Odum did an interview on a Brattleboro AM radio station this morning (podcast - here)about the Second Vermont Republic/Neo-Confederate controversy, which is, apparently, finally spreading around. He plugged FBC on the show a few times. For those of you checking in here, I'd like to clarify some things regarding my involvement and motivations in this whole thing, not because in any way I feel the need to defend myself, just simply for the reason of clarity.
Basically, other than picking apart some of the pathetic excuses some are offering in defense of SVR's ties with these groups, and spreading the word about it, that's really the extent of my involvement and interest. I've still got tons of schoolwork to do and shitty movies to review and my snowthrower bit the shit right at the start of this blizzard, so it's not like I don't have other places I'd rather put my energy. Really. Reading the racist garbage of The League of the South is not exactly my idea of how I'd like to spend an evening. The person to see for the factual information is 'Thomas Rowley' over at Vermont Secession, where one can read the facts, verify them themselves if they like, and make their judgment. He's been the one doing all of the digging. Green Mountain Daily, and to a lesser extent, this blog, have merely been trying to make sure the information gets out there, a well as provide a perspective of the complex forces at work here.
I just want to be very clear about something, since one of the main defenses so far coming from SVR/VT Commons has been to 'shoot the messenger'. I have no motivations or desire whatsoever to facilitate the demise of Second Vermont Republic or VT Commons. Up until this story broke, I was a supporter (though not a member) of SVR and a regular reader of VT Commons, and I have a great deal of respect for many of its contributors, such as Bill McKibben and Dan DeWalt, among others. My issue is simply this... if SVR is promoting itself as a peaceful, democratic organization that, among other things, lists in its principles: 'economic solidarity, equal access, tension reduction, and mutuality," but seeks advice from people with well-known ties to people whose xenophobia, free-market fundamentalism, anti-labor and racist views stand in direct opposition to said principles, that's bullshit. It's easy to say that, hey, if you're gonna get involved with and support an organization, it is your responsibility to do the research on them, and there is most definitely truth to that. But generally, when one seeks support from the anti-imperialist, grassroots progressive community, it's usually not a stretch to assume the organization shares the view of the community and would take a forceful stand against the opposing principles, not get into bed with them under the guise of 'advice', and furthermore, say those views are 'none of their business.' It's dishonest, and it stinks. Perhaps SVR's reluctance to take political stances on issues should have been a heads up, I guess.
I'm really surprised that this stayed under wraps for so long, considering the information was readily available for anyone who chose to look for it. I'm even more shocked at the responses and reactions from Jim Hogue and Rob Williams, two extraordinarily intelligent individuals that I've had a great deal of respect for until this happened. They should know better.
The other thing I've taken from all this, is judging from the reactions of some of the defenders posting over at GMD, is that there is a stronger right-wing contingent in SVR than more of us on the left ever imagined. When I see people who are somewhat familiar with the workings of the hate-filled Vanguard News Service ('No Jews, Just Right'), attacking the Southern Poverty Law center, and referring to Pat Buchanan's American Conservative Magazine, The New York Sun, and Free Republic as somehow being representative of 'mainstream media', that sets off some alarm bells to me as to the political leanings of the posters.
And that's fine. SVR is free to be whatever they want to be. There is nothing that says they have to be progressive, egalitarian, whatever. They just need to be on the level about it, and not try to rationalize, obfuscate, attack, parse and bullshit their way around it when some people take it upon themselves to alert the larger progressive community from which they draw their support. That's pretty much it, folks. There's not much more for me to do, and I'm glad about that. It's out there, and people will either stick with it or move on to better things. Maybe it will lay the groundwork for a truly progressive secession movement that the right-wingers would loathe to be involved in. We'll just have to wait and see, I guess.
Read More...
Summary only...