click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!
Showing posts with label intelligent design. Show all posts
Showing posts with label intelligent design. Show all posts

Friday, March 9, 2007

Common sense from Idaho

I don't really know much about Idaho other than the fact that a lot of potatoes come from there, it's pretty white, and it seems to be a hotbed of far-right militia-lookout-for-the-black-helicopter types. I could be wrong. Anyways, I was surprised and pleased to read at the 'Americans United for Church and State' blog that Intelligent Design got the big 'no' from the science teachers:

Recently the Idaho Science Teachers Association (ISTA) stood up for science education and church-state separation by declaring that “intelligent design,” the latest variant of creationism, has no place in science class.

“In a public school setting we are charged with teaching methodology that’s been approved by the scientific community,” said Rick Alm, ISTA president. “It basically would be unethical to teach creation science or intelligent design because it is not science, and it does not belong in a science classroom.”

Alm added that his group is not “taking a position against religion; it’s just under the context of the law and public school setting, religion has its place, and it’s not in our science classroom.”

I think I'll have some Idaho Russets for dinner tonight.

Read More...

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

Christofascist Idiot Watch Update! Late Feb. edition

Is it just me or is the Religious Right a bit quieter since the November elections? Not quiet enough. A legislator in Tennessee is trying to force the creation vs. evolution debate into the forefront again, this time by having the state Education Commissioner answer, once and for all, whether there is a 'Supreme Being' that created the universe.

As the resolution is written, if Seivers does answer no to the first question - stating that the universe was not created by a Supreme Being - she would be offered "the General Assembly's admiration for being able to decide conclusively a question that has long perplexed and occupied the attention of scientists, philosophers, theologians, educators and others."

But if she answers yes, or states that the answer to the creation of the universe is uncertain, then there is a follow-up question that must also be answered: Why is creationism not being taught in Tennessee schools?

Wow, how clever. They still haven't gotten over that monkey trial thing down there, apparently. Or grasped the definition of the word, "science", for that matter:

Finney said there is no doubt in his own mind that everything in the universe, including human beings, was created by a Supreme Being.

"There has never been any proof offered that Darwin's theory of evolution is correct," he said.

Uh, okay. If you say so. Curious how the article also gives us the intertwining of the words 'creationism' and 'intelligent design'. I thought ID wasn't religious? Who knew?

Next up, WorldNut Daily is reporting of the heads exploding over the James Cameron documentary about the alleged Jesus tomb thing. Brent Bozell, head of the right-wing crybaby media watch group, Media Research Center:

"Now it's the 'tomb' of Jesus," Bozell said. "What they're really doing is attacking Christianity. The title of the documentary ought to be 'Discovery Channel Says Christianity Is a Fraud' – but they don't have the guts to say it."

Knight told WND that the danger is that people will believe what they see. "We saw this with the 'Da Vinci Code.' People bought into the alleged historical accuracy of claims, made even in a work of fiction, so when a documentary comes along, posing as objective critical analysis, that means more people will buy into the absurd and unproven premise that Jesus was just a man and that his earthly remains have been found."

He noted that the "leap" of logic the film forces viewers to make is beyond belief. "All they can tell us is that two of the caskets in the crypt held remains that were unrelated maternally, then they take the giant leap of logic that these two people were married and they were Jesus and Mary Magdalene."

Apparently , Bozell fails to mention the 'leap' of logic it requires to believe the 'unproven premises' such as a man was born of a virgin and subsequently rose from the dead. And the idea that somehow Christianity is immune to criticism and ridicule is par for the course, as well. Seeing how true believers are reacting to this makes me wonder out loud... what piece of irrefutable proof that solidly debunks the Christian mythology would ever be believed by these people? I'm not implying the tomb is the one, but I think no matter how compelling the evidence may be on these kinds of things, there is no way that people will ever accept them, for their worlds would come crashing down if they did.

Finally, over at Smirking Chimp, Mel Seesholtz has a rundown on fundamentalist homophobia and hypocrisy, 'ex-gay' therapy, the 'Left Behind' video game (where players get to kill the non-believers in bloody displays of Christian love and tolerance), and a host of other things that are indicating a lot of trouble in the ranks of the Religious Right, including their ever-diminishing influence. It's quite an extensive good read, so check it out: 'The Hypocritical Christian Right is being "Left Behind"

Happy Wednesday, everybody.

Read More...

Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Now Pander Bear McCain's with the Creationists

Think Progress is reporting that John McCain, in his perpetual bend-over for the GOP nomination, is delivering the keynote address to the Discovery Institute, the think-tank most responsible for getting the intelligent design assault on science into the public sphere. Problem is, like just about everything else McCain says nowadays, it's the opposite of what he's said in the past. Today:

McCain has an ambiguous record on whether he supports intelligent design in the science curriculum. In 2005, he said it should be taught:

Daily Star: Should intelligent design be taught in schools?

McCain: I think that there has to be all points of view presented. But they’ve got to be thoroughly presented. So to say that you can only teach one line of thinking I don’t think is - or one belief on how people and the world was created - I think there’s nothing wrong with teaching different schools of thought.

Daily Star: Does it belong in science?

McCain: There’s enough scientists that believe it does. I’m not a scientist. This is something that I think all points of view should be presented.

Last year:
“I think Americans should be exposed to every point of view,” he said. “I happen to believe in evolution…I respect those who think the world was created in seven days. Should it be taught as a science class? Probably not.“
About the only thing he's got going for him at this point is the people he's trying to pander to tend not to pay too much attention to hypocrisy, inconsistency, and fact-checking. Keep digging that hole, John. Gonna play well with the swing voters.

Read More...

Thursday, January 25, 2007

Dumb All Over, January Edition

A few weeks ago, I let you know about a dimwitted Christianist named Frosty Hardison in Washington state who got his panties in a wad when his daughter was shown Al Gore's global warming documentary, 'An Inconvenient Truth', because "The Bible says that in the end times everything will burn up, but that perspective isn't in the DVD." Yeah, dumb, I know.

Sadly, it's not over, because the science teacher was disciplined for not alerting parents that their student would be viewing something 'controversial'. Well, the good news is that there's been a backlash...

Members of the school board say they have been bombarded by thousands of e-mails and phone calls, many of them hurtful and obscene, accusing them of scientific ignorance, pandering to religion and imposing prior restraint on free speech....

In public comments at the board meeting, several riled-up Federal Way residents argued that "An Inconvenient Truth" was, indeed, scientifically true and that saying otherwise is "deliberate obfuscation."

These residents derisively compared the search for "balance" in the global-warming issue to decades of phony claims by cigarette companies about the lack of "proof" that smoking is harmful to human health.

Yep, it's all about 'balance', I guess. Just look at those mountains of tangible evidence the Holocaust deniers use, right? Good luck on that one...

His daughter's science teacher, meanwhile, said she is struggling to find authoritative articles to counter the information in the Gore documentary.

"The only thing I have found so far is an article in Newsweek called 'The Cooling World,' " Walls said.

It was written 37 years ago.

I think it was Dawkins who said, 'Every one is entitled to their own opinion. They're not entitled to their own set of facts.' This case is a classic example of how this man should be publicly ridiculed because of the crap he's slinging. There's no way around it. Meanwhile, say goodbye to the glaciers in the Alps.

I've mentioned it before. We constantly hear when parents got up in arms when their kids are taught science in school that contradicts their fairytale beliefs about what really happened. Ed Brayton, over at 'Dispatches from the Cultural Wars', when speaking of this 'parents always know best' phenomenon, nails it on the head:

But legal issues are not decided on what taxpayers like or dislike, nor should they be. If you put up for a vote what should be taught in public schools, the results would be frightening. And why should such a thing be put to a vote? Why would we give credence to someone to make a judgment on what ought to be taught in a science classroom if they know little or nothing about science? We don't put medical diagnoses up for a vote of the public, nor do we take straw polls to decide what is wrong when our car doesn't work, we defer to the judgment of those trained in medicine or auto mechanics because they have a far better chance of actually knowing what they're talking about.

The same is true in matters of science or history or mathematics, which just like auto mechanics or medicine require a good deal of study and expertise in order to be understood. Asking the general public to decide what ought to be taught in a class in which the vast majority of them would have a vanishingly small chance of passing a mid-term exam is as absurd as asking the janitors at the hospital the best course of treatment for a herniated disk; they simply do not have the knowledge required to make an informed choice.

And so the battle rages on.

Read More...

Thursday, October 12, 2006

More good news...

...on the War Against Stupidity. The Michigan Board of Education has approved public school curriculum guidelines that support the teaching of evolution in science classes, but not intelligent design.

"The intent of the board needs to be very clear," said board member John Austin, an Ann Arbor Democrat. "Evolution is not under stress. It is not untested science."
Good news.

Read More...

Thursday, April 6, 2006

A Missing Link...

No, it's not a story about the origins of our president.. something way better. The New York Times is reporting that scientists have found the fossil remains of a 375 million year old fish. Ok, you say, they find fossils all the time. Here's what's special about this one:

"In two reports today in the journal Nature, a team of scientists led by Neil H. Shubin of the University of Chicago say they have uncovered several well-preserved skeletons of the fossil fish in sediments of former streambeds in the Canadian Arctic, 600 miles from the North Pole.

The skeletons have the fins, scales and other attributes of a giant fish, four to nine feet long. But on closer examination, the scientists found telling anatomical traits of a transitional creature, a fish that is still a fish but has changes that anticipate the emergence of land animals — and is thus a predecessor of amphibians, reptiles and dinosaurs, mammals and eventually humans.

In the fishes' forward fins, the scientists found evidence of limbs in the making. There are the beginnings of digits, proto-wrists, elbows and shoulders. The fish also had a flat skull resembling a crocodile's, a neck, ribs and other parts that were similar to four-legged land animals known as tetrapods."

Here's the best part (for me, anyways):

"Other scientists said that in addition to confirming elements of a major transition in evolution, the fossils were a powerful rebuttal to religious creationists, who have long argued that the absence of such transitional creatures are a serious weakness in Darwin's theory."

Now, as far as transitional fossils, we already have archaeopteryx, a bird-like creature with reptilian features. Since that doesn't fit in with the creation scientist's viewpoint, it has been dismissed by creationists. How many more transitional fossils will it take? Have a look at that creation science link to get an idea of the stunning lack of logic and critical thinking we're dealing with. And then remember that this mindset is dicatating much of American policy right now. Scared yet?

As a side note, I want to make clear that snarkiness aside, I do find great value in this discovery, not just as another stick in the eye of the creationists, but as an important discovery in the realms of understanding the origins of life here on our planet. I am in awe of it. And the fish thing looks really cool, too. Nothing I'd want to get chased by while mountain biking down by the river.

Read More...

Saturday, March 4, 2006

Science and the Art of Language


When discussing the 'intelligent design' debate, one idea I've beaten to death is that scientists have a looooooooooooooooooong way to go in explaining and clarifying science and its methods to the layman. It would go a long way to diffusing the mistrusted 'ivory tower' elitist image that so many people have regarding scientists. For a great example of how this should be done, read Dr. Penny Higgins' article "Why Intelligent Design is not Science and therefore, Should Not Be Taught in a Science Curriculum"

Clear, plain language. No condescending tone, a la Dawkins. But most importantly, not 'dumbed down' either. Give it a read.


Read More...

Friday, February 24, 2006

A bit more on ID and 'teaching the controversy'

As some of you know who have been following the 'intelligent design' debate (the notion being pushed by certain Christianists that evolution has too many holes and must have been guided by an intelligent designer, i.e. 'God'), one of the methods they've been using to get the idea taught in schools is that in the name of academic freedom and inquiry, we should be 'teaching the controversy', which is a not-so-subtle method of sowing the seeds of doubt of evolution's validity.

There's a bit of a problem though; amongst the scientific community, there really isn't a controversy. Scientists will readily admit that sure, there are still many things in evolutionary theory yet to be discovered. But a solid majority of them put evolution as the bedrock of biology. CSICOP's Robert Camp has a good article about this phenomenon here, as well as some surveying that helps prove his point.

One of the main problems I see in the way debates are framed today is this so called 'balanced view' approach. It goes under the assumption that A) all opinions are equal and B) that there are always two sides to every issue. It's like saying that in order to teach a class on Holocaust studies, we must also teach the viewpoints of Holocaust deniers. Sure, everyone is entitled to an opinion. But they don't all carry equal weight. Some can be backed up by mountains of evidence (evolution, the Holocaust) and some can't (ID theory, Holocaust denial).

This is even more obvious in today's political reporting. Take something like Bush's numerous tax cuts for the wealthy. The evidence is all there on paper as to whom these tax cuts are benefitting(the top 1%). Yet when discussed in the media, both sides are shown, as if they are somehow doing us a favor by letting us decide for ourselves, even though the facts are there for all to see.

Often, I read in letters to the editors and such, how ID should be taught alongside evolution to let the students (or parents of the students) decide. Since when do high school students (or their parents, for that matter) know more than the biologists? Most people can't even name their congressman, for Crissake.

Yes, there are often two sides to an issue; a correct one and an incorrect one. But teaching something that is factually incorrect is wrong, pure and simple.

Read More...

Friday, December 30, 2005

Behold His Noodly Appendage!

I'm probably(as always) behind the times here, but have you heard about the Flying Spaghetti Monster? This is a real hoot, a creation of Oregon resident Bobby Henderson, in response to the current so-called intelligent design idiocy that the nation is currently dealing with(one of many).

He espouses another alternative ID theory, that the world was created by the aforementioned FSM. He's gone so far as to write to members of the reality-challenged Kansas school board(the ones that are putting ID in the public schools now, ensuring that no Kansas high shool graduate will ever go to M.I.T. or Yale). In his letter, he threatens legal action if FSMID(Flying Spaghetti Monster Intelligent Design) isn't taught alongside evolution and that other ID theory. Apparently this is more well known than I thought, it even got a mention on CNN. The funniest thing about the site is the 'hate mail' page. Some of the insanity includes many letters from Christians speaking of bad things they'd like to do to Mr. Henderson that are decidedly un-Christian(or maybe not, there was that little Inquisition thing a while back). There's also quite a few from people that really believe that this is all for real. Their intelligence is astounding. Is 'ur' some hip new red state way of spelling 'you're'?

As one who closely follows the doings of good ol' Christian wingnuttery, I've been following the ID debacle quite closely. Not like you'd care, but I even wrote a paper on it for my class last semester. It is truly amazing how little that people understand science. This has many angles, of course. I feel scientists could do a much better job of explaining science(and the scientific method in particular) to Joe Six-pack. It's not an easy task, because it requires a bit of an attention span-maybe if they could somehow 'sex it up' and put some boobs on it, it would finally get to the masses.

But it's not so simple. For example, let's look at the 'Daubert Criteria'(thanks to Wikipedia):

In its 1993 Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals opinion, the United States Supreme Court articulated a set of criteria for the admissibility of scientific expert testimony, in effect developing their own demarcation criteria. The Daubert Standard governs which evidence can be considered scientific in United States federal courts and most state courts. The four Daubert criteria are:


  • The theoretical underpinnings of the methods must yield testable predictions by means of which the theory could be falsified.

  • The methods should preferably be published in a peer-reviewed journal.

  • There should be a known rate of error that can be used in evaluating the results.

  • The methods should be generally accepted within the relevant scientific community.

Ok, I'm sure you got the gist of that, now can you think of a way to put that in a CNN blurb that can get the point across in just a few minutes? See what I mean? That's part of the problem.

Of course, when one is guided by faith, especially that of one who believes the Bible is the infallible word of God, and to be made aware of and to have one’s children be taught something that shakes the core of their worldview and belief system is not an easy thing to deal with, and were I on that side of the fence, I would be doing the same thing. However, as much as I understand it, I am by no means sympathetic; no one is forcing them to hold onto their anachronistic belief system. They cross the line when they try to force something faith-based into the world of the fact-based, in order to justify their beliefs.

Scientists can and should do more to make science more accessible to the public. They are never going to be able to convince the fundamentalists. They don’t require ‘evidence’ to believe what they believe, so the presentation of more evidence will not change anything.


There's been a major victory for reason though. The Dover, Pennsylvania ID case has been ruled unconstitutional. Although it's a bit lengthy, I highly recommend reading the ruling by federal judge John Jones. You can read it here. Let's just say, he gives us one of those 'he says what we all aready know and have been thinking since this whole thing started' moments:

'In summary, the disclaimer singles out the theory of evolution for special treatment, misrepresents its status in the scientific community, causes students to doubt its validity without scientific justification, presents students with a religious alternative masquerading as a scientific theory, directs them to consult a creationist text as though it were a science resource, and instructs students to forego scientific inquiry in the public school classroom and instead to seek out religious instructions elsewhere.' (p. 49)

'After a searching review of the record and applicable case law, we find that while ID arguments may be true, a proposition on which the Court takes no position, ID is not science. We find that ID fails on three different levels, any one of which is sufficient to preclude a determination that ID is science. They are (1) ID violates the centuries-old ground rules of science by invoking an permitting supernatural causation; (2) the argument of irreducible complexity, central to ID, employs the same flawed an illogical contrived dualism that doomed creation science in the 1980’s; and (3) ID’s negative attacks on evolution have been refuted by the scientific community. As we will discuss in more detail below, it is additionally important to note that ID has failed to gain acceptance in the scientific community, it has not generated peer-reviewed publications, nor has it been the subject of testing and research. (p. 64)

And what he says about the board member ringleaders:

Finally, although Buckingham, Bonsell, and other defense witnesses denied the reports in the news media and contradicted the great weight of the evidence about what transpired at the June 2004 Board meetings, the record reflects that these witnesses either testified inconsistently, or lied outright under oath on several occasions, and are accordingly not credible on these points. (p. 105)

and with a sharp uppercut to the jaw:

As we will discuss in more detail below, the inescapable truth is that both Bonsell and Buckingham lied at their January 3, 2005 depositions about their knowledge of the source of the donation for Pandas, which likely contributed to Plaintiffs’ election not to seek a temporary restraining order at that time based upon a conflicting and incomplete factual record. This mendacity was a clear and deliberate attempt to hide the source of the donations by the Board President and the Chair of the Curriculum Committee to further ensure that Dover students received a creationist alternative to Darwin’s theory of evolution. We are accordingly presented with further compelling evidence that Bonsell and Buckingham sought to conceal the blatantly religious purpose behind the ID policy. (p. 115)

The people of Dover are quite pissed about being the laughingstock of the nation(well, actually that would be Dubya, but he's getting so dangerous it's not so funny anymore). An op-ed in one of their newspaper even hoped that perjury charges would be filed against the board members.

ID proponents remind me of the hardcore Bushevik supporters; they keep citing the same old discredited shit and hope you won't notice. A day or two before the ruling, a writer to my local paper was citing the whole much-discredited Michael Behe irreduccible complexity crap. And there are still WMD's in Iraq... and O.J. is still looking for the real killers.

The Flying Spaghetti Monster might be getting some competition...

Coming up....
The Musical Saga of John D. Ryan
and...
Is it time to take the gloves off when confronted with irrational belief systems in regards to public issues?


Read More...