click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!
Showing posts with label iraq. Show all posts
Showing posts with label iraq. Show all posts

Friday, April 27, 2007

Is VT GOP's "Support the Troops" Resolution a Poison Pill?

crossposted at Green Mountain Daily

By now, in our fifth year of Iraq war fatigue, no single term has been bandied about and abused as "Support the Troops". Part of it has its origins in guilt about the way returning Vietnam Vets were treated by certain people. And naturally, no matter how much one may or may not support what the troops are actually doing, I hope it's still safe to say that we support them as human beings in a difficult situation. And many of us reading this blog know that the best way to 'support the troops' is to remove them from harm's way and bring them home as soon as humanly possible.

Unfortunately, the Bush Administration, as you all know, often views the troops as nothing more than props and political pawns. They talk about 'supporting the troops' every chance they get, yet their policies do anything but, whether it be the Bush-McCain-Lieberman escalation, the atrocities at Walter Reed Hospital, cuts in Veteran's services, insufficient body armor, you name it. I'm sure you're well aware of them. Yes, it's criminal.

So, today I was a bit stunned (but not surprised) to read in the Times Argus that the VT GOP is proposing a resolution that will declare "full support to our troops and their mission in conducting the War on Terror." The TA reports that "The bill seeks to designate May 6 as "Vermont Vets for Victory Day" and coincides with a six-day support-the-troops rally beginning on May 1 through several communities, including Rutland, Chester and Bennington." It's not as simple as it sounds, however...

As it stands, this resolution is not a good one. First, there is the ever-so-subtle insinuation that only good Republicans "support the troops". But the larger problem is it's basically putting one of the biggest lies about the war into a public legislative record : that the Iraq War is part of the "War on Terror" (or more appropriately as Borat would have called it, the "War of Terror"), and it's trying to get the Dems to sign off on that. Gotcha!

Many in the GOP are still obviously drinking the Bush Krazy Kool Aid:

David Ayer, a Republican activist from Barre who helped organize the upcoming support-the-troops tour, said Republicans may be open to some language changes, but insisted that the resolution is nonpolitical and has nothing to do with the Iraq War.

"I defer to the experienced veterans who have been on the ground and have been fighting the war," he said. "They tell me that the war in Iraq is the war on terror. We are fighting terrorists there."

He added that it is important for the troops to know that Vermonters support them.

"It's demoralizing for them to hear some of the comments made concerning the war," he said.
Yes, those comments demanding they be taken out of harm's way are just so 'demoralizing', aren't they? Maybe to those few who still love this war. Only thing missing was the 'so we don't have to fight them here' line.

But the absurdity doesn't stop there. One of the propagandists leading the complementary 'Vets for Victory' tour is none other than retired Lt. Col. Steve Russell...
an Oklahoma man who founded a pro-war organization of the same name. He travels the country now urging people to continue supporting the four-year-old conflict.

Russell, who traveled to Vermont earlier this year to speak opposite of peace mom Cindy Sheehan during the Senate Iraq War debate, was one of troop leaders who helped capture Saddam Hussein in December 2003.

In his speeches, Russell justifies the invasion of Iraq because he believes that Hussein was actively trying to make a nuclear bomb and ordered his military to smuggle other weapons into nearby Syria.
(emphasis mine - JD)

That assessment puts Russell at odds with the Iraq Survey Group, the multinational fact-finding group that searched the country for weapons of mass destruction. The group's 2004 report stated that Hussein had abandoned his nuclear program in the early 1990s and a 2005 revision declared it unlikely that officials moved weapons into Syria.
Yet another war hawk completely unhinged from reality. VT Democrats have already raised concerns about some of the language in the bill, and I'm sure some of them also smell the 'gotcha!' in this resolution. Ultimately, there is nothing wrong with passing a resolution simply thanking the troops for their service and sacrifice. It is just imperative that it's wording doesn't include something proliferating well-discredited ideas, something the GOP has mastered until recently.

Read More...

Monday, March 26, 2007

Sit-in at Sanders' office tomorrow

The Occupation Project, who inspired last week's non-violent protest at Peter Welch's office last week is having another sit-in at Bernie Sanders' office tomorrow in hopes that he will not vote to approve the supplemental funding for the war. From the press release:

Citizen Sit-In  and Call-In at Senator Bernie Sanders' Office to Protest War Funding

Meet in front of Burlington City Hall on Church Street at 2pm Tuesday, March 27 to plan

Walk to Bernie's Office, 1 Church Street, between 2:20 and 2:30 pm


There will be a Citizen Sit-In and Call-In at Senator Bernie Sanders' office in Burlington on Tuesday afternoon to voice dissent about the $100 billion supplemental war funding up for debate in the US Senate. Inspired by a national movement called The Occupation Project and Voices for Creative Nonviolence,  participants from all over the state will be asking Senator Sanders to vote no on the funding approved by the US House on Friday.  Iraq Veterans Against the War, college students, members of local peace organizations, and concerned citizens are all planning on participating either by visiting Sanders' office or calling the office. They will meet in front of Burlington City Hall on Church Street at 2pm Tuesday, March 27 to plan.

They will then walk to Bernie's Office, 1 Church Street, to arrive at 2:30 pm.  Participants will each decide for themselves how long they would like to stay at the office.


I called Sanders' office a few moments ago, and the person on the phone told me that Sanders has not indicated how he will vote. His statement on the website isn't clear, either:

In the coming week, the Senate is set to debate legislation that calls for a troop withdrawal from Iraq. Having originally voted against the war, Senator Sanders has been an outspoken advocate for bringing our troops home as soon as possible. "We have got to use the budget to tell the president that this war cannot go on. We have to bring our troops home as soon as possible," Senator Sanders told Thom Hartmann during his weekly Air America interview program "Brunch with Bernie."
So, if you are in opposition to the continued funding of the war, this is an opportunity to let Bernie know loud and clear.

Read More...

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

Occupation Project targets Peter Welch's office

I'm one of those people who's participated in quite a few marches in my lifetime, and with the exception of one that landed me in jail, I always leave them with an empty feeling, that although there was a 'support group/community' feeling to be gained from it, the reality is that the people in power could really care less about us marching in the streets. And half the time many on the left have a bit of a focus problem, in that instead of staying on task with a single-minded objective, we get the Free Palestine/Mumia/The Whales/Go Vegan/insert-liberal-cause here crowd, and it dilutes the message. So I've resolved not to do it anymore.

One complaint we've heard is that Iraq protesters don't really go far enough. Many people have singled out the people who vigil in front of the Federal Building in Montpelier every week. Although I thoroughly respect the people who do it, and would never say they shouldn't, I am inclined to agree with the critics in terms of its lack of any real effectiveness.

It's a much different world than it was thirty years ago. The idea of civil disobedience, of really laying one's body on the line, sometimes at the risk of bodily harm was something that, up until recently, has had a rich tradition in the United States, and you don't have to go back to Henry Thoreau to see it. Just go back 30 or 40 years.

Well, anyways, thankfully, some people haven't forgotten. Enter the Occupation Project. The O.P. is a coalition of several anti-war organizations such as Veterans for Peace, United for Peace and Justice, CODE PINK, and many others, whose objective is :

"a campaign of sustained nonviolent civil disobedience aimed at ending the U.S. war in and occupation of Iraq. The campaign will begin the first week of February 2007 with occupations at the offices of Representatives and Senators who refuse to pledge to vote against additional war funding."
And I'm pleased to report to those of you who are hungering for a more direct, somewhat confrontational activism, the Occupation Project has targeted Peter Welch's office, this Wednesday, March 21st. They'll be meeting at at the Peace and Justice Center in Burlington at noon, where they will then proceed to Peter Welch's office. Anyone of our readers that attend, please post something in the comments with your experiences, if you feel so inclined.

Read More...

Monday, March 5, 2007

Frank Rich on Hillary

(crossposted at Green Mountain Daily.)

The NYT's Frank Rich, one of their better columnists, really tackles one of the biggest problems facing Hillary Clinton. In his 'Bring Back the Politics of Personal Destruction', he asks the question that Hillary should be asked every single day until the race is over:

The issue is not that Mrs. Clinton voted for the war authorization in 2002 or that she refuses to call it a mistake in 2007. Those are footnotes. The larger issue is judgment, then and now. Take her most persistent current formulation on Iraq: "Obviously, if we knew then what we know now, there wouldn't have been a vote and I certainly wouldn't have voted that way." It's fair to ask: Knew what then? Not everyone was so easily misled by the White House's manipulated intelligence and propaganda campaign. Some of her fellow leaders in Washington - not just Mr. Obama out in Illinois, not just Al Gore out of power - knew plenty in the fall of 2002. Why didn't she?
Why didn't she indeed? The one frustrating thing about this is, isn't a little too late to be asking this question? I was asking it of John Kerry back in '04. That's why John Edward's mea culpa doesn't hold water with me.So many of us knew how bogus this war was from the get go. All it took was a bit of time to seek out the facts. And almost all of what we were saying back then has turned out to be true. How did so many in the Senate and Congress, with all of the resources they have that we don't, manage to miss something that was so obvious to many Americans? That is a question that they all need to answer, not just Hillary. Considering that the truthful answer probably has to do with fear of the right-wing noise machine and being branded 'unpatriotic', I'm not holding my breath waiting for that answer. It seems to be more motivated by a lack of courage, conviction and principle than being taken in by misinformation. And that, folks, should seriously raise a red flag on any of those candidates' ability to lead.

Read More...

Monday, February 5, 2007

Well, then... Welch signs on to H.R. 508

Well, then... Peter Welch has signed on to the anti-Iraq war bill H.R. 508, which I've been talking about all week, here and here. From Welch's office (via Green Mountain Daily):

"What is clear is the financial impact of the President's failed policy in Iraq. The President requests an additional $245 billion in funding for operations in Iraq and Afghanistan for the fiscal year 2007 and 2008 budgets and projects $50 billion more to be spent in fiscal year 2009.

"Pressing needs are going unmet because of a failed Iraq policy. There will be no more blank checks for the war.

"To that end, I am working closely with my colleagues on tough legislation that demands an end to this war:

I am an original cosponsor of H.R. 508, sponsored by Representatives Lynn Woolsey and H.R. 746, sponsored by Rep. James McGovern, both call for the redeployment of all U.S. forces from Iraq within a six month period and the turnover of all U.S. bases to the Iraqis.

I have co-sponsored a resolution with Rep. John Murtha, H.J.Res. 18, calling for an immediate redeployment of our troops.
Finally, I have co-sponsored H.R. 353, legislation introduced by Rep. Markey to prohibit the President from spending funds to escalate the troop presence in Iraq without specific Congressional approval."

Now, there's a bit of a discrepancy here in that I couldn't find Welch on the original list of co-sponsors, but I'm reserving judgment until I get more details.

So, this is good, no? I'll be posting more on this as I get more info... Thanks to my fellow bloggers who spread the word about this last week. Who knows, maybe it had an impact, maybe not... and I did see the U.S. House of Representatives pop up on my sitemeter a few days ago, so someone down there is paying attention to this. Or at least curious. But, hey, if it ended up in 50 phone calls to his office, then it had its part.

Now, be sure to call Welch's office and thank him. And now that that's out of the way, have a look at Welch's global-warming proposal, the Carbon Neutral Initiative, something that has gotten lost in the shuffle this last week.

UPDATE: Although, in typical predictable fashion, some in the batshit-insane VT right-blogosphere are already trying to make hay over the discrepancy, it turns out the mistake was that Welch was the original co-sponsor of H.R. 746, not H.R. 508. So don't buy into the hype, these people are desperate at this point (considering Welch has only been there less than a month, maybe if they waited a little longer, they'd actually find something of substance).

Read More...

Saturday, February 3, 2007

Is This What Democracy Looks Like?

(Note from J.D. -- I've posted this account of last week's Washington protests from two of my friends (Lee Light and Robin Taylor) who were there. Hope you enjoy.)


These are some observations of two 60+ year old women, veterans of civil rights, women's rights and anti-Vietnam movements returning to the demonstration circuit. Because the actions of this administration are so disastrous, we decided that we needed to participate in the anti-war rally and march in Washington, D.C. on Saturday, January 27. Many friends and community members that we told thanked us for taking the trip and said that they were with us in spirit. It was a very cold night on Friday at 10pm when we boarded one of six buses that Peace and Justice Center had chartered to take folks down to Washington. We got on the Montpelier bus and knew only four people out of the 55. Some of the others seemed to be new to the anti-war movement. There were some families and also a church group. Everyone was eager and proud to be representing the anti-war voice in Vermont. We heard of estimates of 500-750 Vermonters in total that went to Washington. We were a proud bunch wearing our "Vermont Says No to War" banners and stickers.

On Saturday under a bright sun and temperatures in the 50's we listened first to church leaders, then politicians, political activists, ex-soldiers, and celebrities. For about two hours we listened and cheered. The main themes of the speakers were to bring the troops home now and not fund the escalation and the occupation. The bounty of caring for the troops, their safety, and care when they returned home came through loud and clear, as well as concern for the suffering of their families. Speakers also mourned the lost lives of Iraqis and their children who have been caught up in a useless and unending war. But there was an underlying message coming through loud and clear through signs and chants that these Americans wanted Bush and Cheney impeached. Several signs read Pelosi in 2007!

But we would like to mention some of what the media didn't cover in reporting this event. There were people from all over the country: Washington, Oregon, California, Iowa, Texas, Michigan, Minnesota, Wisconsin, to name a few. The AP story in the Sunday Times-Argus implied that the organizers, United for Peace and Justice, hoped for 100,000 people and were disappointed. We strongly disagree. At the rally and march we believe we were about 500,000. The park police on orders from the White House no longer give estimates of the size of protest marches and rallies. There was also no mention in the AP story of the `Impeach Bush/Cheney' signs that were everywhere.

After the rally, demonstrators expected to march down Pennsylvania Ave. As folks were moving forward to start the march, people were being corralled through a passage way to the parade route that funneled the 6 lane boulevard down to three, creating a tremendous bottleneck. People slowly edged forward to get in line. Once we were on Pennsylvania Ave. we were allowed to march 2-3 blocks up toward the Capitol and then the crowd was dispersed because we were blocked from going further. This action of police manipulation of the crowd successfully defused the momentum of the marchers. It was virtually impossible to see how great a number of people there were. While we weren't herded into corrals like protestors in other demonstrations in New York City, our effort to send our message to the rest of the United States and the world was definitely thwarted.

Eventually the "march" which really wasn't a march was over. We wondered why we didn't parade down Pennsylvania Avenue toward the White House. We believe we had been allowed to demonstrate under the control of a government that had absolutely no intention of listening to the people. If Congress allows the Bush/Cheney administration to continue to ignore the vote of the American people then we are only living under the illusion of a democracy.

Did the media minimize the rally by underestimating the crowd? Did they forget to mention the outcry for impeachment? Was the coverage of the rally and march downplayed by only minimally reporting the event in the press? Looks that way to us!

Lee Light farms with her husband in Marshfield.
Robin Taylor is also a farmer in Marshfield.

Read More...

More on the Woolsey Iraq Bill

I've finally gotten some time to actually read the 'Bring Our Troops Home and Sovereignty of Iraq Restoration Act of 2007' (H.R. 508) by Congresswoman Woolsey. As I see it, this is the ONLY bill that House Dems should be talking about, no more of this 'nonbinding resolution' crap, which are basically methods of acting like you're doing something while doing nothing. You can read the entire text of the bill here. Some things in the bill worth noting:

"The occupation of Iraq has made the United States economically and militarily weaker, has made the United States less safe because it has enhanced the recruitment of terrorists, and has diminished America’s prestige and influence in the world.

The civilian leadership at the Department of Defense has failed to adequately support United States Armed Forces in Iraq, which were not trained to carry out an occupation and did not receive the proper equipment to achieve their stated mission.

Congress declares that it is the policy of the United States—
(1) to end the occupation of Iraq on the basis of the findings specified in section 101;
(2) to accelerate the training and equipping ofthe military and security forces of the Government of Iraq;
(3) to pursue security and stability in Iraq through diplomacy;
(4) to help preserve the territorial integrity of Iraq as a nation state;
(5) to take all appropriate measures to account for any missing members of the United States
Armed Forces or United States citizens in Iraq; and
(6) to turn over all internal security activities and military operations in Iraq to the elected Government of Iraq not later than the end of the six month period beginning on the date of the enactment of this Act"
And I love this one here...
SEC. 109. PROHIBITION ON PRODUCTION SHARING AGREEMENTS FOR IRAQI PETROLEUM RESOURCES.
(a) PROHIBITION.—On or after the date of the enactment of this Act, no department, agency, or other entity of the Government of the United States and no national of the United States may enter into a contract for the development, production, or marketing of petroleum resources in Iraq.
Kinda defeats the purpose of why we went in there, huh? Now, maybe I'm repeating myself here, but it's time for Vermonters to take Peter Welch to the mat on this, especially considering that he based a good portion of his campaign on ending the war and bringing the troops home. The nonbinding resolutions Welch supports do nothing. Zip. Nada. So, once again, nicely call his VT office at 888-605-7270 or his Washington office at 202-225-4115, and ask Welch's office why he hasn't signed on as cosponsor to the Woolsey bill, if he is really serious about ending the war in Iraq. And remember, be nice.

Another thing... if Welch does sign on, let's give him props for actually doing what he was elected to do. But if he doesn't, it's time to start calling for his head. I've already got the spike ready.

Read More...

Thursday, February 1, 2007

URGENT: Time to Put the Screws to Welch on the War. Here's how.

As you probably know, Sen. Russ Feingold has introduced legislation that will essentially cut off funding for the war after 6 months and call for a redeployment of troops from Iraq. This is not some mushy non-binding symbolic resolution, it is the real deal. Leahy has already signed on as a co-sponsor, and I'm sure Bernie will too, if he hasn't already. Here's the fact sheet for the bill, be sure to read it here.

Anyways, as we hear all the talk of Welch not going far enough, etc. , here's how to put him to the test. Call his VT office at 888-605-7270 or his Washington office at 202 225-4115 and tell them that you want Welch to publicly express support of Feingold's resolution bill, and that 'symbolic resolutions' are meaningless, and don't go far enough. And remember, be nice.

UPDATE: Congresswoman Lynn Woolsey is sponsoring a bill on the house side (Bring Our Troops Home and Sovereignty of Iraq Restoration Act of 2007) that is similar to Feingold's. Here are the cosponsors:Barbara Lee (CA), Maxine Waters (CA), Diane Watson (CA), James McGovern (MA), Barney Frank (MA), Raul Grijalva (AZ), Chaka Fattah (PA), Jerrold Nadler (NY), John Conyers Jr. (MI), Wm. Lacy Clay (MO), Steve Cohen (TN), Maurice Hinchey (NY), Bob Filner (CA), Dennis Kucinich (OH), Donald Payne (NJ) and Sheila Jackson-Lee (TX).

Call Welch and demand him to co-sponsor this important legislation.

Please post your experiences in the comments section.

Read More...

Saturday, January 20, 2007

21 U.S. Soldiers Died in Iraq Today

21 more died for the lie. Surge on.

Read More...

Tuesday, January 9, 2007

Kennedy, Uygur on the Escalation

I have a bit of a love/hate relationship with the big lefty blogs, my main issue being the sometime excesses of Dem rah-rah cheerleading. But there were two good diaries over at Kos today worth looking at. First, one by Ted Kennedy (yeah, Ted Kennedy), about legislation he will propose, short and sweet:

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

Section 1. Prohibition on use of funds for escalation of United States forces in Iraq.

Notwithstanding any other provision of law, no Federal funds may be obligated or expended by the United States Government to increase the number of United States forces in Iraq above the level for such forces which existed as of January 1, 2007, without a specific authorization of Congress by law for such an increase.

Also, a non-atheist related entry from Cenk Uygur, 'The White House Threatens to Ignore Congress."
"This is the stuff constitutional crises are made of. This president has been unabashedly breaking and reinterpreting the law to suit his needs for years now. He does out in the open. He does it with the flimsiest of explanations. And he rubs everyone's face in it.

He is in direct violation of FISA - he knows it, we all know it, and no one does a thing about it (except the previous Republican Congress that tried to make it legal retroactively and Senator Feingold's motion for censure). He now claims the right to violate the new postal reform bill - right after he signed it into effect. Laws don't apply to him. He has magical executive authority.

You know what this kind of "executive authority" used to be called before? The divine right of kings, dictatorial power, authoritarian rule. I would like anyone to explain how a president in our constitutional form of government can claim the right to ignore laws passed by the legislative branch."

Read More...

Tuesday, January 2, 2007

Leahy and Welch Would Support Defunding Troop Escalation

Although it still hasn't crept fully into the public consciousness yet, there has been more talk of the idea of defunding the war as one of the only viable options in putting the brakes on it, even though Nancy Pelosi has seemingly dismissed the idea.

Peter Welch and Patrick Leahy have both come out now with the message that any surge escalation of troops can be countered with the defunding option:

Vermont Sen. Patrick Leahy, a Democrat on the Appropriations Committee, is having discussions with other senators about legislation that would restrict the president's use of the military. He said the "only way" a withdrawal would occur is through the budget process.


"I don't know anyone who believes we'll see an end to (the Iraq war) the way we're doing it now," he said in an interview. "It's time to get out of there."

"What will the president do? That's the $64 million question," said Congressman-elect Peter Welch, D-Vt. "I would oppose adding troops," Welch said in an interview. "And I would support steps to deny funding for adding more troops."

If Leahy and Welch are serious, I think this is a step in the right direction. Let's just say they pull it off, and it goes over well with the public. It suddenly doesn't seem like such a far-fetched idea as a way to stop the war.

If it happens, it's crucial that it is done in a way to insulate it from the expected 'Dems don't support the troops' attack that will come from the right-wing noise machine. As I understand it, this could be done by continuing to fund personnel - and nothing else, no money for new operations, anything. The troops would be sitting around camp all day, but it's a much better option than getting blown up. And it's also very easy to counter by simply asking the Repubs how sending more troops to die is supporting them.

Read More...

Tuesday, December 19, 2006

Little Green Footballs and Rosemarie Jackowski

The far right Little Green Footballs website, which I usually refer to as the 'used, discarded condom of American history' has been talking trash about Rosemarie Jackowski, the Vermont grandmother arrested three years ago in a peaceful anti-war protest. Well, Ed Garcia over at Green Mountain Daily has had enough. Warning: some graphic photos and language, but some really powerful stuff.

Read More...