FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!
Where to start? You might remember a few weeks back, when a certain GOP congressman complained when he was told the new Congress was going to work five days a week (oh, the horror!):
“Keeping us up here eats away at families,” said Rep. Jack Kingston (R-Ga.), who typically flies home on Thursdays and returns to Washington on Tuesdays. “Marriages suffer. The Democrats could care less about families — that’s what this says.”
But now this same congressman has a great solution to end poverty... get married and work longer hours. Think Progress has the video.
Sorry 'bout the light posting the last few days. I built my new computer yesterday and it's taking a while to get it back up to speed (and lemme tell ya, it' is fast). Part II of my Sam Harris critique coming up soon, as well as other goodies. I promise. And as always, thanks for stopping by.
I have a bit of a love/hate relationship with the big lefty blogs, my main issue being the sometime excesses of Dem rah-rah cheerleading. But there were two good diaries over at Kos today worth looking at. First, one by Ted Kennedy (yeah, Ted Kennedy), about legislation he will propose, short and sweet:
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,
Section 1. Prohibition on use of funds for escalation of United States forces in Iraq.
Notwithstanding any other provision of law, no Federal funds may be obligated or expended by the United States Government to increase the number of United States forces in Iraq above the level for such forces which existed as of January 1, 2007, without a specific authorization of Congress by law for such an increase.
"This is the stuff constitutional crises are made of. This president has been unabashedly breaking and reinterpreting the law to suit his needs for years now. He does out in the open. He does it with the flimsiest of explanations. And he rubs everyone's face in it.
You know what this kind of "executive authority" used to be called before? The divine right of kings, dictatorial power, authoritarian rule. I would like anyone to explain how a president in our constitutional form of government can claim the right to ignore laws passed by the legislative branch."
I read something encouraging in today's Times Argus. The Vermont Legislature is proposing a tax on new homes built over 4,000 square feet. Be ready for the free-market whine brigade to start complaining: Under the Senate version of the proposed law, those who put up new houses larger than 4,000 square feet would be charged unless their buildings were energy efficient.
A similar bill likely to be introduced soon in the House is even tougher. Fees assessed under that proposal on such large houses will go directly to a fund promoting renewable energy production in the state.
Rep. Tony Klein, D-East Montpelier, said he will introduce his House bill, which would impose a $1,000 per-square-foot surcharge on the construction of houses over 4,000 square feet.
"It's meant to make people think about what they are doing," said Klein, who added that to some extent all Vermonters underwrite the cost of energy and other impacts of large new homes. "When they build these homes, everybody in Vermont has to pay for it," he said.
Of course, the builders associations are opposed:
"It's just ridiculous. It's just awful," Joe Sinagra of the Homebuilders and Remodelers Association of Northern Vermont said of Klein's proposal. "We have a housing crisis and you are adding an additional cost on housing."
Of course, Sinagra fails to mention that the very real housing crisis in Vermont has to do with affordable housing, not second homeowners who can afford to build a second home over 4,000 square feet. As I look deep within my heart to try and find some compassion for them, it's just not there. Sorry.
I support this strongly, especially on philosophical grounds; namely, there's a huge contingency of Americans who seem oblivious to the idea of taking and using much more than necessary, regardless of the impact it has on society and the planet. Maybe this will, as Klein said, 'make people think about what they're doing.' Or not.
The House Majority Leader, Congressman Steny Hoyer, has scheduled a vote for January 11 on the Stem Cell Research Enhancement Act. Reps. Diana DeGette (CO) and Mike Castle (DE) are reintroducing the Stem Cell Research Enhancement Act (#H.R. 3) in the House, and Sens. Tom Harkin (IA) and Arlen Specter (PA) are bringing it to the Senate (#S. 5.). The bill is the same bill that President Bush vetoed last year.
Please contact your representative immediately and urge her or him to vote YES on H.R. 3, the Stem Cell Research Enhancement Act. If you live in a district with a new representative, it would be extremely helpful for you to call the office directly and tell the staff how important it is for the representative to vote YES. We recommend you call their Washington offices as soon as possible.
Unless you're one of those deluded 'save the blatocysts' types who believes that a cluster of several cells that was going to end up in the garbage anyway (why aren't they protesting the disposal?) has a soul, it would be a good idea to let your legislators know the importance of passing this legislation. You can take action here.
After my next piece on Sam Harris later this week, I'm going to shift gears away from the 'atheist thing' for a while. I feel it's time to turn to some more lighthearted fare on here, or at least some Bush-bashing (hardly a challenge nowadays) lest this turn into an 'atheist blog', which was never my intent to begin with. Between last week's debate with Charity and the Sam Harris stuff, I'm getting kind of burnt out on the whole subject.
There's a good little back and forth over at Smirking Chimp between rude atheist (I say that with affection) Cenk Uygur and critic RJ Eskow. Eskow's been taking on what he calls 'fundamentalist atheism' quite often lately. I don't necessarily agree with him on some points, but he's a good writer, nonetheless. It's a good read.
Ok, as many of you who frequent this site know, I like to quote Sam Harris; what attracts me about him is his basic premise that religious beliefs should be held up to the same scrutiny as any other human phenomenon. If you think about it for a minute, it's not really that radical of a concept. But, as his message and bestselling book, "The End of Faith" (TEoF), have made their rounds and spread his message, there is much to criticize in some of what Harris has said in his book. The two criticisms I'm hoping to address (in two parts, as to not overwhelm and to make sure I do my homework) are Harris' apparent embrace of Eastern mysticism and psychic abilities, and Harris' Islamophobia, intolerance and support of torture. For a few articles to give you some background on the criticism, go here, and here.
Chapter 7 of TEoF is called 'Experiments in Consciousness', and is arguably the most open-minded section of the book. Harris basically asserts that there is still much to be learned in defining what we know as 'consciousness', and that in some ways, spirituality is a way of investigating the nature of consciousness:
"The history of human spirituality is the history to explore and modify the deliverances of consciousness through methods like fasting , chanting, sensory deprivation, prayer, meditation, and the use of psychotropic plants. There is no question that experiments of this sort can be conducted in a rational manner. Indeed, they are some of our only means of determining to what extent the human condition can be deliberately transformed. Such an enterprise becomes irrational only when people begin making claims about the world that cannot be supported by empirical evidence." (p 210, TEoF)
Now, in some of the criticism one can find about Harris', a recurring theme is that somehow he is being inconsistent by being open to the possibilities of psychic phenomena such as ESP, and that he believes that the construction of the 'self' is quite possibly an illusion (which is consistent with many Eastern mystic belief systems). Meera Nanda over at the New Humanist:
"Harris describes the mystical experience as tuning, or focusing, the mind through meditation, fasting, chanting, sensory deprivation or psychotropic drugs, that enables it to overcome, or dissolve, the sense of the self that stands separate from the objects of its consciousness. The goal is to “experience the world perfectly shorn of self… to lose the subject/object perception… to continue to experience the world, but without the feeling that there is a knower standing apart form the known. Thoughts may arise, but the feeling that one is a thinker of these thoughts vanishes. Harris is describing the classic all-is-one and one-is-all experience that mystics and spiritualists have reported throughout history."
I take issue with Nanda's problem with the 'loss of self'... it is a very conservative perspective that I feel is deeply rooted in the fear of the loss of individuality. Harris:
"As a mental phenomenon, loss of self is not as rare as our scholarly neglect of it suggests. This experience is characterized by a sudden loss of subject/object perception: the continuum of experience remains, but one no longer feels that there is a knower standing apart from the know. Thoughts may arise, but the feeling that one is the thinker of these thoughts have vanished" (TEoF, p.212)
Last semester, as I did my research for a paper on the use of entheogenic (psychotropic) plants in native cultures, this theme of 'depersonalization' (brought on by the consumption of plants, in that case) was a common theme. Psychologists found the use of psychedelics a huge breakthrough, in part because of the ability to seemingly break down the ego, and it showed promising therapeutic possibilities, which sadly came to an end after the criminalization of them in the mid-60's. So, I don't think that Harris, in embracing this possibility, is going out on a limb here. He is showing an open mind that, unfortunately is lacking in some of his other arguments in the book.
I don't believe that any of the critics that I've read have read Harris' rebuttal to Tom Flynn's criticisms in Free Inquiry magazine last year:
"The hypothesis is this: if I use my attention in the prescribed way, it may have a specific, reproducible effect. Needless to say, what happens (or fails to happen) along any path of “spiritual” practice has to be interpreted in light of some conceptual scheme, and everything must remain open to rational discussion. How this discussion proceeds will ultimately be decided by contemplative scientists. As I said in my book, if we ever develop a mature science of the mind, most of our religious texts will be no more useful to mystics than they now are to astronomers.
What words should we use to acknowledge the fact that the happiest person on this earth at this moment might have spent the last twenty years living alone in a cave? Any experienced meditator knows that this is a serious possibility. (Indeed, I consider it not only possible, but likely.) What can we say about the fact that the conventional sources of human happiness—association with family and friends, positive engagement with society, diverse experiences of physical pleasure, etc.—might be neither necessary nor sufficient to produce happiness in its most profound forms? This is not New Age mumbo jumbo. What secularists like Flynn tend not to realize is that there are genuine, introspective insights that can be terribly difficult to acquire. The lack of general accessibility does not render such insights at all suspect...
My Sam Harris piece is coming up shortly. In the meantime, a quick photoblog. I've had way to many 'rainy' photoblogs this winter. Gimme some damn winter already.
I've never seen a dog hate being photographed so much. Maybe she has body-image issues or something.
There are times when you find another man in your bed with your gal, but you just can't get angry... but is he reading my Eugene Debs biography as well? The nerve...
First cookbook-worthy photo ever, of some French mushroom dish I made for New Years but would not eat, due to my intense hatred of food mushrooms.
I just added a link to this in my music links on the side. Thanks to a tip from Vermonter, this site will provide hours and hours of wholesome entertainment. Here's one to get to get you started:
Quick blurb here in the WaPo about how some right wingnut group known as 'The Family Foundation' is supporting legislation to make it harder for people with children to get divorced. Perhaps they are finally putting their own house in order, considering that states in the Bible Belt have the highest divorce rates, and big surprise, the secular, more prone to reality-based New England states have the lowest rates. And, no, I'm not coming out in favor of divorce or anything (although I can personally attest to its merits), I'm just really getting sick of the Christofascists continually trying to regulate relationships.
One of my favorite bass players is someone you've probably never heard of - Mick Karn. Incredible, unique fretless player, his style being a quirky, funky one with a Middle Eastern tonality which doesn't sound like anything I've ever heard. He's a pretty lousy singer, as you'll notice when you watch this, but jeez, the bass playing...and he plays a Wal, as does yours truly. I remember figuring out how to play this song a few years ago, and it was a lot of fun. Be sure to also check out the great flute solos from Theo Travis (who's also played in Gong in the last few years).
I know that Keith Olbermann's excellent special commentaries are all over the blogosphere. 'Cuz they're so friggin good. Once again, he seems to be the voice of the diminutive contingency of Intelligent Americans out there. In a time where I repeatedly find myself telling George Bush to go fuck himself several times a day, it's good to have a few eloquent voices out there saying what needs to be said. Watch it.
It would be so much easier if we could somehow sacrifice Bush, wouldn't it?
Here's one of those very few instances that I wish I had a television.I got this in one of my CSICOP bulletins, I'm just going to reprint it here (although I would hardly call what's going on 'non-religious fervor'... if we could only be so lucky)...
The PBS program Religion and Ethics Newsweeklywill be airing a special segment on atheism and unbelief in America on the weekend of January 5th through the 7th.
In addition, the show's cameras were on hand to capture the November 14 Grand Opening press conference of the Center for Inquiry's new Office of Public Policy in Washington, D.C. In a wide-ranging interview, Paul Kurtz took the opportunity to discuss the dangerous intermingling of religion with science and the ethics of leading a good moral life, without the need for religion. Watch for the segment this weekend on your local PBS stations (broadcast times will vary in different cities). From the Web site (www.pbs.org/religion):According to national polls, 90 percent of Americans say they believe in God, and more than 50 percent hold a negative view of those who don’t share their belief in a "Supreme Being." But non-religious fervor is slowly gaining a foothold in the U.S. as some atheists find a way to successfully reach out to mainstream America about their views on the existence of God.Betty Rollin explores how a small group of America’s non-believers, such as biologist Richard Dawkins, author of "The God Delusion," neuroscientist Sam Harris, author of "Letter to a Christian Nation," and actress/comedian Julia Sweeney, are challenging religious fundamentalism through best-selling works and sold-out performances. According to Harris, "The usefulness of religion -- the fact that it gives meaning, that it makes people feel good -- is not an argument for the truth of any religious doctrine."
I'm so glad that George Bush is committed to preserving the freedoms we Americans have, as he often likes to remind us, usually to the point of producing nausea at best, or sometimes violent diarrhea. In keeping with that tradition of reckless freedom-producing, he's produced another one of those signing statements in the latest Postal bill that will give him sweeping new powers to open your mail without a warrant:
The President asserted his new authority when he signed a postal reform bill into law on Dec. 20. Bush then issued a "signing statement" that declared his right to open people's mail under emergency conditions.
That claim is contrary to existing law and contradicted the bill he had just signed, say experts who have reviewed it...
Most of the Postal Accountability and Enhancement Act deals with mundane reform measures. But it also explicitly reinforced protections of first-class mail from searches without a court's approval.
Yet in his statement Bush said he will "construe" an exception, "which provides for opening of an item of a class of mail otherwise sealed against inspection in a manner consistent ... with the need to conduct searches in exigent circumstances."
Bush cited as examples the need to "protect human life and safety against hazardous materials and the need for physical searches specifically authorized by law for foreign intelligence collection."
Now, I'm sure the conservative nutjobs will once again be okay with this, because, you know, if you've got nothing to hide, why would you care, right?. But then again, since many of these people tend to be some of the most sexually repressed members of our society, aren't they a little concerned about what the Prez might find in their mailbox?
Seven Days, our local alternative free weekly, is a pretty good paper. However, I'm not a big fan of their music reviewer, Casey Rea. Although he's a great writer, he has a tendency to find genius in just about every alterna-pop post-grunge piece of crap that seems to set foot in Burlington, as if this stuff isn't the same old angst-ridden poseur crap we've been hearing for the last 13 years or so. But his crap-ometer definitely gets it right every now and then, often with pretty funny results. Like in this review of local Barre band, 'Cellblock One':
With its scraggly mix of dude-rock clichés and undercooked production, the record sounds seriously dated. It’s hard for me to imagine this stuff taking off beyond North Country barrooms, but, hey, it’s an unpredictable world...The band gets quasi-political with “Revolution,” or, as vocalist Matt Coles pronounces it, “rav-o-loo-shaw-un.” Ever hear South Park co-creator Trey Parker poke fun at macho metal? Well, I don’t think this is satire.
One thing that I've always had an issue with in regards to us skeptics, atheists, and such, is that many of us are downright rude. We don't exactly endear many people with our arguments because they are often laced with contempt with our outrage at the both perceived and real stupidity of our opponents. As one look around this blog will attest to, I count myself among the guilty. It is an incredibly frustrating thing to try to communicate with people who are seemingly impervious to reason, when you have people that believe Jesus is returning this year, for example, and they've been wrong over 2000 times, you get a little tired of all the wasted ink and oxygen. And I'm not necessarily defending this rude behavior, but it's hard to bite my tongue when trying to present evidence to people who don't need evidence to believe what they do in the first place (and I'm not counting 'personal revelation' as evidence - there are many holes and viable explanations for that).
Richard Dawkins and Sam Harris, two rather outspoken atheists that get a lot of mention on here and in the press, are the rudest of the rude. And I agree with a good majority of what they're saying, but I just can't help but wonder if the tone were a little different, if it would reach more people. But on the flip side of that, religious belief has been given such a free ride, such an absolution of any accountability in the public sphere (as in having people offer some proof as to why God wants a law passed/struck down), that part of me feels that it is appropriate and way past due time to point out the idiocy of some of what these people are saying.
Another angle, though: it is easy often to rudely dismiss a group, when you look at the collective image presented, as in the way the fundies have a pretty nutjob public persona. It's a different experience altogether when going one on one, as my current ongoing discussion with Charity is going (here, here, and soon here). When there is an actual human element involved (when they're all not James Dobsonlike nuts), it changes the tone to a more respectful one. And that is where our problem lies... just as I know that not every fundie is a complete Ted Haggard nutjob, there is still that public image of that for me, which is reinforced just about every time the religious right is in the news because it's never in the news for saying something with an inkling of rationality to it. And as to our side, I think we run the risk of others, especially those who might be open to our reasoning, being alienated or turned off, thinking we're all a bunch of nasty people.
And my 'Rudest Atheist Post of 2006' goes to Cenk Uygur's 'If You're A Christian, Muslim, or Jew, You Are Wrong'. It's so very rude and disrespectful, yet says what many people are feeling yet can never bring themselves to say. It's great and horrible at the same time.
(note: I've just realized Uygur's post is from 2005... but I've still found none ruder)
UPDATE: A poster at DKos speculates on how Jesus will return...
My guess is that He'll show up in His Hummer at religious right retreat, with a Cuban cigar hanging off His lip and the front seat loaded with empty Big Mac® wrappers.
Jesus will step out of His Hummer, give a big hug to Richard Land, Don Wildmon, Pat Robertson and John McCain and declare loudly, "Time to wipe out those ragheads!"
Although it still hasn't crept fully into the public consciousness yet, there has been more talk of the idea of defunding the war as one of the only viable options in putting the brakes on it, even though Nancy Pelosi has seemingly dismissed the idea.
Peter Welch and Patrick Leahy have both come out now with the message that any surge escalation of troops can be countered with the defunding option:
Vermont Sen. Patrick Leahy, a Democrat on the Appropriations Committee, is having discussions with other senators about legislation that would restrict the president's use of the military. He said the "only way" a withdrawal would occur is through the budget process.
"I don't know anyone who believes we'll see an end to (the Iraq war) the way we're doing it now," he said in an interview. "It's time to get out of there."
"What will the president do? That's the $64 million question," said Congressman-elect Peter Welch, D-Vt. "I would oppose adding troops," Welch said in an interview. "And I would support steps to deny funding for adding more troops."
If Leahy and Welch are serious, I think this is a step in the right direction. Let's just say they pull it off, and it goes over well with the public. It suddenly doesn't seem like such a far-fetched idea as a way to stop the war.
If it happens, it's crucial that it is done in a way to insulate it from the expected 'Dems don't support the troops' attack that will come from the right-wing noise machine. As I understand it, this could be done by continuing to fund personnel - and nothing else, no money for new operations, anything. The troops would be sitting around camp all day, but it's a much better option than getting blown up. And it's also very easy to counter by simply asking the Repubs how sending more troops to die is supporting them.
Interesting piece in the Guardian about a new super-sized labor union to take on the multinationals:
The move, to be announced this week, is seen by union leaders as the first step towards creating a single union that can present a united front to multinational companies.
Derek Simpson, general secretary of Amicus, said: 'Our aim is to create a powerful single union that can transcend borders to challenge the global forces of capital. I envisage a functioning, if loosely federal, multinational organisation within the next decade.'
Amicus is itself planning to merge with the Transport & General Workers' Union in May to create a 2 million-strong labour organisation. Between IG-Metall's 2.4 million members, the USW's 1.2 million and 730,000 at the Machinists', a merger would create an organisation with some 6.3 million members.
Simpson added that multinational companies 'trade off countries and workforces against each other' and that forging such solidarity agreements as have been signed with German and US unions is the best way to combat such practices.
This is a step in the right direction, but unless it is able to move into the third world areas where all of the jobs are disappearing to, I'm not sure how effective it will be.