I had to meet a friend for lunch to day in Montpelier, and then sauntered over to the Statehouse to catch the impeachment proceedings in the House. It was defeated, 87-60. I'd like to offer a big thanks who stood up for accountability and voted for the resolution. Odum has the roll call at GMD here.
Yes, as others have noted, it was inspiring, and it truly was a case of democracy in action. But I left rather pissed.
The VT blogosphere was on hand... from who I could see, Norsehorse, Snarky Boy, GMD, Carpetbagger Report and yours truly were all there to report on the carnival. The house was packed, as you can see from the photo I took.
There were people of all kinds in the crowd on hand (over 300) to do that 'democracy' thing that seems to be in short supply lately. The Republican speeches were pretty pathetic, ranging from Tom Koch (Barre Town) keeping consistent and speaking out against it on procedural grounds, partisanship and everything but the kitchen sink. Not surprising, because that guy, when not trying to pass laws forbidding driving-while-flute-playing pretty much opposes anything good that ever gets presented, regardless of the issue. Another Repub whose name I didn't catch acted as though the various misdeeds of Bushco were somehow still in doubt, then rehashed a bunch of statements from prominent Dems from almost ten years ago. Others just looked annoyed.
But the one that got me pissed more than anything was from a Democrat (once again, I didn't get a name-if someone has these names please put something in the comments and I'll revise) who gave the tired excuse of how the legislature had many other areas of important business to address, and didn't have time for this. Wrong on two accounts...first off, the only 'time' taken was already in progress. Second, this has been one of the least productive legislatures that I can remember in recent memory. Other than avoiding confrontation with Douglas with a big bendover on issue after issue, I'm hard pressed to think of anything substantial to come out of the Statehouse this year, short of the resolution to end the war. Nothing involving healthcare. A meager proposal on property taxes. What are they spending so much time on? The bill to help small farmers process meat on-site so they can sell at markets and restaurants is a great bill, but is it a real time-stealer?
Although I was a bit disappointed, I didn't think this was going to pass. House Speaker Gaye Symington, one of the more spineless speakers in recent memory (someone quipped 'bad as he was, at least Walter Freed (R) got some things passed, fer Crissake') has shown an astounding lack of leadership on the issue, as with most issues. This is the only explanation that makes sense, because it's not like these people were going to face some harsh electoral consequences back home for supporting it. And I suspect they're not going to face anything harsh for not supporting it either. Real leadership would have enabled it to happen beyond just the traditional lefty Dems, same with the "Death With Dignity" bill.
Admittedly, although I support it wholeheartedly, I'm not as impassioned as some are in regards to the impeachment thing, probably because I know better than to hope that Congressman Welch is going to ride in on his white horse and actually do something about it. Perhaps he's too preoccupied with making friends in Washington and not making waves with Pelosi.
The larger issue here for me is the astounding lack of leadership from the Democrats in the Statehouse. They have the numbers to go on the offensive against Douglas, and don't. Instead, we hear Ann Cummings talk about "sending the governor something he can sign." Perhaps I wouldn't be so astounded if they had a supermajority for 20 years and were just getting complacent and lazy. But that's not the case. There is a serious leadership vaccuum in the Statehouse right now. Symington needs to go. The question is, who in the Dem party machine is going to be courageous enough to take that step and point it out?
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!Wednesday, April 25, 2007
Impeachment resolution defeated in VT House
Labels: impeachment, vt politics
Thursday, April 19, 2007
Last minute legislative action! IRV up for vote in VT Senate.
My apologies for getting this to you last minute, but those of you who are in support of Instant Runoff Voting (the voting system in which you mark off your candidates in order of preference instead of just one) are probably well aware of it never seeming to get out of committee in the VT legislature. Well, tomorrow (4/20) it is getting a vote in the full Senate.
If you are indeed in support if this bill, it is important for you to get in touch with your Senators tonight and tomorrow morning and ask them to support this bill.
The full text of the bill can be found here. It's S.0108. You can find the contact information for your Senators here.
Labels: activism, vt politics
Wednesday, April 18, 2007
More runaround from Shumlin and Symington on impeachment
The impeachment meeting at the Statehouse that I mentioned earlier in the week happened yesterday. No surprises, just more of the usual runaround from Pete Shumlin (who walked out) and Gaye Symington. I couldn't make it, but if you're interested in what happened, check out coverage from The VT Guardian, Snarky Boy and Peter Freyne, and Blazing Indiscretions.
Labels: impeachment, vt politics
Monday, April 16, 2007
Paul Krugman and a lesson for the dysfunctional VT Dem legislature
crossposted at Green Mountain Daily.
There was another great article today by the NYT's voice of reason, Paul Krugman, called 'Way Off Base'. It's basically addressing something that's been on our minds for quite a while, the notion that the public is way ahead of the curve on the issues that Dems are cautiously supporting, yet the Dems still fail to get that, as if they're really afraid of some political liability in challenging a president less popular than recently thawed dog-poop in the snowmelt on a Hubbard Park trail.
Democrats don’t have the same problem. There’s no conflict between catering to the Democratic base and staking out positions that can win in the 2008 election, because the things the base wants — an end to the Iraq war, a guarantee of health insurance for all — are also things that the country as a whole supports. The only risk the party now faces is excessive caution on the part of its politicians. Or, to coin a phrase, the only thing Democrats have to fear is fear itself.Exactly. I've said this before, especially when dealing with DLC types who preach moderation and accomplish nothing but enabling the president and his allies. They need to stop behaving like it's October of 2001. The GOP has nowhere to go but backwards:
Normally, politicians face a difficult tradeoff between taking positions that satisfy their party’s base and appealing to the broader public. You can see that happening right now to the Republicans: to have a chance of winning the party’s nomination, Republican presidential hopefuls have to take far-right positions on Iraq and social issues that will cost them a lot of votes in the general election...And that brings me to my second part. The stunning lack of any accomplishment from this veto-proof Democratic VT legislature. Impeachment gets scuttled. Nothing but a meager proposal for property tax reform. We were lucky to get the anti-war resolution. Last session's Catamount healthcare was like a band-aid that still fails to address the larger problem. What the hell are they doing up there?
Republicans will, for a while at least, be trapped in unpopular positions by a base that’s living in the past. Rudy Giuliani’s surge into front-runner status for the Republican nomination says more about the party than about the candidate. As The Onion put it with deadly accuracy, Mr. Giuliani is running for "President of 9/11.”
Is it laziness? Timidity? Do some Democrats apparently not realize what having a large majority means? Apparently Washington County Senator Anne Cummings doesn't have a clue. When not busy knitting in committee meetings, she shared this nugget (on VPR) in regards to the greenhouse gas tax bill that would put a surcharge on fuel oil:
(Dillon) Cummings says the goal is two-fold: First get something the governor can sign.First, get something the governor can sign. Great place to start the negotiation, huh? What exactly does Douglas have to concede when presented with that sort of position?
(Cummings) "There's a great deal of concern that a tax of that kind would be vetoed, and we would then end up with nothing."
Now, personally I think this particular bill, although well-intentioned, was a bad idea and should not have been introduced in the first place, considering how many Vermonters are already struggling to pay their fuel bill. But I use it because Cummings' response is really emblematic of the problem, most notably in regards to some of the other matters in the legislature.
Considering the current makeup of the legislature, it's Governor Douglas who is the one that should be asking for concessions here, not the other way around. Regardless of the issue, the Dems should be forceful and put forth the best possible legislation, and then have the Governor do the negotiating so he won't have his veto overridden. Not the other way around. It's all about the positioning, and to get back to Krugman's point, if the Dems decided to push through a BOLD proposal for universal healthcare, for example, and they just might find that they're not really being extreme at all. Sure, they're going to piss off corporate apologists like John McLaughry, Big Insurance/Pharma and a few conservatives, but by and large they'd be lauded for the courage and as an added bonus, if they frame it correctly, could paint the gov as a tool for corporate interests, which he most certainly is. Most importantly, they'll have taken action on an important issue and worked towards a solution instead of just perpetual hand-wringing.
And the Dems' inaction does not let you or I off of the hook, either. So many of us talk a good game when it comes to democracy, but we need to not just 'practice' it, we need to get good at it. Go to these committee meetings. Talk to your legislator and look him/her in the eye and tell them to show some courage and that you will support them strongly when they do. And that you will make a stink when they don't.
Having a supermajority shouldn't mean sitting on ones ass and not doing anything. It doesn't mean being drunk with power either, as the national nightmare of Republican rule exemplified. It means taking action. It's time to start putting Douglas on the ropes. Now.
Labels: criticism, democrats, vt politics
Vermont: Let's kick it up about impeachment.
For those of you following the Vermont impeachment matter, you probably know that the two people in the legislature that could make it a reality, Senate Pro Tempore Peter Shumlin and House Speaker Gaye Symington, are dragging their asses in order to not make it happen, citing other priorities and such. When considering how little the legislature has actually accomplished this year, one seriously has to wonder what those other priorities can be. And this is rubbed in even worse, considering that Shumlin time and time again expresses support of the impeachment measure, yet refuses to back it up with words. Now, Green Mountain Daily and VT Impeach have been covering this quite a bit, so you can get more background on it over there, but I do want to draw your attention to this message from Dan DeWalt, one of the pivotal citizens adding the impeachment, another call to arms, of sorts:
We are looking at at least 40 citizens coming to Montpelier to demand impeachment action next Tuesday. You folks could turn that 40 into 100, and an interesting news day could be changed into a sea of change. Folks just need to show up at the statehouse cafeteria this Tuesday April 17 at 10 am, (if they come later, it will work too). They will be given information about what they can accomplish there, talking points and assistance in getting an appointment with a rep, and in general everything they will need to be comfortable and effective. they can email letsgoflyakite@yahoo.com for more info.
Labels: activism, impeachment, vt politics
Friday, April 13, 2007
Brattleboro Reformer: Worst president ever.
As a contrast to the droolin' fools who write the editorial page at the Caledonian Record, the Brattleboro Reformer came out with both guns 'a blazin' today: stating the obvious, that Bush is the worst president ever. And they're not letting any of the the players in Vermont off of the hook, either:
History will not look kindly on House Speaker Gaye Symington for her insistence that her chamber must focus on "important matters" and that the House "does not have the time" to deal with impeachment.Hear, hear! And of course, the editorial ends with the important question still as of yet unresolved:
History will not look kindly on Senate President Pro Tem Peter Shumlin, who has talked loudly about impeaching Bush and Cheney, but won't pursue the issue as long Symington says no.
History will not look kindly on Sen. Bernard Sanders, and his successor in the House, Peter Welch, as well as Sen. Patrick Leahy, for treating impeachment as if it were a barrel of toxic waste. Short-term political considerations apparently are more important than the Constitution, which they took an oath to uphold and defend.
Does Vermont want to go down in the history books as standing up to the worst president ever? We, the people of Vermont, have the chance to affect the outcome of this story. We must seize this opportunity.
Labels: bush, congress, politics, senate, vt politics
Monday, February 5, 2007
Well, then... Welch signs on to H.R. 508
Well, then... Peter Welch has signed on to the anti-Iraq war bill H.R. 508, which I've been talking about all week, here and here. From Welch's office (via Green Mountain Daily):
"What is clear is the financial impact of the President's failed policy in Iraq. The President requests an additional $245 billion in funding for operations in Iraq and Afghanistan for the fiscal year 2007 and 2008 budgets and projects $50 billion more to be spent in fiscal year 2009.Now, there's a bit of a discrepancy here in that I couldn't find Welch on the original list of co-sponsors, but I'm reserving judgment until I get more details."Pressing needs are going unmet because of a failed Iraq policy. There will be no more blank checks for the war.
"To that end, I am working closely with my colleagues on tough legislation that demands an end to this war:
I am an original cosponsor of H.R. 508, sponsored by Representatives Lynn Woolsey and H.R. 746, sponsored by Rep. James McGovern, both call for the redeployment of all U.S. forces from Iraq within a six month period and the turnover of all U.S. bases to the Iraqis.
I have co-sponsored a resolution with Rep. John Murtha, H.J.Res. 18, calling for an immediate redeployment of our troops.
Finally, I have co-sponsored H.R. 353, legislation introduced by Rep. Markey to prohibit the President from spending funds to escalate the troop presence in Iraq without specific Congressional approval."
So, this is good, no? I'll be posting more on this as I get more info... Thanks to my fellow bloggers who spread the word about this last week. Who knows, maybe it had an impact, maybe not... and I did see the U.S. House of Representatives pop up on my sitemeter a few days ago, so someone down there is paying attention to this. Or at least curious. But, hey, if it ended up in 50 phone calls to his office, then it had its part.
Now, be sure to call Welch's office and thank him. And now that that's out of the way, have a look at Welch's global-warming proposal, the Carbon Neutral Initiative, something that has gotten lost in the shuffle this last week.
UPDATE: Although, in typical predictable fashion, some in the batshit-insane VT right-blogosphere are already trying to make hay over the discrepancy, it turns out the mistake was that Welch was the original co-sponsor of H.R. 746, not H.R. 508. So don't buy into the hype, these people are desperate at this point (considering Welch has only been there less than a month, maybe if they waited a little longer, they'd actually find something of substance).
Labels: activism, iraq, peter welch, vt politics
Saturday, February 3, 2007
More on the Woolsey Iraq Bill
I've finally gotten some time to actually read the 'Bring Our Troops Home and Sovereignty of Iraq Restoration Act of 2007' (H.R. 508) by Congresswoman Woolsey. As I see it, this is the ONLY bill that House Dems should be talking about, no more of this 'nonbinding resolution' crap, which are basically methods of acting like you're doing something while doing nothing. You can read the entire text of the bill here. Some things in the bill worth noting:
"The occupation of Iraq has made the United States economically and militarily weaker, has made the United States less safe because it has enhanced the recruitment of terrorists, and has diminished America’s prestige and influence in the world.And I love this one here...
The civilian leadership at the Department of Defense has failed to adequately support United States Armed Forces in Iraq, which were not trained to carry out an occupation and did not receive the proper equipment to achieve their stated mission.
Congress declares that it is the policy of the United States—
(1) to end the occupation of Iraq on the basis of the findings specified in section 101;
(2) to accelerate the training and equipping ofthe military and security forces of the Government of Iraq;
(3) to pursue security and stability in Iraq through diplomacy;
(4) to help preserve the territorial integrity of Iraq as a nation state;
(5) to take all appropriate measures to account for any missing members of the United States
Armed Forces or United States citizens in Iraq; and
(6) to turn over all internal security activities and military operations in Iraq to the elected Government of Iraq not later than the end of the six month period beginning on the date of the enactment of this Act"
SEC. 109. PROHIBITION ON PRODUCTION SHARING AGREEMENTS FOR IRAQI PETROLEUM RESOURCES.Kinda defeats the purpose of why we went in there, huh? Now, maybe I'm repeating myself here, but it's time for Vermonters to take Peter Welch to the mat on this, especially considering that he based a good portion of his campaign on ending the war and bringing the troops home. The nonbinding resolutions Welch supports do nothing. Zip. Nada. So, once again, nicely call his VT office at 888-605-7270 or his Washington office at 202-225-4115, and ask Welch's office why he hasn't signed on as cosponsor to the Woolsey bill, if he is really serious about ending the war in Iraq. And remember, be nice.
(a) PROHIBITION.—On or after the date of the enactment of this Act, no department, agency, or other entity of the Government of the United States and no national of the United States may enter into a contract for the development, production, or marketing of petroleum resources in Iraq.
Another thing... if Welch does sign on, let's give him props for actually doing what he was elected to do. But if he doesn't, it's time to start calling for his head. I've already got the spike ready.
Labels: activism, iraq, peter welch, vt politics
Tuesday, January 9, 2007
New McMansion Tax? Good.
I read something encouraging in today's Times Argus. The Vermont Legislature is proposing a tax on new homes built over 4,000 square feet. Be ready for the free-market whine brigade to start complaining: Under the Senate version of the proposed law, those who put up new houses larger than 4,000 square feet would be charged unless their buildings were energy efficient.
A similar bill likely to be introduced soon in the House is even tougher. Fees assessed under that proposal on such large houses will go directly to a fund promoting renewable energy production in the state.Of course, the builders associations are opposed:
Rep. Tony Klein, D-East Montpelier, said he will introduce his House bill, which would impose a $1,000 per-square-foot surcharge on the construction of houses over 4,000 square feet.
"It's meant to make people think about what they are doing," said Klein, who added that to some extent all Vermonters underwrite the cost of energy and other impacts of large new homes. "When they build these homes, everybody in Vermont has to pay for it," he said.
"It's just ridiculous. It's just awful," Joe Sinagra of the Homebuilders and Remodelers Association of Northern Vermont said of Klein's proposal. "We have a housing crisis and you are adding an additional cost on housing."Of course, Sinagra fails to mention that the very real housing crisis in Vermont has to do with affordable housing, not second homeowners who can afford to build a second home over 4,000 square feet. As I look deep within my heart to try and find some compassion for them, it's just not there. Sorry.
I support this strongly, especially on philosophical grounds; namely, there's a huge contingency of Americans who seem oblivious to the idea of taking and using much more than necessary, regardless of the impact it has on society and the planet. Maybe this will, as Klein said, 'make people think about what they're doing.' Or not.
Labels: vt politics
Tuesday, January 2, 2007
Leahy and Welch Would Support Defunding Troop Escalation
Although it still hasn't crept fully into the public consciousness yet, there has been more talk of the idea of defunding the war as one of the only viable options in putting the brakes on it, even though Nancy Pelosi has seemingly dismissed the idea.
Peter Welch and Patrick Leahy have both come out now with the message that any surge escalation of troops can be countered with the defunding option:
Vermont Sen. Patrick Leahy, a Democrat on the Appropriations Committee, is having discussions with other senators about legislation that would restrict the president's use of the military. He said the "only way" a withdrawal would occur is through the budget process.If Leahy and Welch are serious, I think this is a step in the right direction. Let's just say they pull it off, and it goes over well with the public. It suddenly doesn't seem like such a far-fetched idea as a way to stop the war.
"I don't know anyone who believes we'll see an end to (the Iraq war) the way we're doing it now," he said in an interview. "It's time to get out of there.""What will the president do? That's the $64 million question," said Congressman-elect Peter Welch, D-Vt. "I would oppose adding troops," Welch said in an interview. "And I would support steps to deny funding for adding more troops."
If it happens, it's crucial that it is done in a way to insulate it from the expected 'Dems don't support the troops' attack that will come from the right-wing noise machine. As I understand it, this could be done by continuing to fund personnel - and nothing else, no money for new operations, anything. The troops would be sitting around camp all day, but it's a much better option than getting blown up. And it's also very easy to counter by simply asking the Repubs how sending more troops to die is supporting them.
Labels: iraq, vt politics
Thursday, November 16, 2006
The Lofty Goal of Walking a Fine Line Between Two Political Realities (or, How I Learned to Reluctantly Coexist with Some Democrats)
Ok, time for a post I feel that is long overdue. As most of you know, I live, breathe, eat and shit politics. I'm a nerd about it. And, living in the People's Republic of Vermont (which I proclaim proudly), I'm subjected to all varieties of left-wing politics, from the rational to the ridiculous. There's the stereotypical banana-republic-lovin' types with their Che Guevara posters, the conspiracy theorists (I'm even now hearing how the Democratic victory was some sort of Republican conspiracy), left-leaning Democrats, moderate Democrats, activists of all stripes, pointless let's protest-everything-that-moves-types, neo-Luddites, back-to-the-landers,you name it, it's here. And many of these people are my closest friends. And I agree with many of them on many issues, namely that our American system is inherently rigged to benefit moneyed interests, and other than throwing an occasional bone to the masses, it's always been that way, and that a major change and realignment are necessary for this country to move forward.
The idea that we need to have a better relationship with our planet is one I hold higher than just about anything else. Our government's priorities have always been screwed up, whether it's our interventions in the doings of foreign nations or our incessant worship of the stock market and consumerism. Much of middle America makes me want to puke.
I ultimately think that will end up prevailing in the end is some weird synthesis of socialist democracy and capitalism. In principle, I agree with many of the tenets of my anarchist and socialist friends, and wholly support a grass-roots movement to change things. A shift to everything becoming more local-based would benefit all regardless of what side of the political spectrum one resides. I've gotten arrested in political protests before, as well as participated in affinity groups that have been a bit on the subversive side. A glance around my blog attests to whose side I'm on. So I've got some semblance of credibility.
But here's where things differ. I also realize that the current system, even with all of our well-intentioned goals and actions, is not about to come crashing down like the Soviet Union did (well, one could almost say the neo-con implosion was similar, I guess). And so, along with supporting the goals that we on the left strife for, I have made a conscious effort to participate in the system as well as outside of the system. And believe me, I catch hell for it.
A few months ago, Joel Hirschhorn at Smirking Chimp wrote an article called 'Neo-Cons Meet Neo-Progressives'. It struck a nerve with me:
What is now apparent is that we have a whole lot of "neo-progressives," people who have no hesitancy in supporting mainstream Democrats in the name of defeating Republicans. Neo-progressives cannot resist the temptation to support the lesser-evil as a pragmatic strategy, justified in the name of saving the country from yet more years of Republican dominance.Ok, I agree with that to an extent. Now here's where I think he misses the mark:
Neo-progressives seem blind to the fundamental deficiencies of the Democratic Party and its candidates. The concept of a two-party duopoly and the reality that Democrats as well as Republicans are beholding to many special economic interests, are also corrupt and dishonest, and when in power do not seriously pursue what were historic progressive and populist values – all seem now to be lost in the pseudo-ecstasy of anticipating a Democratic victory this year, enough to take over one or both houses of congress. Objective reality is lost in the heat of anti-Republican anger and frustration. Neo-progressives, it seems to me, have let their emotions out-gun their deeper intellectual knowledge and principles. They seem drunk from drinking Democratic Party Kool-aid.You don't now how many times I've been accused of 'drinking the Kool-aid' for the simple crime of pointing out how a Democrat has a good stance on a host of issues, or for dismissing the importance of a party-organizational decision.
Part of the problem with some of us on the left is that we are so disgusted with the political system that we refuse to partake in it in any way, shape, or form. I can't think of a bigger disenfranchisement. I don't know how many people I've known over the years with great ideas and passion, that haven't accomplished one single goal. And I'm not saying that their efforts have been completely for naught; we've made great strides here in Vermont in the past few years on several fronts, such as gender equality, and restricting GMO's and bovine-growth hormone. They're great examples of what good, local politics can accomplish. Over the past few years, nothing has been more important to me than putting the brakes on the neo-con Republican juggernaut. Nothing. It is, without a doubt, the most immediate, dangerous thing I've seen in this country in my 35 years of existence. And the biggest short-term solution, as I see it, is the recapture of the U.S. Congress and Senate by the Dems, which is now a reality. I'm not looking forward to the '08 presidential race. Nobody even comes close to representing my values, least of all, Hillary.
So, I'm stuck in a rock and a hard place. Part of me feels like, at the very least, like many in the netroots, I should do as much as possible to influence the Democratic party in a way that will help to accomplish our progressive goals. It's not much, but it's something, and it's better than not engaging at all, isn't it? The idealism I encounter outside of the system is at times refreshing and inspiring, and other times frustrating. I've said this before; I hear a lot of where we should be at at point 'G', and we're currently at point 'A'. What's step 'B' or 'C'? That, and I think that on the further reaches of our side, I often get the sense that many of us don't have a clue as to how backwards many parts of this country still is. We carry on like we can't understand why our beliefs are so marginalized when they just make sense. And that's one of the things that keeps my idealism in check; last time I looked, there was still a Bible Belt. And Beverly Hills.
I'll still take every opportunity to ride the ass of every Democrat who dares drift rightward (are you listening, Mr. Welch?). And I'll still work with my comrades (had to say it) to organize and press hard for our ideas, no matter how out in left field they may seem to some. And I can do it without selling out or being some 'party hack' as some called me. But it takes a sense of nuance, knowing that yes, not everyone in the system is completely evil (or those who work with them), but to know ultimately that things need to change, and it's not going to happen overnight.
Labels: democrats, liberals, politics, vt politics
Tuesday, November 14, 2006
Peter Welch: Contributions Profile
So, Peter Welch is going to be our next congressman. Have you ever asked yourself where his contributions come from? Well, you can find out at Open Secrets, by the Center for Responsive Politics. There's a wealth of information here, including breakdowns of business, labor, PAC's, etc. You can look up any U.S. Senator or Congressperson.
So who donated to Peter and, based on that, what can we expect? In political action committee (PAC) contribution breakdowns, Peter got 11.8% from business, 43.4% from labor, and 44.8% from ideological/single issue PAC's. So it is a safe bet that Peter will be a friend to labor interests. Hopefully, he will support trade policies that will benefit the American worker, and will not support more NAFTA-like agreements. His top contributors were unions of different stripes; teachers, firemen, you name it.
Of the companies that were in the top, Burton snowboards and Green Mountain Coffee Roasters were ones I noticed. Better than Exxon-Mobil, no doubt. Nothing surprising about large Vermont businesses giving donations to political candidates.
I looked up a few of the PAC's... 'Forward Together PAC' seems to be a PAC set up for the purpose of electing Democrats. I couldn't find much info on it, but 'Our Common Values PAC' seems to be of the same kind. Committee for A Livable Future is another Dem PAC, but its purpose is 'to help elect Democratic Members of Congress who support the policies and principles that will make the U.S. government a partner in building and maintaining livable communities that embody smart growth principles.' That one sounds pretty good to me. Welch also recived $10,000 from the abortion rights group, NARAL.
To be honest, I didn't see anything to disturbing or shocking. I was expecting something questionable to show up. His top industry contributor were lawyers and law firms ($107,650), no surprise, especially considering that Welch himself is a lawyer. He did receive $2000 from defense industry PACs. Not surprising either.. it's small, and there are a few defense industries in the state (it would be nice if he didn't take it, though).
You can even see expenditures there. He spent $34 at Dunkin' Donuts... if that doesn't send up a red flag, what will?
So, what does this all mean? Well, as I said before, Peter's going to be a friend to labor. He's solidly pro-choice. I think he'll work to get contracts for the small defense industry (something Pat Leahy has done quite well), good or bad depending on where you stand on that. And he probably won't support much in the way of tort reform or lawsuits that limit corporate liability (good). All in all, I think it's a mixed bag, but definitely one that is more in support of our values than against. We'll see what happens. Whatever the case, as I've said before, we need to be vigilant with the Democrats and if they don't do the right thing, we'll let them (and others) know about it. There is another whole issue underlying this as well... the very idea of how much money gets tossed around in campaigns and wondering what is expected in return. That's also a big part of the problem.
Labels: democrats, politics, vt politics
Thursday, November 9, 2006
Post Election Thoughts on the Osman Campaign
AS some of you may know, I worked on a VT State Senate campaign for Democrat Donny Osman, a superb candidate, and great on the issues. I don't have the numbers in front of me, but as you know, the incumbents stayed in, Kim Cheney was 4th, Donny Osman was 5th. Republican businessman archetype Jim Parker was 6th (which became my joke du jour, as I was constantly labasted for playing it safe in that one prediction I was sure of).
The Osman campaign was the first campaign I worked on. My job was basically to brainstorm, come up with various tactics to get the word out, and to craft and hone the message accordingly. I also designed the bumper stickers and those blue signs some of you saw everywhere. And I learned quite a bit about campaigns and campaigning.
One of the most profound things I learned was that the poison that infects national politics, and to a lesser extent, our statewide races, was nonexistent in this campaign. Peter Young, the campaign manager, and Donny often tempered my instincts to go for the jugular. I'm not talking about dirty tricks or anything, just a bit more aggression in challenging the others on the issues. The idea of running a clean and more importantly, congenial campaign was going to be the way things were done.
We had some pretty good advice getting out the gate. Early on, we had dinner with former VT Lt. Governor Doug Racine, who offered us some tips on campaign strategy. We also met with the Democracy For America people and a rather popular Barre politician.
Donny worked his ass off, knocking on over 6,000 doors in Washington County. He seemed to have a lot of support in Montpelier. My concerns were the other three big towns, none of which nearly as liberal as Montpelier. Northfield is a tough town for a liberal. Donny even noticed a difference in the demeanor of people in the different towns, depending on the political leanings of the town.
We had a great GOTV effort, with lots of enthusiastic supporters helping to write postcards, stuff envelopes and such. In dealing with the party apparatus (one that I am incredibly skeptical of, and none too enamored of), we listened to some advice and ignored some.
Donny went into the studio and cut a folksy radio ad with local well-known musician, Colin McCaffrey. We went and then put together a short low-quality video on YouTube. When it was well received, we had a professional film another one, 10 minutes long, about the issues, which was available on Donny's website as well as YouTube. Donny's son Daniel also set up a MySpace page for Donny as well. We were trying to think a bit outside of the box (at least for a local campaign).
The frustrating thing about working on a local campaign is that there are no polls, nothing to indicate how you're actually doing. It really feels like a crapshoot. I did a fairly good job keeping my optimism in check. Throughout the race, right till the end, I had no idea if we'd win. I didn't want to be like, let's say, Orrin Hatch's presidential campaign team where you have to suspend reality just to show up to work on the campaign.
On election night, it was decided pretty early. Donny came in 3rd in Montpelier, a big deal considering that all of the incumbents live in Montpelier. He came in first in his old rep district, Calais/Marshfield/Plainfield. We had put a lot of legwork into Barre, I was kind of surprised that our numbers weren't higher there. Northfield was no surprise, nor was Waterbury. Even though it was somewhat somber at our election headquarters that night, I still felt really good inside (and what was happening nationally helped keep my spirits up,as well). We ran a great campaign, and we worked our asses off. They say James Brown is the hardest working man in show business; Donny was definitely the hardest working man on the campaign trail. And we did get a lot of progressive-minded people very excited.
What went wrong? Well, I think we really underestimated the power of incumbency. We were running against three popular incumbents, in a somewhat benign environment (compared to the civil union days). Kim Cheney was also well known, for it was his 3rd run. Donny is well known in Montpelier and some of the outlying towns; many more people don't know him (well, after this campaign, hopefully they do). My own personal miscalculation was the heightened optimism I felt when watching the debates. No disrespect intended to any of the other candidates, but I think Donny kicked some major ass, very engaged, impassioned, and personable. Where I screwed up was forgetting that 95% of the electorate didn't see or hear those debates. If they did, we might have won.
I have my own personal feelings abut the other candidates. In the interest of having a future in political doings around here, I'm not going to let 'er rip. Let's just say that all of them are personable, decent people. Some of them have some pretty bad politics in various areas, and some of them have just been around too damn long.
Running for senate and winning the first time is an uphill battle. It's important to keep that in mind when doing it, but not to let it demoralize yourself. What does the future hold for Donny Osman? We'll see... it could be a very different race two or four years from now. I suspect we haven't heard the last of him. At least I hope not.
Labels: vt politics
Monday, November 6, 2006
FBC Election Predictions
Ok, time for self-aggrandizing pundit minute. predictions...
First, VT Gov. - Jim Douglas, at least 10 points
Lt. Gov. - probably Brian Dubie (sigh) by a small margin
VT House - more seats, possibly a veto-proof majority (let's hope)
VT Senate- I think they'll pick up at least 3 seats. As far as my own Washington County race, jeez, I really don't know. I do think that if mPublishy candidate Donny Osman wins, it will be from bumping off Republican Phil Scott or fellow Dem Anne Cummings. Republican Jim Parker will come in 6th, of that I am certain. Lousy candidate.
National races... I'm expecting a lot of Republican dirty tricks, they've already started. Those and Diebold will cost the Dems a few seats, but I think the Dems will take the house with at least a 10 seat majority. The Senate, I don't have a clue but I think worst case 50-50, and I think regardless, we'll have the Senate 2 years from now.
Of course, like most pundits, I'm probably full of shit. We'll see on Wednesday.
Labels: politics, vt politics
Friday, October 13, 2006
Another Osman video
This is my second foray into video editing, and much better than my first one. We had a real cameraman this time. Check it out, and if you live in central VT, please pass it on. It's a 9:30 bit on some of the issues this election.
Labels: media, vt politics
Wednesday, October 11, 2006
Monday, October 9, 2006
Donny Osman campaign commercial
I put together this commercial for the Osman campaign. I didn't have a good camera, so the sound and video quality is pretty bad, but the message comes across quite well.
Labels: vt politics
Sunday, September 24, 2006
VT Politics - My take on Peter Welch, and the state of liberalism
Ok, going to make that rare excursion into VT politics again. I've just returned from a 'house party' for Peter Welch, who is running to fill Bernie Sanders' seat. Now, for those of you not in the know, in Vermont, due to our smallness factor, we have 'house parties' for candidates at the local and statewide level (I'm sure other states do this too, I just don't know). Anyways, sometimes they're publicly advertised, sometimes private invite. Since I've gotten more involved in VT politics working on the Osman senate campaign, and have gotten to know many more of the 'movers and shakers' (god, I hate that term), I seem to get invited to a lot of these house parties, or 'coffees' as they're called. They are kinda cool, because they give one the opportunity to meet the candidate one-on-one, look them in the eye, and question them... and give them follow-ups if they give you the typical politician non-answer. Lots of schmoozing. And, of course, the opportunity to raise cash.
So, anyways, Jenni and I went to the coffee in Marshfield. There were lots of people I knew there. When Welch showed up, I approached him, and thanked him for acknowedging my Rainville bash letter to the Times Argus. He remembered it and thanked me again.
Anyways, after lots of good cheese, pastry and almost too much wine, I went into the big room to hear him speak. His speech was heavy on the Bush-bashing, but more importantly laying out some of the things he wants to do in Congress, such as bringing the troops home, fixing the Medicare D donut hole, protecting Social Security, and repealing the tax breaks for the wealthy and the oil companies. Welch is a very personable guy, not slick at all, and that was a plus in my book. He's quite soft-spoken, not the Bernie firebrand type.
After the speech, he took some Q&A, and I asked him that basically, time and time again, whether it be torture, war, wiretapping, 9-11, whatever, the Dems drop the ball and roll over, time and time again. I asked him what his thoughts were on that, and considering how unpopular Bush is in VT (the 20's), it would be politically quite safe to take on Bush, and how agressive would he be in regards to holding Bush and co. accountable?At first he was treading dangerously close to being a bit evasive, repeating his plans to fix things. So I followed up, "Peter, that's great, but what about accountability? What about investigations and such?" He brought up a good point that often investigations and such can derail other initiatives and be turned against the party (while they are important, they cannot be the only focus), but also talked about the power of committees, in that they can stop a lot of things from seeing the light of day in the first place. He agreed that the Dems have been too timid in taking on Bush and that he would not back down from agressively fighting the president. So he sounds like he would be an obstructionist to the Bush agenda, which is what I was looking for. Every other question from the audience was pretty in-depth and intelligent, and he answered everything straight on, not giving the stock answer. He's not the pandering type.
Peter's an intelligent, thoughtful down-to-earth kind of guy, with none of the slickness(such as Bernie), which is a plus in my book. Of course, he's not as leftie as I would like but I can be quite far to the left of the spectrum, but he needs to get elected, and I don't think statewide that kind of radical leftism will sell. I donated some to the campaign and also volunteered to drive him around if he needs it. I'll vote for him, and won't feel bad about it, unlike when I voted for Kerry. I encourage you to do the same. I think he'd make a great congressman.
Several people approached me afterwards and thanked me for 'putting his feet to the fire'. Other conversations I had with some of them there agreed that we need to take the gloves off and start getting agressive. Many liberals, for some reason, find this hard to do, whether it be because of political correctness, or the idea that agressiveness is never good, it's too masculine, whatever. Bullshit. I was having some beers on Friday with my longtime friend Wes and spent a lot of time talking about this liberal hypersensitivity, and how it's crippling us. That, as well as an overreliance on magical thinking. Libs often offer up these silly, hippie-dippie answers, with no basis in reality and we get mocked by the right-wing even more, because we feed into the stereotypes. Or we offer answers that are hopelessly idealistic, and don't take into account the political and social realities of America (like the Bible Belt). Enough. I've had it.
That is the big difference between the lib/progressives of today and the 60's radicals. Backbone. For whatever reason, whether because of political correctness or whatever, it's been lacking, and we get our asses kicked on the political stage constantly since Reagan.
These people fighting us don't want to compromise; they want to destroy us, and that se
ems lost on many on our side. Whining and playing defense while worrying about offending people is not a winning strategy, it's a recipe for disaster, and certainly not a way to win anything.
Wes and I half-joked about starting up a think-tank for rational, proactive liberalism, unburdened by magical thinking, naivite and hypersensitivity, and that plays offense as well as defense. We then realized how few people we knew that we could ask to join. But it's time for a realignment in the liberal movement that is aggressive, fights back, and commands the dialogue. In some ways , yes, be more like the GOP, except tell the truth and not make shit up like they do. And no, I'm not talking about self-described 'anarchists' who go to rallies and throw trash cans through windows - they make themselves feel better about themselves and the futility of their movement, and alienate lots of people who might otherwise agree, but I fail to see how they're helping the cause progress in any way. Now, I'm not saying the Black Panthers, Weathermen, SDS, or the Yippies did everything right. But dammit, at least they knew how to fight. It's time we did , too.
Labels: liberals, vt politics
Wednesday, September 6, 2006
Happenings
Hooo boy, was I sick this Labor Day weekend, it started Friday night with the scratchy throat thing, next thing you know it feels like I swallowed some broken glass. I finally went to the ER on Monday because nothing else was open. Turns out to be a major sinus infection, as well as possible strep throat. Still not feeling even up to 75%, but the blog calls me. I had a great month with August, due in no small part to links from my fellow VT bloggers. I've already passed the 2000 mark, and am hoping to hit 3000 by year's end.
I'm not one to jump on the topic-du-jour of the Left Blogosphere, namely because those who make it the topic of the day do a much better job than I could ever do in covering it. But this latest ABC Television 9-11-was-Clinton's-fault-miniseries really pisses me off in a big way. As you probably know by now, ABC is planning a 9-11 docudrama to air over the 9-11 anniversary written by a reputed far-right author, that purports that Sandy Berger, Clinton's National Security Adviser, refused to give CIA operatives surrounding Bin Laden the authority to kill him. This is a total fabrication, as well as other key points in the story. Editor and Publisher has a preview of it, and it's definitely a hit piece on Clinton. Lots of Lewinsky, none of Bush's 'Pet Goat' moment, and his ignoring of the August briefing that said 'Bin Laden Determined to Strike United States' gets a complete revisionist whitewash. Also, strangely enough, preview screeners were made available to right-wing pubs and blogs, but mysteriously, no lefties.
Now, apparently, this is getting quite interesting because some members of Congress are getting involved. John over at Americablog has been following this story dilligently, like flies on shit, so I'd say he's your man to go to read more about this. Think Progress also has a campaign going to put pressure on ABC... I put a link to it right under the 'previously on FBC' links, but I'm not sure if the graphic is loading properly. There's still a link, please click and rant away.
Constituent Dynamics has a great congressional poll available online here. I hope it's accurate, because in the VT race, it's showing Dem Peter Welch with a whopping 14 point lead over Bush cheerleader Martha Rainville. That, as well as an announcement that the national Dems are cutting back a little bit on Welch's TV funding because they are more confident of a Welch victory, bode well for VT. We already know Bernie's gonna kick Rich Tarrant's ass, that's a given. Now if we can just do something about those Douglas and Dubie characters. Who knows, by November if things keep going the way they are, that anti-Republican wave can turn into a tsumami and hopefully take Douglas and/or Dubie down as well.
Speaking of Peter Welch, I was surprised to find a postcard in my mailbox from him today. Not the usual politician-mass-mailing variety. It was a quick handwritten note from Peter himself thanking me for my letter to the Times Argus last week. It was an abridged version of my Rainville. Wrong For Vermont. So There. post I wrote last week. You're welcome Peter, and thank you for the personal acknowledgement. Call me if you need a speechwriter, I'm in the book.
Labels: politics, vt politics
Thursday, August 24, 2006
Rainville. Wrong for Vermont. So there.
Got a few hours to kill before going down to Hartford to go see Steely Dan. Yeah, I'm only 35 but as far as music goes, I'm pretty much an old fart. I'd have to say less than 25% of my music collection was recorded after 1980, hell, make that 1975.
Anyways, it's time to take a look at the GOP stooge that is vying for Bernie's old seat, Adj. General Martha Rainville. Now, the purpose of this is mostly to let you know that as much as the VT GOP would like you to believe Martha's not some backwater Neanderthal Repub (like most of the ones now), a closer look at her shows she is really just another Bush Republican. See, it seems that the strategy the GOP tries time and time again is to avoid talking about issues unless absolutely necessary, because they know that they are nowhere near what traditional VT Repubs, such as the venerable George Aiken, were.
So, lets have a look, shall we? You can look at the bio stuff on her site, I'm going to look at where she stands on the issues, both from the material on her website, and through a Democratic press release graciously forwarded to me from Odum, over at Green Mountain Daily.
A cursory glance on her issues page shows 16 issues, from the Iraq war to No Child Left Behind. Conspicuously absent are two that seem to be quite important to Vermonters, the environment, and gender equality issues. Her energy policy has me quite confused. She mentions often about conservation and weaning us off of fossil fuels numerous times, but still is pushing the 'increasing domestic production' option, which to me, is no longer a viable option. There are many people in this country that simply think the answer to our energy problems is drilling our way out of it. Rainville is enabling this short-sighted thinking, and that mentality is also what is pushing for drilling in ANWR and other pristine, formerly-off-limits places. Granted, there are some good points to her energy plan, such as increased conservation, and the use of flex-fuel or hybrid government vehicles. There's nothing about ending oil subsidies, nothing about increasing fuel mileage standards, nothing about increasing subsidies for solar, biomass and wind technologies.
On other things such as abortion, she supports parental-notification, and is opposed to the Republican buzzword 'partial-birth abortion'. She supports line-item veto, which, considering we have a president that just ignores parts of the law he doesn't agree with, seems kind of unnecesary(anything that gives an already power-obsessed executive branch more power is not a good thing).
On tax cuts, she's taken the words right form the Bush book:
"As a fiscal conservative, I believe that taxpayers spend their hard earned money better than the government. Tax cuts stimulate the economy, promote strong economic growth and create new jobs."
No surprises there, still playing the thoroughly discredited trickle-down theory.
Same on jobs, more form the tired old Repub playbook that's running this country into the ground: "cut taxes, reduce regulatory burdens and reform our legal system". Yep, damn trial lawyers and regulations... She offers nothing new on healthcare reform either, and I suspect that she believes the 'market', you know the one that has done such a great job so far with it, just needs a few reforms here and there and it will be ok. Screw universal healthcare.
Now to be fair, she supports a raise in the federal minimum wage, has called for diplomacy when dealing with Iran, is against the Federal Livestock ID system (a big issue in VT), and is in support of some sort of ethics reform. So basically, she's not a far right lunatic. But, ultimately, what I find so discomforting about her is her position on Iraq. Like all of the assholes pushing the 'stay the course' vibe, she ties Iraq into the GOP 'war on terror' talking point, and what's worse, she sees the failure in Iraq as primarily a failure of our government to communicate:
"A very important element has been missing, and that is good communication on what's going on there... It's very difficult for citizens to have an accurate perspective of the war of our successes... Part of that is, I believe, the fault of all of those involved for not communicating more openly with Americans, or not telling the story of what's going on in Iraq."
So basically, we're losing the war because we're not getting the right spin on those 30 or 40 Iraqis killed every day due to sectarian violence and the 2600+ Americans who have died for the lie. Ok. Feel better?
Apparently, Rainville uses this same illogic to explain away the miserable failure known as the Bush Administration:
"I think his weakness all along has been communicating with people. I wish so much that he would tell more of the good news that's there. There are some positive things happening... We tend to hear the bad news which is a function of how we cover news. I think the help to the Iraqi people that the war has given - I think that needs to be better understood. Those stories get lost, and I think it's important for our nation as a whole to understand all that's going in so that we can judge the strengths and weaknesses better of our president or our congress or our foreign policy."
So what does that mean, Bush needs to lie better? Needs to hide his imbicilic IQ better? Sorry, Martha, that dog won't hunt. Blame the liberal media? That is soooooo 2002.
So where am I getting at with all this? Well, in case you haven't noticed, one-party GOP rule has been an unmitigated disaster for this country. It's been polarizing, and morally bankrupt. It needs to end, now. Bush needs his power checked, in a serious way. And the thing you need to remember, no matter how much Martha Rainville (or Rich Tarrant, whom I'll get to shortly) wants you to think they are 'independent' and 'moderate', they are still members of, and will be contributing to the numbers and power of the party responsible for screwing this country up so royally. A vote for a Repub on the national ticket means a continuace of bad foreign policy. Of no accountability. Of divisive domestic agendas that do nothing to make the average person's life better, nor us better as a society as a whole. Party really does matter in this election, folks. Now I know there is a lot of talk about the lackluster candidacy of Peter Welch, and it is increasingly getting harder to hold our noses and vote for the lesser of two evils, as we had to for Kerry. But you know damn well Welch is not going to be another rubber stamp for Bushco. Rainville and Tarrant will, no matter how hard they try to convince you otherwise. Rainville: wrong for Vermont. So there.
Also, be sure to check out Philip Baruth's excellent piece on Martha over at VT Daily Briefing, called 'What is Rainville Republicanism, Daddy?'
Labels: vt politics








