click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!

Wednesday, March 7, 2007

James Randi's Million Dollar Challenge

If you're not familiar with James Randi, you should be. He's made his life's work out of debunking paranormal hoaxes and such. He's best known for offering a prize of one million dollars to any person who can demonstrate psychic ability or paranormal activity in a controlled setting.Here's a list of phenomena, which demonstrated, would win one the money:

Dowsing. ESP. Precognition. Remote Viewing. Communicating with the Dead and/or "Channeling". Violations of Newton's Laws of Motion (Perpetual Motion Devices). Homeopathy. Chiropractic Healing (beyond back/joint problems). Faith Healing. Psychic Surgery. Astrology. Therapeutic Touch (aka "TT"). Qi Gong. Psychokinesis (aka "PK"). The Existence of Ghosts. Precognition & Prophecy. Levitation. Physiognomy. Psychometry. Pyramid Power. Reflexology. Applied Kinesiology (aka "AK"). Clairvoyance. The Existence of Auras. Graphology. Numerology. Palmistry. Phrenology.
The money's still there, if that tells you anything. Anyways, I added the James Randi Educational Foundation to the blogroll. It's a great site, where you can read about how psychics convince people that they know what they know when they really don't. Randi spent many years as a magician and a mentalist (kind of like a psychic), so he knows all of the tricks of the trade. Currently, there's a good piece on all of the 'woo-woo ideas' that seem to be on Oprah all of the time. Have a look.

Read More...

Funeral for the Second Vermont Republic

Cathy Resmer did a great article in the new Seven Days... 'Funeral for the Second Vermont Republic?' Seems like their little get-together was a bit lonely.

The mood was more somber last Sunday, when seven SVR supporters — including founder Thomas Naylor, his son, and Jim Hogue, dressed in period garb as Ethan Allen — huddled in the snow around Allen’s gravesite in Burlington for a second mock funeral. Naylor opened the short ceremony by playing a recording of Chopin’s death march.

Turns out the deceased may as well have been SVR itself. The drop in attendance and change in tone is the result of a recent controversy; as reported here last week, in early February, Vermont bloggers began questioning SVR’s ties to white supremacist groups such as the League of the South. The Southern Poverty Law Center classifies LOS as a hate group.
Naylor also got caught lying about why the Langdon St event was moved:
Naylor says he was told the collective that runs the Montpelier cafĂ© was “skittish” about hosting his event, so he decided to relocate rather than feel unwelcome.

Langdon Street collective member Wes Hamilton offers a slightly different spin — “My interpretation was that they didn’t feel comfortable with possibly being confronted,” he says.
It's funny, because I remember when the possibility of it being cancelled by the LSC folks came up, they decided against it for the very reason that it would give people a chance to ask questions, something that Naylor was apparently afraid of doing.

I know, I know, we're all pretty tired of hearing about this now. I keep hoping that every time I write about it will be the last time. I'm guessing that this will probably be the last one for a while.

As Thomas Naylor continues into the twilight years of his life, he will most undoubtedly continue to blame this on us nasty bloggers. I'm sure he wil curse John Odum on his deathbed. It is really sad that a man with the academic credentials and intelligence of Naylor seems to be so incapable of looking inward to why his dream that offered hope to some so quickly turned into a bad one. Here's to hoping he figures it out.

Read More...

Tuesday, March 6, 2007

Great feature on Spaghetti Westerns

Stumbled across a rather extensive overview of the spag westerns here. And some fantastic reviews here.

Read More...

A red flag on John Edwards

You know, I've often thought a lot lately about the blogosphere's ongoing obsession with which corporate stooge is going to replace our current corporate stooge in 2008. By and large, I've tuned most of it out. I don' t want to really get into it until primary season is just around the corner, and, as usual the candidates so far that interest me are 'none of the above'.

Nevertheless, I read something today in Huff Post about John Edwards that may be of interest to the FBC readers who put the separation of church and state at the top of their lists. The article is mostly benign, focusing on how John Edwards believed Jesus would be appalled at the way this country was being run. Putting aside the question of whether or not Jesus actually existed, I'm inclined to agree with him. But then he said something that made my alarm bells go off:

Edwards also said he was against teacher-led prayers in public schools, but he added that "allowing time for children to pray for themselves, to themselves, I think is not only OK, I think it's a good thing."
No, it's not. My objections to this (and school prayer in general) stem not just from the fact that we are a secular nation, but the idea that I feel many proponents of school prayer want it as a way to validate their belief system in the public sphere, and in a subtle way, I view it as a form of evangelizing. It comes down to this: there is no reason whatsoever a prayer needs to be said in a public school. Kids are there to learn, not to pray. If a daily prayer is so important, they can say it before they come to school, and they can again when they go home. Hell, I don't care if the need to pray overwhelms them like a diarrhea attack and they need to run to the toilet stall to pray. That's fine, because it remains a personal, private matter. Plus, if you really want to get into it, praying in school is the last thing Jesus would have wanted:

"And when thou prayest, thou shalt not be as the hypocrites are: for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and in the corners of the streets, that they may be seen of men....when thou prayest, enter into thy closet and when thou has shut thy door, pray to thy Father which is in secret...." - Matthew 6:5-6

Yeah, I'm one of those atheists that have actually read the Bible. This is one of the many, many passages the fundies conveniently like to ignore so they can continue to behave badly. Like I said, just as Jesus was turned off by the public professions of faith by the Pharisees and Sadducees, I can't help but think he would have thought the same of the subtle evangelizing that school prayer is a manifestation of.

So back to Edwards. He is obviously a man of faith, and he seems to be more of the mindset of using his faith to help, not harm, unlike Falwell, Dobson and Co. Knowing full well that one cannot get elected in this country without a bit of God-ass-kissing, I'm aware of how limited our choices are. But this kind of talk from Edwards gives all of us supportive of church-state separation pause for concern about how this mindset might affect other areas of policy under a potential Edwards administration.

Read More...

Monday, March 5, 2007

VDB on the Blogger Meetup

Philip Baruth at Vermont has a hilarious take on the less-than-photogenic crowd at last Saturday's blogger meetup. Can you believe that many of these people aren't single?

Read More...

Rob Williams jumps the SVR ship

Rob Williams, the editor of VT Commons, is leaving Second Vermont Republic. Also, Bill McKibben's articles are no longer on the VT Commons site. He's unequivocally one of the good guys, so I'm not surprised by that at all. So that pretty much leaves Papa Naylor and that's about it. Rowley has more.

Read More...

Naylor in the Burlington Freeps

SVR's guru Thomas Naylor had an op-ed in the Burlington Free Press today. Interesting thing is, the raving lunatic we've heard from lately is nowhere to be seen. It' s his typical shtick on why we need secession, nothing in it that I really disagree with, to be honest. But he asks a vital question that cannot go unanswered...

Is it possible that out of the ashes of the first Vermont Republic a Second Vermont Republic might emerge?
Not any one with you or your Neo-Confederate buddies steering that ship, buddy. Maybe it's time for someone to form the 'New Second Vermont Republic', or the 'Confederacy-free Second Vermont Republic'. That funeral ceremony you had over the weekend? It was yours, pal.

Read More...

Frank Rich on Hillary

(crossposted at Green Mountain Daily.)

The NYT's Frank Rich, one of their better columnists, really tackles one of the biggest problems facing Hillary Clinton. In his 'Bring Back the Politics of Personal Destruction', he asks the question that Hillary should be asked every single day until the race is over:

The issue is not that Mrs. Clinton voted for the war authorization in 2002 or that she refuses to call it a mistake in 2007. Those are footnotes. The larger issue is judgment, then and now. Take her most persistent current formulation on Iraq: "Obviously, if we knew then what we know now, there wouldn't have been a vote and I certainly wouldn't have voted that way." It's fair to ask: Knew what then? Not everyone was so easily misled by the White House's manipulated intelligence and propaganda campaign. Some of her fellow leaders in Washington - not just Mr. Obama out in Illinois, not just Al Gore out of power - knew plenty in the fall of 2002. Why didn't she?
Why didn't she indeed? The one frustrating thing about this is, isn't a little too late to be asking this question? I was asking it of John Kerry back in '04. That's why John Edward's mea culpa doesn't hold water with me.So many of us knew how bogus this war was from the get go. All it took was a bit of time to seek out the facts. And almost all of what we were saying back then has turned out to be true. How did so many in the Senate and Congress, with all of the resources they have that we don't, manage to miss something that was so obvious to many Americans? That is a question that they all need to answer, not just Hillary. Considering that the truthful answer probably has to do with fear of the right-wing noise machine and being branded 'unpatriotic', I'm not holding my breath waiting for that answer. It seems to be more motivated by a lack of courage, conviction and principle than being taken in by misinformation. And that, folks, should seriously raise a red flag on any of those candidates' ability to lead.

Read More...

Sunday, March 4, 2007

The crazy things...

Good post by Paul over at Alien and Sedition, ' Yeah, They Pretty Much ARE That Crazy'. It's about some nutty polls that have been floating out in the right-wingnuttia blogosphere . Some choice questions:

1) Do you think the surge should go forward?
Yes (61) -- 97% No (2) -- 3%

2) Do you think that a majority of Democrats in Congress would like to see us lose in Iraq for political reasons?
Yes (53)-- 84% No (10) -- 16%

3) Do you believe that the wall on the border will ever actually be completed?
Yes (6) -- 10% No (56) -- 90%

4) Do you think mankind is the primary cause of global warming?
Yes (0) -- 0% No (59) -- 100%


Read More...

Steely Dan - Aja, Hartford '06

Stumbled upon a pretty decent audience video from that Steely Dan show that Jenni and I saw last summer, the epic 'Aja'. Great drum solo, too.

It' s funny, at the Burlington blogger meetup last night, the issue of nerdiness/dorkiness came up (with a room full of bloggers? Say it isn't so!). Although I've repressed mine quite well, my music selections on the blog here reveal a bit too much sometimes. Enjoy...



Unless Second Vermont Republic does something else stupid (which seems to have been par for the course lately), things will get back to normal around here this week. Or not.

Read More...

Saturday, March 3, 2007

New Snow Photoblog


Well, the storm kept Jenni's N.Y. friends away from her 30th birthday party last night, but plenty of people were still here crammed in our tiny house. Woke up this morning to some nice scenery in the yard.

Read More...

Thursday, March 1, 2007

Update from Rowley on SVR's Poll (UPDATED)

According to SVR guru Thomas Naylor, us critics of SVR are motivated by our fear their success, based on the 48 (8%) people who favored secession in that poll that Naylor loves to brag about. From Rowley, at VT Secession:

In a statewide random sample of over 600 eligible voters, two-thirds of the respondents expressed the view that the U.S. government has become unresponsive to the needs of individual Vermonters...

...According to the person responsible for UVM's 2006 Vermonter Poll, the data was collected for SVR. The poll that SVR has repeatedly referred to without ever once providing specific details as to the questions, question order, results or the fact that they were the "client" in the first place, was their poll all along and not, as they have tried to lead the press and the public to believe, a UVM poll. UVM's CRS merely collected the data for SVR...
Seriously, are these people on-the-level about anything? Ok, one poll, commissioned by SVR, not UVM, and we have Naylor going on about how '40,000 Vermonters favor secesssion.' Quite a leap to extrapolate 40,000 from 48, no? What do most Vermonters really think when it comes to secession and more specifically, the Second Vermont Republic? FBC uses cutting-edge, state-of-the-art technology to give you the answer...

UPDATE: Rowley has the actual poll questions and results here.

Read More...

Wednesday, February 28, 2007

Free cigar to first hundred answers, call now!


What movie is this from?

Extra credit: What recent popular movie (last few years) was heavily influenced by this?

See the comments for the answer as well as a few more pointless trivia questions. I think I'm gonna do a weekly installment of this. God help you.

Read More...

Science Watch: More on Magnet 'Therapy'

If you've been coming here for a while you might remember this post I did last December about bogus 'magnet therapy'. I was poking around the 'Healthy Skeptic' over at CSICOP's website, and there was a brief article about magnetic shoe insoles. Guess what? They don't work any differently than the non-magnetic variety:

In a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association in 2003, Dr. Mark Winemiller and colleagues at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota, tested magnetic and nonmagnetic insoles on 101 patients with foot pain. (Fifty-seven patients received magnetic insoles, the others received regular insoles — and neither scientist nor patient knew who was getting what.)

After wearing the insoles daily for eight weeks, both groups of patients reported pain relief, but the run-of-the-mill insoles worked just as well as the magnetic variety.

The good news about magnetic insoles is that they can ease foot pain by providing cushioning and support — just like regular insoles. "If you're going to get an insole," Winemiller says, "I wouldn't bother with a magnet."

As I pointed out in my previous post on this, there's no concrete supportive evidence that magnetic fields affect the iron in the blood, which is the basis for many of the claims of the effectiveness of magnet therapy (see that previous post of mine for more on that). I can see why some people might believe it, because on the surface, it sounds like it makes sense. But it doesn't really work that way.

Read More...

Christofascist Idiot Watch Update! Late Feb. edition

Is it just me or is the Religious Right a bit quieter since the November elections? Not quiet enough. A legislator in Tennessee is trying to force the creation vs. evolution debate into the forefront again, this time by having the state Education Commissioner answer, once and for all, whether there is a 'Supreme Being' that created the universe.

As the resolution is written, if Seivers does answer no to the first question - stating that the universe was not created by a Supreme Being - she would be offered "the General Assembly's admiration for being able to decide conclusively a question that has long perplexed and occupied the attention of scientists, philosophers, theologians, educators and others."

But if she answers yes, or states that the answer to the creation of the universe is uncertain, then there is a follow-up question that must also be answered: Why is creationism not being taught in Tennessee schools?

Wow, how clever. They still haven't gotten over that monkey trial thing down there, apparently. Or grasped the definition of the word, "science", for that matter:

Finney said there is no doubt in his own mind that everything in the universe, including human beings, was created by a Supreme Being.

"There has never been any proof offered that Darwin's theory of evolution is correct," he said.

Uh, okay. If you say so. Curious how the article also gives us the intertwining of the words 'creationism' and 'intelligent design'. I thought ID wasn't religious? Who knew?

Next up, WorldNut Daily is reporting of the heads exploding over the James Cameron documentary about the alleged Jesus tomb thing. Brent Bozell, head of the right-wing crybaby media watch group, Media Research Center:

"Now it's the 'tomb' of Jesus," Bozell said. "What they're really doing is attacking Christianity. The title of the documentary ought to be 'Discovery Channel Says Christianity Is a Fraud' – but they don't have the guts to say it."

Knight told WND that the danger is that people will believe what they see. "We saw this with the 'Da Vinci Code.' People bought into the alleged historical accuracy of claims, made even in a work of fiction, so when a documentary comes along, posing as objective critical analysis, that means more people will buy into the absurd and unproven premise that Jesus was just a man and that his earthly remains have been found."

He noted that the "leap" of logic the film forces viewers to make is beyond belief. "All they can tell us is that two of the caskets in the crypt held remains that were unrelated maternally, then they take the giant leap of logic that these two people were married and they were Jesus and Mary Magdalene."

Apparently , Bozell fails to mention the 'leap' of logic it requires to believe the 'unproven premises' such as a man was born of a virgin and subsequently rose from the dead. And the idea that somehow Christianity is immune to criticism and ridicule is par for the course, as well. Seeing how true believers are reacting to this makes me wonder out loud... what piece of irrefutable proof that solidly debunks the Christian mythology would ever be believed by these people? I'm not implying the tomb is the one, but I think no matter how compelling the evidence may be on these kinds of things, there is no way that people will ever accept them, for their worlds would come crashing down if they did.

Finally, over at Smirking Chimp, Mel Seesholtz has a rundown on fundamentalist homophobia and hypocrisy, 'ex-gay' therapy, the 'Left Behind' video game (where players get to kill the non-believers in bloody displays of Christian love and tolerance), and a host of other things that are indicating a lot of trouble in the ranks of the Religious Right, including their ever-diminishing influence. It's quite an extensive good read, so check it out: 'The Hypocritical Christian Right is being "Left Behind"

Happy Wednesday, everybody.

Read More...

Seven Days and Steve West weigh in on SVR

In the newest issue, Seven Days asks the question: 'Is Second Vermont Republic Affiliated With Racists?' Yours truly gets in a tiny quote there. This is similar to the VT Guardian article in that it doesn't try to spin it one way or the other, just laying out the connections, which is fine. It's good that it's making it into print media now.

Steve West, the host of WKVT in Brattleboro, however, has a different perspective. His show hosted John Odum one week and then a frothing-at-the-mouth Thomas Naylor the next. Here's some of what he had to say:

In the opinion of this writer…………..Dr. Naylor’s press release/rant is paranoiac and mean-spirited, and does not indicate a person who is confident in his position. Someone who feels comfortable in their own skin can weather any kind of criticism, especially anything as “outlandish” or “presposterous” as the things Odum posted, and respond with a measure of cool and comparative aplomb. Now, I know that I can get pretty steamed, too, when I feel I’m being disrespected. But frankly, I don’t detect any disrespect in Odum’s words. Rather, I see someone bringing to light some information that should be pretty easily dismissed, if it has not credence.

Instead, I’m reading a vitriolic screed by a man defending his own anti-racism credentials (which have not been questioned), slamming the character of Mr. Odum (who he does not know), and implying that Mr. Odum’s employer should put a tighter leash on him.

No matter what the details of this discussion……….that’s just not cool.

Any hope of keeping the “moral high ground” that SVR and Mr. Naylor had prior to this phenomenon is gone. He has displayed some fairly childish “schoolyard bully” behaviors, and has entirely alienated at least one potential comrade to the SVR cause……….meaning me.

Well put, Steve. I'm tired of it, too. But SVR has really crossed the line and showed their true colors. Not gonna get this shitstink off of them for a while, if they do at all.

Read More...

Tuesday, February 27, 2007

Odum steps back from GMD

If you're familiar with the VT blogosphere, you probably know this already, but John Odum, founder of Green Mountain Daily, has taken a leave of absence from blogging. Basically, his particular line of employment isn't conducive to him being a political blogger, as he invites controversy which sometimes may be at odds with the aims of his organization. Not cool, but understandable.

The latest controversy, of course, stemmed from Odum taking on the wingnuts at the Second Vermont Republic, when he drew attention to the fact that some of their advisory board members have concrete ties with Neo-Confederate organizations, and several are on the watchlist of the anti-hate group watchdog, the Southern Poverty Law Center. Interestingly enough, SVR has ranted and railed against the SPLC with the same attacks that the Neo-Nazis and white supremacists use, if that tells you anything. As I've reported below, SVR's guru Thomas Naylor made the incredibly stupid mistake of sending out a character assassination hit piece on Odum to many, many people, with the intent of causing him trouble at his job. One of the most telling parts in the letter was subsequently removed from the statement on their website...
Now, I don't want to give those people at SVR too much credit for this. Contrary to all the academics, they're not a particularly bright lot of people, as evidenced by the way they've handled this controversy... lies, evasions, lack of concern, and an almost megalomaniacal obsession with the idea that they're somehow relevant to all but a few people. If you read Naylor's hit piece, it sounds more like that of a cult leader with a rapidly fading grip on reality than the respected academic he's known to be,until recently. My point is, don't gloat over this too much, SVR guys... payback truly is a nasty muthah. And there were other forces at work here that had absolutely nothing to do with you. And don't be deluded into thinking that now that Odum's quiet for now that this story is going to disappear. You've just given yourself even more bad press (as if you needed any). And I'm certainly not going anywhere.

But anyways, back to Odum. GMD has and will continue to fill an important niche in the VT political blogosphere. There are a talented group of writers there, as well as many great diarists, so the good work that Odum started will continue. And if you haven't already, come on over and have a read. Post a diary. Help keep it going.

UPDATE: Other VT bloggers chime in...
Cathy at 802 Online
Charity at She's Right
Julie at Reason and Brimstone
Baruth at VDB
Alex at Rip and Read

Read More...

Monday, February 26, 2007

SVR Update over at VT Secession blog


More from Rowley on the latest lies from Thomas Naylor and Co., plus some new information. It's interesting, since Naylor's smear campaign went public, how the apologists have suddenly become silent.

Read More...

The path to finding Jesus....


...may actually have been found, in an archaeological site in the Holy Land.

Although the evidence contained in the film and book is hardly definitive, it is compelling. Inscribed in Hebrew, Latin or Greek, six boxes — taken from a 2,000-year-old cave discovered in March, 1980, during excavation for a housing project in Talpiyot, south of Jerusalem — bear the names: Yeshua (Jesus) bar Yosef (son of Joseph); Maria (the Latin version of Miriam, which is the English Mary); Matia (the Hebrew equivalent of Matthew, a name common in the lineage of both Mary and Joseph); Yose; (the Gospel of Mark refers to Yose as a brother of Jesus); Yehuda bar Yeshua, or Judah, son of Jesus; and in Greek, Mariamne e mara — meaning 'Mariamne, known as the master.' According to Harvard professor Francois Bovon, interviewed in the film, Mariamne was Mary Magdalene's real name.

Nothing in the film or book challenges traditional Christian dogma regarding the resurrection. But it could pose a problem for those that believe Jesus' ascension, 40 days after the resurrection, was both physical and spiritual. And, if further DNA testing were to link Jesus and Yose with Mary, it would call into question the entire doctrine of the Virgin Birth.
I have mixed feelings about this. Most importantly, one cannot rule out fraud, as the issue of the James ossuary illustrates. But if it turns out to be true, what will be the implications? This is basically saying that Jesus got married and had a child, didn't rise from the dead, and wasn't born of a virgin. And I realize many of you reading this are probably thinking, 'Yeah, it's not like we believed those things anyway, what's the big deal?'

That's what I'm trying to figure out. There's pretty good odds that this could be for real, as Newsweek reports:

To calculate the odds, Mr. Jacobovici took the data to University of Toronto mathematician Dr. Andrey Feuerverger. Factoring in the commonality of these names in first-Century Israel, Dr. Feuerverger puts the odds of this tomb not belonging to Jesus and his family at one in 600.

Another estimate, commissioned by Dr. James Tabor, chair of the department of religion studies at the University of North Carolina, puts the odds at one in 42 million. "If you took the entire population of Jerusalem at the time," says Dr. Taber, "and put it in a stadium, and asked everyone named Jesus to stand up, you'd have about 2,700 men. Then you'd ask only those with a father named Joseph and a mother named Mary to remain standing. And then those with a brother named Yose and a brother named James. Statistically, you end up with one person."

But one can tell, even in the reporting, how much of a bombshell this could potentially be:

Good sense, and the Bible, still the best existing historical record of the life of Jesus of Nazareth, argue against Jacobovici's claims. All four Gospels say that Jesus was crucified on the eve of the Sabbath; all four say that the tomb was empty when the disciples woke on Sunday morning. "The New Testament is very clear on this," says Alan Segal, religion professor at Barnard College. "Jesus was put in a tomb that didn't belong to him and then he rose and there was nothing left."

"Good sense and the Bible?" Is Newsweek implying that doubting the historical accuracy of the Bible is somehow 'bad sense'? Are they implying that the resurrection is actually 'part of the historical record', as in 'actually happened?" So, if this story gets legs (as I'm sure it might be tough, considering how many reporters and news orgs won't want to touch this), be aware of the subtle spin that implies that the Bible is somehow accurate in all of this.

It will be interesting to see how true believers react to this. If they try to use it as proof of Jesus' existence, they're also going to have to accept that the supernatural stuff was a bunch of bunk. But it's not like that particular group tends to be swayed by 'facts'. They don't require evidence to believe what they do in the first place, so they might just ignore it. If it does turn out to be true, it's another argument to use against the literalists. I'll definitely be keeping an eye on this one.

UPDATE: More here.


Read More...

Monday Random Photoblog

Behold the eternal wisdom of the nose...

Driving towards Mount Washington last Saturday.

One of my next door neighbors.

Here's to hoping it's a slow week.

Read More...