary and Joseph); Yose; (the Gospel of Mark refers to Yose as a brother of Jesus); Yehuda bar Yeshua, or Judah, son of Jesus; and in Greek, Mariamne e mara — meaning 'Mariamne, known as the master.' According to Harvard professor Francois Bovon, interviewed in the film, Mariamne was Mary Magdalene's real name.

Nothing in the film or book challenges traditional Christian dogma regarding the resurrection. But it could pose a problem for those that believe Jesus' ascension, 40 days after the resurrection, was both physical and spiritual. And, if further DNA testing were to link Jesus and Yose with Mary, it would call into question the entire doctrine of the Virgin Birth.
I have mixed feelings about this. Most importantly, one cannot rule out fraud, as the issue of the James ossuary illustrates. But if it turns out to be true, what will be the implications? This is basically saying that Jesus got married and had a child, didn't rise from the dead, and wasn't born of a virgin. And I realize many of you reading this are probably thinking, 'Yeah, it's not like we believed those things anyway, what's the big deal?'

That's what I'm trying to figure out. There's pretty good odds that this could be for real, as Newsweek reports:

To calculate the odds, Mr. Jacobovici took the data to University of Toronto mathematician Dr. Andrey Feuerverger. Factoring in the commonality of these names in first-Century Israel, Dr. Feuerverger puts the odds of this tomb not belonging to Jesus and his family at one in 600.

Another estimate, commissioned by Dr. James Tabor, chair of the department of religion studies at the University of North Carolina, puts the odds at one in 42 million. "If you took the entire population of Jerusalem at the time," says Dr. Taber, "and put it in a stadium, and asked everyone named Jesus to stand up, you'd have about 2,700 men. Then you'd ask only those with a father named Joseph and a mother named Mary to remain standing. And then those with a brother named Yose and a brother named James. Statistically, you end up with one person."

But one can tell, even in the reporting, how much of a bombshell this could potentially be:

Good sense, and the Bible, still the best existing historical record of the life of Jesus of Nazareth, argue against Jacobovici's claims. All four Gospels say that Jesus was crucified on the eve of the Sabbath; all four say that the tomb was empty when the disciples woke on Sunday morning. "The New Testament is very clear on this," says Alan Segal, religion professor at Barnard College. "Jesus was put in a tomb that didn't belong to him and then he rose and there was nothing left."

"Good sense and the Bible?" Is Newsweek implying that doubting the historical accuracy of the Bible is somehow 'bad sense'? Are they implying that the resurrection is actually 'part of the historical record', as in 'actually happened?" So, if this story gets legs (as I'm sure it might be tough, considering how many reporters and news orgs won't want to touch this), be aware of the subtle spin that implies that the Bible is somehow accurate in all of this.

It will be interesting to see how true believers react to this. If they try to use it as proof of Jesus' existence, they're also going to have to accept that the supernatural stuff was a bunch of bunk. But it's not like that particular group tends to be swayed by 'facts'. They don't require evidence to believe what they do in the first place, so they might just ignore it. If it does turn out to be true, it's another argument to use against the literalists. I'll definitely be keeping an eye on this one.

UPDATE: More here.


Read More...

Thursday, February 8, 2007

Free Speech Alert: Something Smells Funny at the U.N.

I'm generally a supporter of the United Nations, and the concept behind it. I also understand why certain conservatives hate it so much. And I'm well aware it's not a perfect institution, understandable, considering the monumental task its purpose serves. I think if our government took it more seriously, we wouldn't be in this pickle we're in right now,and our standing in the world would be much higher than it currently is. Generally, I find most of what they do to be benign, and I'm certainly not afraid of some world government conspiracy horseshit like some wingers are. So, before you read on, know that I come from this as a liberal (if ornery)secular humanist who holds freedom of speech in the highest regard, not as some 'New World Order/black helicopters outside my window' kinda guy.

However, I came across something by science writer Ed Brayton at Dispatches from the Culture Wars that was quite disturbing. Apparently there has been a U.N Resolution proposed, for 'Combating the Defamation of Religions', voted on two years in a row, now (it's the first resolution on the page):

The Commission adopted by a roll-call vote a resolution on combating defamation of religions (E/CN.4/2004/L.5) by 29 in favour, 16 against, with 7 abstentions, by which it welcomed the report of the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of racism entitled “Situation of Muslim and Arab peoples in various parts of the world”; expressed deep concern at negative stereotyping of religions and manifestations of intolerance in some regions of the world; urged States to ensure equal access to education for all in law and in practice; expressed deep concern that Islam was frequently and wrongly associated with human rights violations and terrorism; noted with deep concern the intensification of the campaign of defamation of religions, and the ethnic and religious profiling of Muslim minorities in the aftermath of the tragic events of 11 September 2001; and expressed deep concern at programmes and agendas pursued by extremist organizations and groups aimed at the defamation of religions, in particular when supported by governments.

The Commission also urged all States, in conformity with international human rights instruments, to take all appropriate measures to combat hatred, discrimination, intolerance, and acts of violence motivated by religious intolerance; urged all States to ensure that all public officials in the course of their official duties respected different religions and did not discriminate on grounds of religion; strongly deplored physical attacks and assaults on businesses, cultural centres and places of worship of all religions; called upon the international community to initiate a global dialogue to promote a culture of tolerance based on respect for religious diversity; called upon the High Commissioner for Human Rights to promote and include human rights aspects in the Dialogue among Civilizations; and requested the Special Rapporteur to examine the situation of Muslim and Arab peoples in various parts of the world with special reference to physical assaults and attacks against their places of worship, cultural centres, businesses and properties in the aftermath of the events of 11 September 2001 and to submit a progress report on his findings to the Commission at its sixty-first session.
Now, at first glance it seems like there are some noble aims here, for example, preventing discrimination of religion and such. And it was obviously drafted in part, to concerns from Muslim nations. The Western nations and a few others voted against it. Ironically, many of the nations in support of it have abysmal human rights and tolerance records, as Brayton points out:
All Middle Eastern states except Israel voted for the resolution? Can that be serious? We're going to ask the opinion of Saudi Arabia, where schools routinely teach that Jews and Christians are pigs worthy of death, whether we should pass a law forbidding the defamation of religion? We're going to ask nations full of people who burn down synagogues over cartoons drawn halfway around the world and who believe that someone who converts from Islam to Christianity should be put to death whether religions can be criticized? We're supposed to care what China, a nation that has all but destroyed Tibetan Buddhism and routinely locks up and tortures Christians and Muslims, thinks about our laws on religious freedom?
Now, although I don't necessarily agree with Brayton's sweeping over-generalization of Muslims (much like Sam Harris does), but he does have a point. I couldn't find Israel's name under the yeah, nay, or the abstention, so I'm unclear as to where the notion of where Israel stands on this. Last May, Dr . Robert Freeman wrote some crazy stuff in an op/ed the Jewish Times, shortly after the Danish cartoon controversy:

In order to rectify the situation, and to prevent a future crisis of this type from erupting, what is needed is a "code of conduct" for the newspapers and other media in both the Western and Muslim worlds. All governments must agree that the negative depiction of religion is "out of bounds," and penalties should be imposed on those who violate the code of conduct.

The problem, of course, is to determine the difference between legitimate criticism of someone who acts in the name of a religion, and the negative depiction of that religion.

To solve that problem, I propose the creation of an International Religious Court, composed of Christian, Muslim and Jewish clergymen with one clergyman representing each of the three religions. Anyone feeling that his or her religion was insulted could appeal to the International Religious Court for a ruling on the matter, and the court would then determine whether a penalty should be invoked. It would be the responsibility of the government on whose territory the action took place to impose the penalty.

Now, this is a touchy subject, aside from political correctness issues that some may have with it. This is one of those rare issues that many people on the left and the right are in support of, although for different reasons and different perspectives. You can easily see that in one of the links that he links to... it's a rightie whose opposition comes not only from free speech issues but equally rooted in that right-wing distaste for all things U.N. But he does make a good point:
Prohibiting the dissemination of xenophobic ideas aimed at any religion that constitute incitement to hostility — sounds like a pretty broad proposition. It would cover many atheist criticisms of religion generally; many secularist criticisms of fundamentalist Christianity (or Islam or Judaism); condemnation of religious groups that are alleged to be cults or scams; many theological criticisms of a wide range of religions; many pro-gay-rights or pro-women's-rights condemnations of religions that are seen as hostile to gays or women; and much more.
And that, regardless of where your ideological chips fall, is not a good place for us to be in. And once again it ties into that whole modern, outspoken atheist thing that Harris, Dawkins, and (rather feebly) I keep trying to get out there: why should religion be exempt from criticism? Let me be very clear: as much as I have a distaste for all things religion, I would never support any violence or discrimination in any way against any one because of their religion, any more than I would based on their race, gender, sexual orientation or other things of that nature.

But as you well know, some religious people believe some pretty crazy things, sometimes harmful, sometimes harmless, but nonetheless irritating, They are not immune from being asked to defend their claims and belief, and yes, uncivil as it may seem, they are not immune to criticism or even ridicule. It doesn't say anywhere in the Constitution about having the right not to be offended. It's a really slippery slope to slide down if something like this were to be implemented, and this is one of those instances that I think, although there are good intentions behind it, the U.N. is wrong on this one.

Read More...