click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!
Showing posts with label 9-11. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 9-11. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Monibot in the Guardian on 9-11 conspiracies...

I've never been big on the more far-fetched 9-11 conspiracies (like the U.S. Gov't blowing up the Towers, etc. ) I saw 'Loose Change' and although it does ask some questions, much of the 'answers' stretch the limits of credibility. By no means do I buy the 'official story' by any strectch of the imagination, it's just that there are an awful lot of factors that would need to line up to buy some of the more adventurous theories, and when looked at on the macro level, they just don't add up, any more than the official story does. I think the truth lies somewhere in between... BushCo might have very well had prior knowledge, was extremely incompetent or both, saw how they could use it to their advantage (considering that this country reacts like a 4-year old child in these situations), and bam, there you have it. George Monibot in the lefty UK Guardian had this to say:

The next evident flaw is that the plot they propose must have involved tens of thousands of people. It could not have been executed without the help of demolition experts, the security firms guarding the World Trade Centre, Mayor Giuliani (who hastily disposed of the remains), much of the US air force, the Federal Aviation Administration and the North American Aerospace Defence Command, the relatives of the people "killed" in the plane crashes, the rest of the Pentagon's staff, the Los Alamos laboratories, the FBI, the CIA, and the investigators who picked through the rubble.
Now before you jump down my throat and somehow suggest I'm working for COINTELPRO or something, remember, I'm skeptical about everything. I just don't let my Bush hatred get the best of my imagination. There are a bunch of unanswered questions, but there aren't exactly any answers coming to the forefront with any kind of irrefutable proof. I'm not satisfied from the official story any more than I am by the conspiracy theorists, for both explanations leave many more questions than answers.

Read More...

Monday, October 2, 2006

9-11 Conspiracy pt. 2

Between the Woodward thing and the Foley thing, my schadenfreude is running so high I can't comment on them right now. Just wanted to point you to a few more 9-11 conspiracy tidbits. The first is from Matt Taibbi , who has a follow-up on his smackdown of 9-11 conspiracy theorists. He now talks about the very relevant fact that although conspiracy theorists have their crazy little theories, none have been able to tie them together into a cohesive narrative:

"there is not -- at least not that I could find -- a single document anywhere that lays out a single, concrete theory of what happened, who ordered what and when they ordered it, and why. There obviously is such a theory, but it has to be pieced together by implication, by paying attention to the various assertions of 9/11 lore (the towers were mined, the Pentagon was really hit by a cruise missile, etc.) and then assembling them later on into one single story. But the funny thing is, when you put together all of those disparate theories, you get the dumbest story since Roman Polanski's Pirates.

"The specifics vary, but the basic gist of what They Say Happened goes something like this:

A group of power-hungry neocons, led by Dick Cheney, Paul Wolfowitz, Bush and others and organizationally represented by groups like the Project for the New American Century, seeks to bring about a "Pearl-Harbor-like event" that would accelerate a rightist revolution, laying the political foundation for invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq.

Your basic Reichstag fire scenario, logical enough so far. Except in this story, the Reichstag fire is an immensely complicated media hoax; the conspirators plot to topple the World Trade Center and pin a series of hijackings on a group of Sunni extremists with alleged ties to Al Qaeda. How do they topple the Trade Center? Well, they make use of NORAD's expertise in flying remote-control aircraft and actually fly two such remote-control aircraft into the Towers (in another version of the story, they conspire with Al Qaeda terrorists to actually hijack the planes), then pass the planes off as commercial jetliners in the media. But it isn't the plane crashes that topple the buildings, but bombs planted in the Towers that do the trick.

For good measure -- apparently to lend credence to the hijacking story -- they then fake another hijacking/crash in the Pentagon, where there actually is no plane crash at all but instead a hole created by a cruise missile attack, fired by a mysterious "white jet" that after the attack circles the White House for some time, inspiring the attention of Secret Service agents who point at it curiously from the ground (apparently these White House Secret Service agents were not in on the plot, although FBI agents on scene at Ground Zero and in Shanksville and elsewhere were).

Lastly, again apparently to lend weight to the whole hijacking cover story, they burn a big hole in the ground in Pennsylvania and claim that a jet went down there, crashed by a bunch of brave fictional civilians who fictionally storm the fictional plane cabin. The real-life wife of one of the fictional heroes, Lisa Beamer, then writes a convincingly self-serving paean/memoir to her dead husband, again lending tremendous verisimilitude to the hijacking story. These guys are good!"

The second piece is a transcript of a recent Democracy Now! show between the creators of the 9-11 conspiracy film 'Loose Change' and the authors of a new book, 'Debunking 9-11 Myths: Why Conspiracy Theories Can't Hold Up to the Facts', who are the editors of the very non-political Popular Mechanics magazine. I have to say, the Pop Mech ones come out of this looking like the sane ones. Check it out here.

Now, I'll say it again... I don't buy the official story, and I am certain that there was a bit of willful negligence on the part of BushCo. But they are too stupid to pull off the things these conspiracy theorists believe, and the amount of coordination, as well as willingness that they would need from many gov't agencies simply could not happen, as well as the fact that in 5 years, not one person involved hasn't come forward. Hey, I hate Bush, too, I'm just not ready to let that hatred destroy my critical thinking skills. Enjoy.


Read More...

Sunday, September 17, 2006

Toddler Nation

Foggy day in Plainfield. Had a near miss with a chainsaw yesterday, but my Carhartts took the brunt of it. I still have two legs. Anyways, been light on the blogging this week; I've been playing catchup for the week I was sick. A few posts ago, I mentioned the soul-searching going on about 9-11, and about how so many Americans just didn't seem to learn anything from it. Rolling Stone's Matt Taibbi nails it on the head, with 'Americans in Denial about 9-11':

"So, why did they hate us after all?

We sure blew off that question nicely. As with everything else in this country, our response to 9/11 was a heroic compendium of idiocy, cowardice, callow flag-waving, weepy sentimentality (coupled with an apparently bottomless capacity for self-pity), sloth, laziness, and partisan ignorance.

We did just about everything except honestly ask ourselves what the hell really happened, and why."
We're a young nation. We don't have a thousand years of history behind us, as, say, Britain. Therefore we don't seem to know how to act like grownups, whether it be the way we fear sex, our hyperreligiousity, or any lacking sense of 'the common good'. And there's that nasty anti-intellectual streak I'm always talking about.

Speaking of whiny babies, gotta show you something on the National Republican Committee's website, that illustrates my point about the level of maturity so common in the nation: 'DEMS' "ROSIE" VIEW ON WAR ON TERROR Cut-And-Run Defeatocrats Across The Country Take Their Cues From Hollywood Friends And Advisors'.

Yep. Cutsie-poo name calling.. the 'Defeatocrats'. How mind numbingly original. But are there too many syllables for their base to remember/comprehend/read? Now, I'm no fan of Rosie, I find her incredibly annoying. I guess if I were a houswife I might feel differently. What did she say that got the GOPanties in a bunch?
"Radical Christianity is just as threatening as radical Islam in a country like America where we have separation of church and state." (ABC's "The View," 9/13/06)

"And as a result of the [9-11] attack and the killing of 3,000 innocent people, we invaded two countries and killed innocent people ..." (ABC's "The View," 9/13/06)

"We are bombing innocent people in other countries." (ABC's "The View," 9/13/06)
Ok, what exactly did she say that wasn't true? Have to figure that one out for yourself, the site doesn't say, it just goes on to show the numerous 'Defeatocrats'' Rosie has contributed to. It makes me wonder what kind of people the GOP is trying to reach using elementary-school level diologue. Maybe people that listen to this guy.

Read More...

Friday, September 8, 2006

9-11

Ok, as the fifth anniversary of 9-11 rolls around, as well as the fifth time Bush is politicizing the hell out of it... oops ....pssstt..hey, 9-11 happened on YOUR WATCH, George, why don't you remind us a little more of that...., and I'm noticing something is different this time around, at least in the media. The looking inward and soul-searching that has been so lacking from this discussion is slowly creeping in, as this article in the latest issue of Time illustrates. There, as in other places, people are starting to wonder how we might have acted differently. Part of why this hasn't happened sooner is simply the passage of time helps us put things into perspective better. Part of it is also, as someone noted in a great blog entry that I read but now can't remember where, is that the way Bush 'led' the nation immediately after 9-11 in a sense robbed us of our own collective experience. He set the frame on how it was to be, why they 'hated our freedoms', etc., not giving us our own space to process the information. Now that the rest of the country is starting to realize how full of shit he was and continues to be, it's finally catching up.

Now, I don't know how common my reaction was to 9-11. Not to sound cold, but it really didn't phase me all that much. It was just another typical work-from-home day, until I turned on the TV that I had at the time and watched it unfold. I was definitely glued to the tube as everyone else, I was horrified at the loss of life, but I sure as hell wasn't scared. I was certain there was going to be an attack in Hollywood later that day, seeing how they struck the financial and military symbols, I figured they'd go for the most obvious cultural one, too. I remember thinking, 'Whoa, we must have really pissed someone off. The chickens have finally come home to roost.'

The fear did start to sink in, but it wasn't about my safety. I was fearful about what our government would do, and what our people would do. As I started to see the bullshit hype and praise heaped upon Bush, 90% approval rating and such, while knowing what a moron he was, well before that, I got really scared. It was then that I realized that those planes knocked the critical thinking skills out of the brains of a good portion of the country. When they're comparing a man who can't even form a complete sentence to Churchill, you know something's screwed up.

And what's been nagging at me lately, looking at how people continue to behave, is how unbelievably immature this country really is. A lot of us crapped our pants on 9-11, whether right or wrong, and somehow it turned into shit-for-brains. I really don't understand it. Granted, I wasn't surprised by 9-11, considering how we behave on the world stage (not justifying it, either), but I was surprised it took so long for something like this to happen. I'm certainly not shocked that *gasp* people might hate us. But when you're constantly fed the 'we're #1' crap everywhere you go your whole life, combined with a wide streak of anti-intellectualism and total disinterest in world affairs or anything not related to sports or celebrities, I can see where the above said pants-crapping came from.

I'm encouraged by a lot of things, lately. Bush's let's-have-military-tribunals-overseas-and-withhold-evidence-from-the-defendants scheme was shot down today by none other than fellow knuckle-dragger Lindsey Graham. There are more and more signs every day of the Republicans going down in an electoral bloodbath, as more 'safe Repub' seats fall into the 'toss-up' column, even in places like Idaho. California is passing a major global warming initiative. And everyday, more and more people are figuring out how unbelievably full of shit George W. Bush is. So there's a lot to be hopeful, but not complacent for.

Read More...

Thursday, April 27, 2006

What happened on 9/11?

Two main failings I see with some of us on the left is a romantic attraction to revolutionaries while turning a blind eye to the flaws, such as human rights abuses (a la Chavez/Castro/Guevara) and a love for conspiracy theories, no matter how factually challenged and outlandish. I'm not talking about the JFK-grassy knoll type, I mean ideas like the Twin Towers were brought down by a controlled demolition (not by the planes, instead charges planted and detonated conveniently at the time of impact), or that a missile or a fighter plane crashed into the Pentagon. Things like this really give the more sensible of us on the left a bad name in the credibility department, kinda like those that can't take a shit in the morning without consulting their horoscope first. I've always thought that most of the conspiracy theories don't hold water, but neither does the official version.

Apparently, Ernest Partridge over at the Crisis Papers feels as as I do. I point you now to his essay, 'The 9/11 Conspiracy: A Skeptic's View'. Very thoughtfully, he takes some of the popular conspiracy theories, as well as the official version and using well-researched facts and logical analysis, catapults the bullshit. It is quite clear that we may never know the full story. Do I believe Bushco actually demolished the towers themselves? That's giving them credit for way more intelligence that they repeatedly have shown they do not posses, not to mention the sheer stretch of the imagination it would involve to pull it off and keep it under wraps. Do I think they might have looked the other way or 'misunderestimated' the threat with the hopes of using it for political gain? Certainly. That is much more in line with the way these scumbags operate.

And lest some of you think Partridge is some kinda right-winger-Bush apologist, have a look around the Crisis Papers site. He is about as anti-Bush as he comes. He just knows how to use his brain.

Read More...