click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!
Showing posts with label sam harris. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sam harris. Show all posts

Thursday, January 18, 2007

Harris vs. Sullivan

Interesting email debate between Sam Harris and conservative blogger Andrew Sullivan here.

And, no, I haven't forgotten my second part of my Sam Harris critique. Don't worry, it's coming.

Read More...

Monday, January 8, 2007

The Problem With Sam Harris, pt. 1

Ok, as many of you who frequent this site know, I like to quote Sam Harris; what attracts me about him is his basic premise that religious beliefs should be held up to the same scrutiny as any other human phenomenon. If you think about it for a minute, it's not really that radical of a concept. But, as his message and bestselling book, "The End of Faith" (TEoF), have made their rounds and spread his message, there is much to criticize in some of what Harris has said in his book. The two criticisms I'm hoping to address (in two parts, as to not overwhelm and to make sure I do my homework) are Harris' apparent embrace of Eastern mysticism and psychic abilities, and Harris' Islamophobia, intolerance and support of torture. For a few articles to give you some background on the criticism, go here, and here.

Chapter 7 of TEoF is called 'Experiments in Consciousness', and is arguably the most open-minded section of the book. Harris basically asserts that there is still much to be learned in defining what we know as 'consciousness', and that in some ways, spirituality is a way of investigating the nature of consciousness:

"The history of human spirituality is the history to explore and modify the deliverances of consciousness through methods like fasting , chanting, sensory deprivation, prayer, meditation, and the use of psychotropic plants. There is no question that experiments of this sort can be conducted in a rational manner. Indeed, they are some of our only means of determining to what extent the human condition can be deliberately transformed. Such an enterprise becomes irrational only when people begin making claims about the world that cannot be supported by empirical evidence." (p 210, TEoF)

Now, in some of the criticism one can find about Harris', a recurring theme is that somehow he is being inconsistent by being open to the possibilities of psychic phenomena such as ESP, and that he believes that the construction of the 'self' is quite possibly an illusion (which is consistent with many Eastern mystic belief systems). Meera Nanda over at the New Humanist:
"Harris describes the mystical experience as tuning, or focusing, the mind through meditation, fasting, chanting, sensory deprivation or psychotropic drugs, that enables it to overcome, or dissolve, the sense of the self that stands separate from the objects of its consciousness. The goal is to “experience the world perfectly shorn of self… to lose the subject/object perception… to continue to experience the world, but without the feeling that there is a knower standing apart form the known. Thoughts may arise, but the feeling that one is a thinker of these thoughts vanishes. Harris is describing the classic all-is-one and one-is-all experience that mystics and spiritualists have reported throughout history."
I take issue with Nanda's problem with the 'loss of self'... it is a very conservative perspective that I feel is deeply rooted in the fear of the loss of individuality. Harris:
"As a mental phenomenon, loss of self is not as rare as our scholarly neglect of it suggests. This experience is characterized by a sudden loss of subject/object perception: the continuum of experience remains, but one no longer feels that there is a knower standing apart from the know. Thoughts may arise, but the feeling that one is the thinker of these thoughts have vanished" (TEoF, p.212)
Last semester, as I did my research for a paper on the use of entheogenic (psychotropic) plants in native cultures, this theme of 'depersonalization' (brought on by the consumption of plants, in that case) was a common theme. Psychologists found the use of psychedelics a huge breakthrough, in part because of the ability to seemingly break down the ego, and it showed promising therapeutic possibilities, which sadly came to an end after the criminalization of them in the mid-60's. So, I don't think that Harris, in embracing this possibility, is going out on a limb here. He is showing an open mind that, unfortunately is lacking in some of his other arguments in the book.

I don't believe that any of the critics that I've read have read Harris' rebuttal to Tom Flynn's criticisms in Free Inquiry magazine last year:
"The hypothesis is this: if I use my attention in the prescribed way, it may have a specific, reproducible effect. Needless to say, what happens (or fails to happen) along any path of “spiritual” practice has to be interpreted in light of some conceptual scheme, and everything must remain open to rational discussion. How this discussion proceeds will ultimately be decided by contemplative scientists. As I said in my book, if we ever develop a mature science of the mind, most of our religious texts will be no more useful to mystics than they now are to astronomers.

What words should we use to acknowledge the fact that the happiest person on this earth at this moment might have spent the last twenty years living alone in a cave? Any experienced meditator knows that this is a serious possibility. (Indeed, I consider it not only possible, but likely.) What can we say about the fact that the conventional sources of human happiness—association with family and friends, positive engagement with society, diverse experiences of physical pleasure, etc.—might be neither necessary nor sufficient to produce happiness in its most profound forms? This is not New Age mumbo jumbo. What secularists like Flynn tend not to realize is that there are genuine, introspective insights that can be terribly difficult to acquire. The lack of general accessibility does not render such insights at all suspect...

I also took considerable heat from Flynn for a few remarks I made about the nature of consciousness. Most atheists appear to be certain that consciousness is entirely dependent upon (and reducible to) the workings of the brain. In the last chapter of the book, I briefly argue that this certainty is unwarranted. I say this as one who is deeply immersed in the neuroscientific and philosophical literature on consciousness: the truth is that scientists still do not know what the relationship between consciousness and matter is. I am not in the least suggesting that we make a religion out of this uncertainty, or do anything else with it. Needless to say, the mysteriousness of consciousness does nothing to make conventional religious notions about God and paradise any more plausible."
I like to think I have a somewhat perceptive bullshit detector. In reading that chapter in question, I didn't take away from it any sense of Harris 'jumping the fence', so to speak. Harris is simply expressing an openness to some of the unanswered questions out there, whether it be ESP (which is something that, although the 'scientific jury' is not solidified, there are many legitimate scientists that believe in its possibilities, just that we haven't enough info yet), or the insights brought on by meditation. Harris isn't attributing these things to supernatural causes by any means. As I see it, he's just open to some ideas to which we don't have answers to yet.

I didn't have much of an issue with Harris on this subject. However, I DO have some serious reservations about Harris and intolerance, and an overestimation of the negative impacts of religion. I'll have that coming up in part 2, later this week.

Read More...

Sunday, December 24, 2006

Some Sam Harris for you, just in time for the holiday.

Sam Harris has a great article in today's L.A. Times: '10 Myths - and 10 Truths About Atheism'. he goes through the most often heard accusations about atheists, and sets them to rest in a frank, honest, and straightforward manner. A good one, in response to 'atheism is dogmatic':

Jews, Christians and Muslims claim that their scriptures are so prescient of humanity's needs that they could only have been written under the direction of an omniscient deity. An atheist is simply a person who has considered this claim, read the books and found the claim to be ridiculous. One doesn't have to take anything on faith, or be otherwise dogmatic, to reject unjustified religious beliefs. As the historian Stephen Henry Roberts (1901-71) once said: "I contend that we are both atheists. I just believe in one fewer god than you do. When you understand why you dismiss all the other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours."

Read More...

Monday, November 27, 2006

Monday Musings

Well, it's official: I am pretty much useless on Mondays. I've come to this conclusion after observing my behavior of the last few Mondays, whether it be housecleaning, homework, blogging, whatever. I don't seem to get shit done. No point in fighting it, I guess. So for your enjoyment, a small Monday linkdump.

Odum over at Green Mountain Daily has a good piece on Instant Runoff Voting, as well as some of the alternatives.

David Sirota has some interesting musings on the huge disconnect between the DC punditry and the rest of the nation, here.

And finally, if you have the time (it's a bit long), check out this excellent debate between Sam Harris and Dennis Prager, called, 'Why Are Atheists So Angry?'. Great stuff.

Read More...

Monday, November 6, 2006

Sam Harris in Newsweek

As I sit here in the home stretch, the night before election day, I seriously wonder if I'll be able to function at all tomorrow, which is important because I have a lot of non-political related things to do. I said to Jenni earlier that I wish I could just go camping tomorrow all day and night and not come back 'till Wednesday night. No such luck.

Anyways, the cover story on the new Newsweek is 'The Politics of Jesus'. The 'Evangelical Identity Crisis' article is pretty interesting, in that it talks about the growing number of Christians, evangelicals in particular, that are increasingly concerned with the lack of social-justice issues in the religious right's political movement. Granted, I still wish religion would stay the hell out of politics completely, but I can't deny that this is at least a step in the right direction. Now if they would just stop obsessing about blatocysts and who's putting what in who's orifice, they'd make some real progress.

Better, though is an article in the same issue from Sam Harris, 'A Dissent: The Case Against Faith':

"Despite a full century of scientific insights attesting to the antiquity of life and the greater antiquity of the Earth, more than half the American population believes that the entire cosmos was created 6,000 years ago. This is, incidentally, about a thousand years after the Sumerians invented glue. Those with the power to elect presidents and congressmen—and many who themselves get elected—believe that dinosaurs lived two by two upon Noah's Ark, that light from distant galaxies was created en route to the Earth and that the first members of our species were fashioned out of dirt and divine breath, in a garden with a talking snake, by the hand of an invisible God....This is embarrassing.
Religion is the one area of our discourse in which people are systematically protected from the demand to give good evidence and valid arguments in defense of their strongly held beliefs. And yet these beliefs regularly determine what they live for, what they will die for and—all too often—what they will kill for. Consequently, we are living in a world in which millions of grown men and women can rationalize the violent sacrifice of their own children by recourse to fairy tales..."

Now to those of you familiar with Harris, this will sound familiar, nothing he hasn't said before, no big deal. But I think the fact that it's in a major newsweekly is a big deal. I've mentioned in other entries about how atheist books are topping the bestseller lists and such, and the poll that shows an abnormally high number of Americans uncertain about God's existence. What I think we're seeing here is the beginning of a ripple, in that I suspect many, many Americans have doubts about the existence of a divine, all-knowing, judgmental creator. We see evidence every day that doesn't jive with what we're told to believe. And I think that maybe, just maybe, some people are starting to feel more emboldened to express that doubt, instead of giving a polite, vague answer.

Read More...

Wednesday, September 20, 2006

More on Sam Harris

I was digging around yesterday and found a new op-ed by Sam Harris in the LA Times, called, 'Head-in-the-Sand-Liberals'. Sam, after laying out his bona fide liberal creds, lays out his case for how liberals by and large don't get how dangerous Muslim extremism really is.
"Given the degree to which religious ideas are still sheltered from criticism in every society, it is actually possible for a person to have the economic and intellectual resources to build a nuclear bomb — and to believe that he will get 72 virgins in paradise. And yet, despite abundant evidence to the contrary, liberals continue to imagine that Muslim terrorism springs from economic despair, lack of education and American militarism."

"In their analyses of U.S. and Israeli foreign policy, liberals can be relied on to overlook the most basic moral distinctions. For instance, they ignore the fact that Muslims intentionally murder noncombatants, while we and the Israelis (as a rule) seek to avoid doing so. Muslims routinely use human shields, and this accounts for much of the collateral damage we and the Israelis cause; the political discourse throughout much of the Muslim world, especially with respect to Jews, is explicitly and unabashedly genocidal."
He also take a dig at 9-11 conspiracy theorists, too. Now, what I do love about Sam Harris is his constant recurring theme that we need to take the gloves off and start criticizing religion as we would anything else in our society, and point out its absurdities. I'm 110% behind that. However, one of the things in The End of Faith that I found so unsettling was the idea that somehow Harris thinks that obliterating Muslim extremism through military might is somehow an option. When he gets going on Muslim extremism, sadly, a lot of his rhetoric sounds like Bushspeak, giving the U.S. and Israel a free pass - "we don't intentionally murder noncombatants". A quick glance at the news will expose that as a crock of shit. Granted, we don't do the 'human shield' thing, but we don't seem to have a problem bombing those human shields, either. So much for not intentionally murdering noncombatants.

I'd like to point you to two criticisms of Harris' latest screed, the first from RJ Escow, called 'The Sad State of Atheism Today'. Now, Escow is no atheist. He takes on Harris for ignoring data:

"I met Sam when we both participated in a group seminar on faith and progressive politics. He seemed pleasant enough, but when I cited the exhaustive works of research that have been conducted on fundamentalism in Islam and other religions he pointedly refused either to discuss them - or even to express willingness to look at them.

How can anyone argue for the virtue of knowledge and reason over faith and emotion, yet refuse to either examine the data or subject one's own arguments to logical challenge?

Specifically, Harris would not acknowledge the research of Martin E. Marty and the Fundamentalism Project, whose complex multidisciplinary study found several intriguing patterns in the distribution of fundamentalism throughout all faiths.

Among the Project's findings was the discovery that fundamentalists, who average roughly 20% of any major faith today, all seek to acquire power using similar techniques and belief systems. Their beliefs share much more in common with fundamentalists of other faiths than they do with their co-religionists, a finding that challenges the notion that Islam is an especially evil religion.

This finding challenges an assumption that is deeply cherished by Harris and his ilk, and equally beloved by Bauer and the Christian Right: that Muslims are more extremist than other people. That makes great fodder for recruiting wavering Christians to atheism, or convincing Americans who question the Iraq invasion that we're at war with a world of "Islamofascists."

He accuses Harris, as well as Richard Dawkins, of promoting a form of 'Evangelical Atheism'. Now, when I hear Harris or Dawkins get up on thier soapbox in regards to thier strong support of science and the insane irrationalities that being religious entails, I tend to agree with them strongly, and often find myself taking that same approach. But I don't think that approach wins over too many people on the fence.

Over at Huff Post, Air America radio host Marty Kaplan also takes on Sam with his 'Atheists for Cheney'. His is more the criticism of how Harris' dissing of liberals feeds right into the RNC talking points. I tend to agree.

I present this all in the interest of fairness. I still admire Sam Harris, but I don't quite agree with his take on Muslims, it has always hinted at stereotyping. One of Sam's points in the End of Faith was that religious moderation can be as harmful in many ways as extremism. I agree with that, I just don't agree with his premise that somehow Muslim extremism represents the majority of Muslims, because whether that's his premise or not, it's how it's coming off.

Read More...

Monday, September 18, 2006

Christofascist idiot watch update!

Well, there's another missing white baby alert going on now, so hopefully I can tear you all away from it to give you a new Christofascist Idiot Watch Update.

First up, it's 'Jesus Camp', a film about the rising evangelical youth movement. It's a camp where young, malleable minds are brainwashed into intolerance, unquestioning faith, and a willingness to die for Jesus. Hey, go right ahead, I won't stop you, just go off in the corner somewhere. As the camp's creator, Pastor Becky Fisher says,

"I want to see them as radically laying down their lives for the gospel as they are in Palestine, Pakistan and all those different places," Fisher said. "Because, excuse me, we have the truth."
Uh, excuse me, pastor, but those suicide bombers 'have the truth', too, don't they? Maybe you should all get together someday. So does that mean suicide bombers will be showing up at Planned Parenthood or the local gay bar soon? Scary stuff.

Next up, the Pope sets off another clash of civilizations, as the religions duke it out about as one fictional belief system upsets another! You probably know by now about Pope Nazinger's speech in which he referred to an ancient Catholic emporer who put the smackdown on Islam. But, the speech it was taken from was basically about how reason is such a problem nowadays, that it is wrong of us to want empirical evidence before believing something. Oh, the horror.

Anyways, I give you the incomparable Sam Harris' take on the Pope's latest nonsensical blathering: 'God's Rottweiler Barks':
"The pope suggests that reason should be broadened to include the empirically unverifiable. And is there any question these new “vast horizons” will include the plump dogmas of the Catholic Church? Here, the pope gets the spirit of science exactly wrong. Science does not limit itself merely to what is currently verifiable. But it is interested in questions that are potentially verifiable (or, rather, falsifiable). And it does mean to exclude the gratuitously stupid."
Have a look. Enjoy.

Read More...

Thursday, June 22, 2006

Sam Harris Quote of the Day

“Tell a devout Christian his wife is cheating on him, or that frozen
yoghurt can make a man invisible, and he is likely to require as much
evidence as anybody else, and to be persuaded only to the extent that
you give it. Tell him that the book he keeps by his bed was written by
an invisible deity who will punish him with fire for eternity if he
fails to accept its every incredible claim, and he seems to require no
evidence whatsoever.”

http://www.samharris.org

Read More...