click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!
Showing posts with label criticism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label criticism. Show all posts

Monday, April 16, 2007

Paul Krugman and a lesson for the dysfunctional VT Dem legislature

crossposted at Green Mountain Daily.

There was another great article today by the NYT's voice of reason, Paul Krugman, called 'Way Off Base'. It's basically addressing something that's been on our minds for quite a while, the notion that the public is way ahead of the curve on the issues that Dems are cautiously supporting, yet the Dems still fail to get that, as if they're really afraid of some political liability in challenging a president less popular than recently thawed dog-poop in the snowmelt on a Hubbard Park trail.

Democrats don’t have the same problem. There’s no conflict between catering to the Democratic base and staking out positions that can win in the 2008 election, because the things the base wants — an end to the Iraq war, a guarantee of health insurance for all — are also things that the country as a whole supports. The only risk the party now faces is excessive caution on the part of its politicians. Or, to coin a phrase, the only thing Democrats have to fear is fear itself.
Exactly. I've said this before, especially when dealing with DLC types who preach moderation and accomplish nothing but enabling the president and his allies. They need to stop behaving like it's October of 2001. The GOP has nowhere to go but backwards:
Normally, politicians face a difficult tradeoff between taking positions that satisfy their party’s base and appealing to the broader public. You can see that happening right now to the Republicans: to have a chance of winning the party’s nomination, Republican presidential hopefuls have to take far-right positions on Iraq and social issues that will cost them a lot of votes in the general election...

Republicans will, for a while at least, be trapped in unpopular positions by a base that’s living in the past. Rudy Giuliani’s surge into front-runner status for the Republican nomination says more about the party than about the candidate. As The Onion put it with deadly accuracy, Mr. Giuliani is running for "President of 9/11.”
And that brings me to my second part. The stunning lack of any accomplishment from this veto-proof Democratic VT legislature. Impeachment gets scuttled. Nothing but a meager proposal for property tax reform. We were lucky to get the anti-war resolution. Last session's Catamount healthcare was like a band-aid that still fails to address the larger problem. What the hell are they doing up there?

Is it laziness? Timidity? Do some Democrats apparently not realize what having a large majority means? Apparently Washington County Senator Anne Cummings doesn't have a clue. When not busy knitting in committee meetings, she shared this nugget (on VPR) in regards to the greenhouse gas tax bill that would put a surcharge on fuel oil:
(Dillon) Cummings says the goal is two-fold: First get something the governor can sign.

(Cummings) "There's a great deal of concern that a tax of that kind would be vetoed, and we would then end up with nothing."
First, get something the governor can sign. Great place to start the negotiation, huh? What exactly does Douglas have to concede when presented with that sort of position?

Now, personally I think this particular bill, although well-intentioned, was a bad idea and should not have been introduced in the first place, considering how many Vermonters are already struggling to pay their fuel bill. But I use it because Cummings' response is really emblematic of the problem, most notably in regards to some of the other matters in the legislature.

Considering the current makeup of the legislature, it's Governor Douglas who is the one that should be asking for concessions here, not the other way around. Regardless of the issue, the Dems should be forceful and put forth the best possible legislation, and then have the Governor do the negotiating so he won't have his veto overridden. Not the other way around. It's all about the positioning, and to get back to Krugman's point, if the Dems decided to push through a BOLD proposal for universal healthcare, for example, and they just might find that they're not really being extreme at all. Sure, they're going to piss off corporate apologists like John McLaughry, Big Insurance/Pharma and a few conservatives, but by and large they'd be lauded for the courage and as an added bonus, if they frame it correctly, could paint the gov as a tool for corporate interests, which he most certainly is. Most importantly, they'll have taken action on an important issue and worked towards a solution instead of just perpetual hand-wringing.

And the Dems' inaction does not let you or I off of the hook, either. So many of us talk a good game when it comes to democracy, but we need to not just 'practice' it, we need to get good at it. Go to these committee meetings. Talk to your legislator and look him/her in the eye and tell them to show some courage and that you will support them strongly when they do. And that you will make a stink when they don't.

Having a supermajority shouldn't mean sitting on ones ass and not doing anything. It doesn't mean being drunk with power either, as the national nightmare of Republican rule exemplified. It means taking action. It's time to start putting Douglas on the ropes. Now.

Read More...

Wednesday, April 4, 2007

Kucinich for Prez? No thanks.

Now, before you read this, I want it to be known that this piece should not be taken as an endorsement of any of the Democratic candidates. I am still firmly in the 'none of the above' camp and will be so for at least another year.

Presidential candidate/Ohio congressman Dennis Kucinich seems to be a favorite of some on the leftier end of the spectrum, in particular in Vermont. I remember his name being tossed around quite a bit back in the'04 race. I read some of the things he stands for, agreed with some of it, but the 'electability factor' was a big issue with me. Aside from anything else, I really couldn't see a vegan candidate scoring big in cattle country. He might as well have an arm protruding from his forehead or something.

Kucinich is back in for '08, and I wanted to read up a bit more about him, and really look into why he will seemingly remain a long-shot candidate. Much has been said about his concept of a Department of Peace. Now, I am by no means a pacifist, and I think that sometimes counterviolence is justifiable, but I generally feel that Kucinich's concept is indeed a noble one. Although, a close read of that page sends up a few warning signals, namely "confirm the presence of universal spirit in our lives".

Now, those of you who have read me before know that I am a staunch atheist. And that means that I find New-Agey religious stuff just as distasteful and ridiculous as fundamentalist Christianity (although I will admit it is much more benign). Now, Kucinich's phrase alone is not much cause for concern, but it sent up a red flag for me. I dug around a bit more, and found this speech Kucinich gave at the Dubrovnik Conference on the Alchemy of Peacebuilding, called 'Spirit and Stardust':

"Spirit merges with matter to sanctify the universe. Matter transcends to return to spirit. The interchangeability of matter and spirit means the starlit magic of the outermost life of our universe becomes the soul-light magic of the innermost life of our self. The energy of the stars becomes us. We become the energy of the stars. Stardust and spirit unite and we begin: One with the universe. Whole and holy. From one source, endless creative energy, bursting forth, kinetic, elemental. We, the earth, air, water and fire-source of nearly fifteen billion years of cosmic spiraling."
Uh, okay. Now, I'm not a big Daily Kos fan, it's a bit too rah-rah for the Dems for me, but I couldn't say it better than Markos in regards to this New Age hooey: "Clearly, Kucinich resides in a higher plane of existence than I do. But my plane is on the planet earth. I want my president to reside here as well." And I can see how this kind of speaking does resonate particularly well in Vermont; we have quite a few people here of this particular worldview and mindset. And most of them are some of the kindest, well-intentioned souls I've ever met. But I sure has hell wouldn't want them running the country.

Now, if that's not enough to put you out, another thing that seems to fly under the radar is that until he started running for president, Kucinich was adamantly anti-choice, and anti-stem cell research, as well, as this article from the Nation a few years ago points out.
One thing you won't find on Kucinich's website, though, is any mention of his opposition to abortion rights. In his two terms in Congress, he has quietly amassed an anti-choice voting record of Henry Hyde-like proportions. He supported Bush's reinstatement of the gag rule for recipients of US family planning funds abroad. He supported the Child Custody Protection Act, which prohibits anyone but a parent from taking a teenage girl across state lines for an abortion. He voted for the Unborn Victims of Violence Act, which makes it a crime, distinct from assault on a pregnant woman, to cause the injury or death of a fetus. He voted against funding research on RU-486. He voted for a ban on dilation and extraction (so-called partial-birth) abortions without a maternal health exception. He even voted against contraception coverage in health insurance plans for federal workers--a huge work force of some 2.6 million people (and yes, for many of them, Viagra is covered).
Now, those positions would not even be labelled 'moderate' by any stretch of the imagination. Is Sam Brownback going to be his running mate? And considering that a solid majority of progressive women hold reproductive rights in utmost regard, how would those of you respond to this?

Kucinich seems to be a bit reality-challenged, and that's my issue with him. Even recently, in regards to the Dems pulling out of the Nevada FOX News-sponsored debate, he had this to say:
"But what I am going to say is that FOX is a legitimate news agency that has the ability to reach out to millions of Americans, so why not get that message out?"
Apparently, Kucinich hasn't seen how FOX always spins the message of Democrats being terrorist sympathizers who hate America. But there's more. Like Second Vermont Republic's completely unhinged cult leader with delusions of grandeur, Thomas Naylor, Kucinich goes to imply that the other candidates canceled out of fear of debating him :

"Is it possible that the real conflict was having to take the stage to defend their votes to fund the war?" Kucinich asked.

No, Dennis. You know as well as they do that you are going to have plenty of debates in the near future. I hardly feel they're feeling threatened that you're going to steal the nomination when you can't even crack into the second tier candidates' poll numbers.

I will say this: Kucinich is really right on on many of the ideas about where this country should be going. He has spoken out about the dangers of the PATRIOT Act, and really puts the notion of world peace and social equality and justice at the top of his priorities, as they rightfully should be. But his about-face on reproductive rights, delusions of grandeur and completely unhinged New Age metaphysical psychobabble should clearly illustrate why this man will not get the Democratic nomination.

Read More...

Wednesday, January 31, 2007

Ted Rall: Republicans, Just Shut Up!

I seem to have a terminal case of the blogging lazies this week, but it's cool. Over at Smirking Chimp today, a great piece by Ted Rall, 'Memo to Republicans: Shut Up, Shut Up, Shut Up':

Attention right-wing neoconservative Republicans: We Americans have done things your way since 1981, when an actor named Reagan convinced us that we weren't entitled to anything from the government other than a canceled check for our taxes. We supported dictators against democratic movements. We started wars against tiny weak countries like Grenada and Panama and
Afghanistan just because we could. Even when we had a Democratic president, he bought into Reagan Republicanism; Clinton cut rich people's taxes, signed NAFTA and got rid of social welfare programs.

Twenty-six years into the NeoCon nightmare, everybody hates the United States. We're broke. Here's how screwed up we are: we can't even get out of a war that 91 percent of Americans are against. Republicans got us into this mess.

Rall then says what many people with functioning brain stems must be thinking:

Since these pundits and politicians were and are so spectacularly wrong about such a straightforward and momentous issue as this idiotic war, no one should take them seriously again. Right-wingers deserve to be marginalized and ignored. The American left--the real, non-accommodationist, non-Hillary, left--ought to define the mainstream from now on. Only the left, from Noam Chomsky on the left left to
Howard Dean on the right left, have been consistently correct.

It's funny, whenever Bush comments on ANYTHING nowadays, before I can even process what he's saying, I'm screaming out loud, 'Shut up. No one worth shit gives a flying fuck about what you think. You are an idiot. You do not tell the truth about anything, zero credibility. Please shut the fuck up." Somehow, I suspect I'm not alone in that sentiment...

Read More...

Monday, January 29, 2007

John McCain, Pander Bear

Good little mini-documentary form Robert Greenwald documenting the many times John McCain's 'Straight Talk' was anything but...

Read More...

Monday, January 22, 2007

The Challenge to and Problem of the Democrats

There's a good diary over at Green Mountain Daily by diarist 'wdh3' today that accurately points out the true problems with the Democrats:

Still, with control of Congress up until the 1994 GOP take-over, and with Bill Clinton in the White House, the Democrats brought us things like NAFTA, which have driven down real wages not only here but in fact globally; and which, along with the aggressive expansion of things like the IMF and WTO in the post-Cold War Era, is responsible for a shocking Chasm between the wealth and security of rich and poor, have and have-not. Yes, even the Democrats are engaged in a class war that favors the rich and powerful over everyone else. But we can say that they are in no way as ruthless and unforgiving and demonstrative as the GOP in how they go about their business (which is in fact big business). And so we hope for their victory on election day.

But Democrats have not given us affordable, universal health care as a right of citizenship, as with the rest of the post/industrial West. They have not provided the working person with all the possible luxuries of personal freedom and liberty, as the revolutionary government of "democracy" had promised it would. There are no "livable wages" and therefore no "livable country". D's can, when those of them choose to do so, speak out against war in Vietnam, Iran-Contra, or war in Iraq. But they can't really do anything about it, because it behooves them to allow the forces of State to play-out their economic rules of perpetual and unfettered expansion, development, and "progress".


Read More...

Monday, January 8, 2007

Uygur vs. Eskow

After my next piece on Sam Harris later this week, I'm going to shift gears away from the 'atheist thing' for a while. I feel it's time to turn to some more lighthearted fare on here, or at least some Bush-bashing (hardly a challenge nowadays) lest this turn into an 'atheist blog', which was never my intent to begin with. Between last week's debate with Charity and the Sam Harris stuff, I'm getting kind of burnt out on the whole subject.

There's a good little back and forth over at Smirking Chimp between rude atheist (I say that with affection) Cenk Uygur and critic RJ Eskow. Eskow's been taking on what he calls 'fundamentalist atheism' quite often lately. I don't necessarily agree with him on some points, but he's a good writer, nonetheless. It's a good read.

Cenk Uygur - What RJ Eskow Doesn't Get: Religion is Wrong

RJ Eskow - Dear Cenk Uygur: Don't Let Them Use Atheism to Divide Us

Read More...

The Problem With Sam Harris, pt. 1

Ok, as many of you who frequent this site know, I like to quote Sam Harris; what attracts me about him is his basic premise that religious beliefs should be held up to the same scrutiny as any other human phenomenon. If you think about it for a minute, it's not really that radical of a concept. But, as his message and bestselling book, "The End of Faith" (TEoF), have made their rounds and spread his message, there is much to criticize in some of what Harris has said in his book. The two criticisms I'm hoping to address (in two parts, as to not overwhelm and to make sure I do my homework) are Harris' apparent embrace of Eastern mysticism and psychic abilities, and Harris' Islamophobia, intolerance and support of torture. For a few articles to give you some background on the criticism, go here, and here.

Chapter 7 of TEoF is called 'Experiments in Consciousness', and is arguably the most open-minded section of the book. Harris basically asserts that there is still much to be learned in defining what we know as 'consciousness', and that in some ways, spirituality is a way of investigating the nature of consciousness:

"The history of human spirituality is the history to explore and modify the deliverances of consciousness through methods like fasting , chanting, sensory deprivation, prayer, meditation, and the use of psychotropic plants. There is no question that experiments of this sort can be conducted in a rational manner. Indeed, they are some of our only means of determining to what extent the human condition can be deliberately transformed. Such an enterprise becomes irrational only when people begin making claims about the world that cannot be supported by empirical evidence." (p 210, TEoF)

Now, in some of the criticism one can find about Harris', a recurring theme is that somehow he is being inconsistent by being open to the possibilities of psychic phenomena such as ESP, and that he believes that the construction of the 'self' is quite possibly an illusion (which is consistent with many Eastern mystic belief systems). Meera Nanda over at the New Humanist:
"Harris describes the mystical experience as tuning, or focusing, the mind through meditation, fasting, chanting, sensory deprivation or psychotropic drugs, that enables it to overcome, or dissolve, the sense of the self that stands separate from the objects of its consciousness. The goal is to “experience the world perfectly shorn of self… to lose the subject/object perception… to continue to experience the world, but without the feeling that there is a knower standing apart form the known. Thoughts may arise, but the feeling that one is a thinker of these thoughts vanishes. Harris is describing the classic all-is-one and one-is-all experience that mystics and spiritualists have reported throughout history."
I take issue with Nanda's problem with the 'loss of self'... it is a very conservative perspective that I feel is deeply rooted in the fear of the loss of individuality. Harris:
"As a mental phenomenon, loss of self is not as rare as our scholarly neglect of it suggests. This experience is characterized by a sudden loss of subject/object perception: the continuum of experience remains, but one no longer feels that there is a knower standing apart from the know. Thoughts may arise, but the feeling that one is the thinker of these thoughts have vanished" (TEoF, p.212)
Last semester, as I did my research for a paper on the use of entheogenic (psychotropic) plants in native cultures, this theme of 'depersonalization' (brought on by the consumption of plants, in that case) was a common theme. Psychologists found the use of psychedelics a huge breakthrough, in part because of the ability to seemingly break down the ego, and it showed promising therapeutic possibilities, which sadly came to an end after the criminalization of them in the mid-60's. So, I don't think that Harris, in embracing this possibility, is going out on a limb here. He is showing an open mind that, unfortunately is lacking in some of his other arguments in the book.

I don't believe that any of the critics that I've read have read Harris' rebuttal to Tom Flynn's criticisms in Free Inquiry magazine last year:
"The hypothesis is this: if I use my attention in the prescribed way, it may have a specific, reproducible effect. Needless to say, what happens (or fails to happen) along any path of “spiritual” practice has to be interpreted in light of some conceptual scheme, and everything must remain open to rational discussion. How this discussion proceeds will ultimately be decided by contemplative scientists. As I said in my book, if we ever develop a mature science of the mind, most of our religious texts will be no more useful to mystics than they now are to astronomers.

What words should we use to acknowledge the fact that the happiest person on this earth at this moment might have spent the last twenty years living alone in a cave? Any experienced meditator knows that this is a serious possibility. (Indeed, I consider it not only possible, but likely.) What can we say about the fact that the conventional sources of human happiness—association with family and friends, positive engagement with society, diverse experiences of physical pleasure, etc.—might be neither necessary nor sufficient to produce happiness in its most profound forms? This is not New Age mumbo jumbo. What secularists like Flynn tend not to realize is that there are genuine, introspective insights that can be terribly difficult to acquire. The lack of general accessibility does not render such insights at all suspect...

I also took considerable heat from Flynn for a few remarks I made about the nature of consciousness. Most atheists appear to be certain that consciousness is entirely dependent upon (and reducible to) the workings of the brain. In the last chapter of the book, I briefly argue that this certainty is unwarranted. I say this as one who is deeply immersed in the neuroscientific and philosophical literature on consciousness: the truth is that scientists still do not know what the relationship between consciousness and matter is. I am not in the least suggesting that we make a religion out of this uncertainty, or do anything else with it. Needless to say, the mysteriousness of consciousness does nothing to make conventional religious notions about God and paradise any more plausible."
I like to think I have a somewhat perceptive bullshit detector. In reading that chapter in question, I didn't take away from it any sense of Harris 'jumping the fence', so to speak. Harris is simply expressing an openness to some of the unanswered questions out there, whether it be ESP (which is something that, although the 'scientific jury' is not solidified, there are many legitimate scientists that believe in its possibilities, just that we haven't enough info yet), or the insights brought on by meditation. Harris isn't attributing these things to supernatural causes by any means. As I see it, he's just open to some ideas to which we don't have answers to yet.

I didn't have much of an issue with Harris on this subject. However, I DO have some serious reservations about Harris and intolerance, and an overestimation of the negative impacts of religion. I'll have that coming up in part 2, later this week.

Read More...

Thursday, January 4, 2007

Olbermann on Bush's Upcoming Blood Sacrifice

I know that Keith Olbermann's excellent special commentaries are all over the blogosphere. 'Cuz they're so friggin good. Once again, he seems to be the voice of the diminutive contingency of Intelligent Americans out there. In a time where I repeatedly find myself telling George Bush to go fuck himself several times a day, it's good to have a few eloquent voices out there saying what needs to be said. Watch it.

It would be so much easier if we could somehow sacrifice Bush, wouldn't it?

Read More...

Saturday, December 30, 2006

A Taxonomy of Annoying People

Atrios has a good commentary on the annoying people on our side... sounds like half the people I know.

Read More...

Friday, December 29, 2006

Showdown at Blog Corral...


Well, not really. One of the few conservatives I really like, Charity, over at She's Right, has been spending some time here. If she lets me, I'll post her piece over here when it's done.

Read More...

Thursday, December 21, 2006

Malaise

I don't usually get too personal on this blog, but here's a rare exception, so if you're not into venting, click somewhere else today, I can dig it. Every now and then I get into a funk when I think about the state of the nation. As I was doing some last minute holiday shopping in Burlington today and saw so much 'stuff' being bought, it hit me. Mostly, as I read the news and see how Bush is obviously not going to budge on Iraq, and I don't think the Dems have the balls to cut off funding or impeach or anything else daring and effective, the anger hits me, but it's not so much the anger at the government. I'm really mad at the ordinary people in this country who have enabled all of this bad behavior. Whether it be because of the intellectual deficiencies that allow them to be so easily emotionally manipulated, or the laziness that prefers American Idol to Being Informed, or just the fact that so many in this country are shallow, selfish and materialistic and just buy in to all the rah-rah we're #1 bullshit, it drives me insane. Many of us acted like little, scared, whiny pants-poopers after 9-11, and didn't learn a goddamn thing. And I've really had it up to here with fundamentalists, like this asshole. I can't help but agree with this by Jesse over at TV News Lies:

All I can say is that this is what you get for believing even for a moment what the US corporate media wants you to believe. The rest of us Bush haters are Bush haters for one reason and one reason only; we pay attention! So to my new former Bush supporting friends who seem to be suddenly surrounding me and telling me that I have been right all along: you can tell me I was right but after that shut the hell up because it is too late for forgiveness. From now on, just shut up and listen. Think about it!
It's easy to say that, well, "we get what we deserve". I sure as hell don't deserve what has been happening to this country. Do you?

Read More...

Wednesday, December 13, 2006

Losing the War

The S.F. Gate's Mark Morford is one of the savvier cultural critics out there... a good deal of snark and honesty, bound to get a right-winger's panties in a bunch. Today he's got 'America Loses Another War':

Sure, you already knew. Sure, you sort of sensed from the beginning that we couldn't possibly win a bogus war launched by a nasty slew of corrupt pseudo-cowboys against both a bitterly contorted Islamic nation and a vague and ill-defined concept that has no center and no boundaries and that feeds on the very thing that tries to destroy it. It was sort of obvious, even if half the nation was just terrifically blinded by Bush administration lies and false shrieks of impending terror.

Read More...

Tuesday, December 12, 2006

Let's Hope He's Right, Soon

(note to Secret Service re: title of post. Don't waste your time with me, it's snark. )

'I'll be dead when they get it right.' So says our dipshit of a President. See, poor Georgie just seems to be misunderstood. It's not really incompetence or mild retardation. That Daily News article I pointed you to basically is a telling of how clueless the W.H. is, and how, still, after 6 years, there are no grown ups in charge. Favorite quote from a W.H. aide:

"The White House is totally constipated," a former aide complained. "There's not enough adult leadership, and the 30-year-olds still think it's 2000 and they're riding high."

Read More...

Wednesday, November 15, 2006

Must-read Joe Bageant

As usual, Joe Bageant nails things on the head like so few others can, with his 'Pissing in the Liberal Punchbowl':

"The Democratic Party does America not one bit of good by sustaining the hubris that has brought us to the point where our high officials and former officials such as Rumsfeld and Alberto Gonzales (and others yet to be charged, we suspect) cannot travel in countries like Germany because of war crime indictments. Someone has to ask, "How did we come to this?" Ask "How can we not only change our course, but also make amends and prove to the world that we are worthy of trust?" It would be of great help if we were actually worthy of trust.

It ain't gonna happen because, just like George Bush, we as a people never admit our mistakes. Not as long as we are packing more heat than all the rest of the world combined. We are the five percent of the planet consuming a quarter of its resources on the grounds of divine entitlement as Americans. And the heat we pack. Think the Dems are gonna address that? Address that belligerent two-ton rhino in the sandbox called the American Lifestyle? Nobody will, and that refusal will ensure our downfall. Rhinos can be taken down, and you don't have to be Hemingway to do it. Ask any 12-year-old Syrian or Palestinian boy. It's their dream. Any bookie will tell you that odds are good that at least one of those millions of boys will accomplish his dream. Providence is like that."

It's always been a rough sticking point with me as to how Americans don't seem to do introspective navel-gazing very well. Like many of our country's problems, I chalk it up to my 'we're a young country' theory. Like a young child, in most cases we haven't matured to the point where we can look back on our behavior and judge it with some sense of objectivity, especially when it leads us to realize we've been acting like dickheads. We are just always so convinced that we are so right, probably because we've been brought up with this crazy way of thinking disguised as 'national pride' that enables that very 'we're #1' delusion.

Read More...

Sunday, September 17, 2006

Toddler Nation

Foggy day in Plainfield. Had a near miss with a chainsaw yesterday, but my Carhartts took the brunt of it. I still have two legs. Anyways, been light on the blogging this week; I've been playing catchup for the week I was sick. A few posts ago, I mentioned the soul-searching going on about 9-11, and about how so many Americans just didn't seem to learn anything from it. Rolling Stone's Matt Taibbi nails it on the head, with 'Americans in Denial about 9-11':

"So, why did they hate us after all?

We sure blew off that question nicely. As with everything else in this country, our response to 9/11 was a heroic compendium of idiocy, cowardice, callow flag-waving, weepy sentimentality (coupled with an apparently bottomless capacity for self-pity), sloth, laziness, and partisan ignorance.

We did just about everything except honestly ask ourselves what the hell really happened, and why."
We're a young nation. We don't have a thousand years of history behind us, as, say, Britain. Therefore we don't seem to know how to act like grownups, whether it be the way we fear sex, our hyperreligiousity, or any lacking sense of 'the common good'. And there's that nasty anti-intellectual streak I'm always talking about.

Speaking of whiny babies, gotta show you something on the National Republican Committee's website, that illustrates my point about the level of maturity so common in the nation: 'DEMS' "ROSIE" VIEW ON WAR ON TERROR Cut-And-Run Defeatocrats Across The Country Take Their Cues From Hollywood Friends And Advisors'.

Yep. Cutsie-poo name calling.. the 'Defeatocrats'. How mind numbingly original. But are there too many syllables for their base to remember/comprehend/read? Now, I'm no fan of Rosie, I find her incredibly annoying. I guess if I were a houswife I might feel differently. What did she say that got the GOPanties in a bunch?
"Radical Christianity is just as threatening as radical Islam in a country like America where we have separation of church and state." (ABC's "The View," 9/13/06)

"And as a result of the [9-11] attack and the killing of 3,000 innocent people, we invaded two countries and killed innocent people ..." (ABC's "The View," 9/13/06)

"We are bombing innocent people in other countries." (ABC's "The View," 9/13/06)
Ok, what exactly did she say that wasn't true? Have to figure that one out for yourself, the site doesn't say, it just goes on to show the numerous 'Defeatocrats'' Rosie has contributed to. It makes me wonder what kind of people the GOP is trying to reach using elementary-school level diologue. Maybe people that listen to this guy.

Read More...

Tuesday, September 12, 2006

Even some cons are waking up...

We all know how badly bias wreaks havoc on human perception and objectivity. Study after study seems to confirm that many seek out information that confirms their world view (hence the popularity of FOX News). Some of us have a better handle on this than others, but I suspect even the best of us are guilty at times. Regardless, while avoiding the bone-in-nose, fur-loincloth conservatives such as Malkin, Little Green Footballs, Limbaugh, and the other blowhards, from time to time I pop in on National Review, American Conservative, Washington Monthly, et. al to see what the more intellectually-inclined opposition is talking about. Sometimes it's no different in its stupidity, selfishness and shortsightedness than the other stuff, but once in a while a few insightful things pop through the muck. Plus, if I don''t fully understand my opponent's arguments, how can I say I fully understand my own?

For your perusal, a feature over at this month's Washington Monthly...'Time For Us to Go: Conservatives on Why the GOP Should Lose in 2006'. It's seven articles, from noted cons such as Joe Scarborough, Christopher Buckley (son of William F.), and William A. Niskanen (Cato institute). It's basically a rundown of how badly G.W. and the current crop of Repubs have screwed this country up so badly, and why it might not be a bad thing (from their conservative perspective, of course) if the GOP lost its grip on power. All of the articles unequivocally voice support for the divided government as the Founding Fathers intended, as well as why divided government works best. Of course, there's the obligatory ass-kissing to the ideals of Adam Smith and other conservative nonsense, but I found myself agreeing, at least in principle, to much of what was said, for it could just as easily explain why it would be good for liberalism in some parts.

Read More...

Friday, June 16, 2006

Farsightedness

I've been having a bit of an email dialogue with one of my friends out in Oakland. We played together in several bands over the years, were in an affinity group a few years ago, and got arrested at the WTO minesterial in Montreal a few years ago (yee ha, we sure threw a cog in the wheel of the New World Order on that one!). He's a great, funny guy, and we've been talking about the goings on in South America, of which he seems to be very hopeful for, although he is aware of the romanticism of it all. He's travelled quite a bit there recently. He doesn't think anything will get better in the world until capitalism is brought down, with all of the misery and such that it brings.

Now, my point of this is I hear this argument (if one could call it that) a lot from some of my more anarchist-socialist leaning buddies, and I agree with them. But here's the kicker. I never hear a plan. Ever. It's as if I were to ramble on about how someday we won't have a need for religion because humanity will finally see through the fictions and stuff and realize one can reach that kind of bliss and be a good person without resorting to belief in fairy tales, but I never talk about how we're going to get rid of such a deeply ingrained belief system. And that's a problem I see with many on the far left. It's like we're at point 'A' in time right now, and they're at point 'Q'. What does point 'B' look like? How do we get anywhere when this belief we espouse isn't even a blip on the radar of most of the public? And that many people like being able to spend $4000 on a television set, and even the ones living in barely-standing mobile homes still manage to find money for their 500 channels of shit every month? And the sad truth that most Americans are so insulated from the effects of their affluence that they wouldn't give enough of a shit to change thier lifestyles even if they did? It's really frustrating, and it really ties into the idealism that ties our hands on the left.

You've heard me rant about it before; we can't seem to really get past talking about the way the world should be enough to have a plan to make it that way. And even if the stuff in Latin America is the real deal, it's not going to work here in that form. America is a different planet. Che was a Stalinist who killed a lot of people, and that's not a right-wing thing, it's just history. Chavez might be alleviating poverty in Venezuela or he might just be another lightweight dictator who talks about it. Get over it.

Stop telling me how it should be. I know that already. Give me some kind of clue that you know how we're going to get us there, because, to be quite honest, I don't think that many of you have any more of a clue than I do. Howzabout how we're going to survive two and a half more years of this asshole president? Do any of you know? If not, then why the hell should I listen to you about what it will be like when the walls of capitalism come crashing down? Do you have a clue as to how thick and titanium-reinforced those walls are? Are we going to even be around long enough to enjoy it?

Read More...

Friday, March 31, 2006

Time to put our own house in order

Yet another awesome, sunny early spring day. Since we've had a crazy winter with lots of wind, the woods are a mess, lots of tree debris everywhere. So I spent last evening collecting and burning said debris, and drinking beer. My bro came over and we grilled and ate way too much meat: pork chops, a 'zampet' sausage from Ping's Sausage Shop, and a London Broil. Mmm. Colon cancer.

I'd like to talk a bit today about rigid ideology. On our side. What prompted this is reading something over at Americablog yesterday. John Aravosis want to some black tie D.C. function, the Radio and Television Correspondents Association annual dinner. Typical DC hobnobing thing, all sorts of types there. Mr. 'as-popular-as-explosive-diarrhea' Dick Cheney was there. Anyways, John was doing what people do at these kinds of functions - schmoozing with all sorts of people. Then he made the fatal mistake of talking to Florida Bush-stooge, Senate candidate and election theft enabler Katherine Harris and getting a picture with her, recognizing the camp value (same reason I collect Nixon memorabilia). Then, he made the doubly fatal mistake of commenting that he was surprised how nice of a person she was on a personal level. This unleashed a bunch of negative, harsh comments from a small percentage of his readership, calling him a sellout, traitor, etc.
Now, I've been reading John for about a year. I think he's a real activist. He got ranting homophobe Dr. Laura off of the air, he successfully put presssure on Ford to resist caving in to the wingnuts about advertising in gay-themed publications, brought the whole 'your cell phone records are for sale' thing to light, etc. He's one of those on our side that's actually accomplished something other than spout out bumper-sticker slogans . Admittedly, he is definitely more in the mainstream than I am. But that's fine. My point is that he is anything but a sell-out. He really got upset about this, and I would think that he could use a bit of a thicker skin. But it prompted him to write a post about those on the left who fear money and power.
He makes some good points. There are those of us on our side, due to their rigid ideology, that cannot deal with the idea that someone who is working for us should be justly compensated for their work. It's almost like there are some that feel because they're able to live off the power grid in their wigwam, that we ALL need to live that way. It's like some kind of hippie fascism. And, like the worst of the conservatives, they are unable to see things in anything but a dualistic black and white. Either you renounce capitalism and any modern comforts completely or you are evil and impure.
I live in Plainfield, Vermont, home of the progressive Goddard College, not your typical college. It's definitely one of theose progressive alternative schools where they spell women with a 'y'. Lots of great people have come through its doors over the years, many of which I am good friends with. The legendary jam-band Phish started out there. Until recently, right down the road, we had the Institute for Social Ecology, a kind of anarchist-type educational institution. So they've kind of helped make Plainfield what I call 'ground zero for the granola belt'. There are lots of back-to-the-land types here, to varying degrees. Lots of fifty and sixty-something guys with huge beards. My own house was originally built with no running water, an outhouse, kerosene lamps, and a wood-fired kitchen stove. Needless to say, you have some of the leftiest of the left here.
I had my first firsthand experience with the idealistic ideology when involved with the Plainfield Co-op, our little food store that has been here since the early seventies. Jenni was on the Board of Directors. It has reached a point, due to various factors, that it is in serious finacial distress, and the BOD wanted to make some radical changes, such as hiring an experienced manager who actually had experience in retail grocery. The idea of moving it to a bigger, more suitable place was also proposed. Now, the PR campaign was kind of botched from the board from the start, lots of miscommunication and such. But some of the bullshit the diehards were spewing was UN-FRICKIN'-BELIEVABLE. The new manager wanted to do such radical things such as proper inventory management, better product placement, the end of paying all of our vendors in cash out of the register, and basically putting long-needed standard operating procedures that any responsible business should have, in place. Some of the bullshit responses to this:

"It's corporate. We should question (above-stated) standard operating procedures."
" We shouldn't even be discussing making this store profitable. Profit is immoral."
"We shouldn't move the store because it will get more cars driving by. The age of the automobile is going to be coming to an end very soon.'
"We have to have non-heirarchical management."

Non-heirarchical management can work great... if everybody on the team has the required skills necessary. Someone needs to know about profit margin. Inventory control. Marketing. Unfortunately, in the 30-plus years of non-heirarchical management, there was never a time where all of those skills were present, hence the problems. You're only as effective as your least effective person.
When I mentioned to one of them how if we actually made a profit, we could afford to pay our employees a livable wage and healthcare (a favorite cause for the left), I heard, "Well, it's not right that profit should have to pay for healthcare." In other words, because we should have universal health care and don't, that we shouldn't try to do what is the current norm for paying for healthcare, until we do have universal healthcare. Sorry, hard-working employees. Tough shit, my ideology doesn't allow this.
So basically, thanks to certain peoples' fear of vague undefined notions, a complete lack of sense of what it takes to run a business, and a pervasive almost Marxist ideological rigidity, we're in trouble.
Now, I don't think that our extremists are evil. I can't find an equivalent of the xenophobic, racist, intolerant right-winger on our side. But our extremists are just as fearful of change, and can't seem to grasp that it is a complex world, with complex issues, and there is no 'black and white' to anything. Scientists who study adult development call it 'dualistic' thinking, which is the first stage of adult thinking. The first. It's the kind that hopefully as a 30-50 year old person you should be well-past. And unfortunately we have a lot of well-educated people on our side that aren't.
I'm not advocating that we go to the 'mushy middle' of things. We can be left, even far-left. But we need to avoid the rigid ideology, recognize nuance, and see the world as it really is, not just as how we think it should be. If we do that, we will be closer to getting it how it should be. If we don't, we are no better than the other side.

Read More...

Thursday, March 9, 2006

What is really going on with the Democrats, pt. 2?

One thing that was apparent in all of your comments about my telemarketer experience, was the Democrats 'not getting it', and being 'out of touch'. I agree, but it really goes deeper than that. What do you think explains what is really going on? Some thoughts to ponder...

- The 'move to the center' strategy we've often heard is about as effective as supply-side economics. It's given them loss after loss after loss in the quest for 'the mushy middle'. Why do they continue to do so? Is the influence of the DLC so pervasive that they are all getting their hands tied?

- Are they continually getting bad advice? If so, why do they continue to listen to it? One would think that they could look at the results of that advice and change strategy. But they aren't. Why?

- Have the above said bad advisors convinced the majority of them that classic liberalism is about as dead as Marxism, and that us netroots people are so far out of the mainstream? John at Americablog seems to have a take on this here. And once again, why do they believe it? Although I may not agree with some things on the left of the blogosphere, I hardly hear anything radical or insane coming from Kos, Americablog, Eschaton, etc. Can't these other politicians see that?

- Let's get into conspiracy theory stuff here, just for the sake of discussion. Are there some backroom deals going on where some of them are working for the Republicans? Are the people giving them the continual bad advice secretly working for the GOP? Is there some kind of blackmail involved? Is it a brain parasite?

- 'Lack of spine' also gets mentioned a lot. How does that work? Can't say 9-11, because 1994 happened, right? What exactly do you think is causing this lack of spine? What are they so afraid of? Dems weren't always this way.

- Is it the resistance to taking the gloves of and getting confrontational that so many on the left seem to have? We could embrace many of the hardball tactics they do, with one big difference - we're not making things up.

- Are they just as corrupt as the Republicans?

I put these out there because at one time or another, I've thought about them, and/or heard them from others, but no one has of yet laid out a concrete theory for me. Now's your chance.

Read More...