click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!

Thursday, April 19, 2007

Last minute legislative action! IRV up for vote in VT Senate.

My apologies for getting this to you last minute, but those of you who are in support of Instant Runoff Voting (the voting system in which you mark off your candidates in order of preference instead of just one) are probably well aware of it never seeming to get out of committee in the VT legislature. Well, tomorrow (4/20) it is getting a vote in the full Senate.

If you are indeed in support if this bill, it is important for you to get in touch with your Senators tonight and tomorrow morning and ask them to support this bill.

The full text of the bill can be found here. It's S.0108. You can find the contact information for your Senators here.

Read More...

Wednesday, April 18, 2007

FBC hits 10,000

Well then... I had my 10,000th visitor in the last few hours, someone from Ontario, Canada. Took me a year for 5,000, and only another 4 months to hit 10,000, so something's working. Thanks for stopping by.

Read More...

Run, Man, Run (Corri, Uomo, Corri)

Last night I watched the third Spaghetti Western by director Sergio Sollima, 1967's Run, Man, Run (Corri, Uomo, Corri), the first being The Big Gundown and the second, Face to Face. This film is actually the sequel to The Big Gundown.

Thomas Milian returns as the knife-wielding Mexican bandito, Cuchillo. As the film begins, we see him returning from the adventure in the first film, where his bride-to-be Dolores (Chelo Alonso) is waiting to get married. Somehow, Cuchillo ends up in jail and happens to be sharing a cell with some poet named Ramirez, who is just about to get out, where several people are plotting his assassination, because as it turns out, he's one of the revolutionaries working for Juarez against Diaz (we're talking Mexican revolution here). He offers Cuchillo $100 dollars to break him out and to accompany him to a town in Texas, where 3 million dollars in gold is stashed, to be used for the revolution. They break out, returning to Ramirez's hometown, where he is killed by a bandito that he used to run with who is also interested in the whereabouts of the gold. As he breathes his last breath, he gives Cuchillo a newspaper with a clue as to the whereabouts of the gold.

Tomas Milian returns as Cuchillo

There's also two French secret service agents, as well as a former American lawman named Cassidy (Donald O'Brien), and a beautiful blonde Salvation Army missionary (Linda Veras) after the gold. Although not as popular as the 'revenge for murdered family' motif of the genre, this is another one of those 'search-for-the-lost-gold' films, also typical of the genre. The ensuing story involves Chucillo making he way to find the gold, fighting the bandits and eventually the Frenchmen in a final showdown, with Cassidy as his ally.

Donal O'Brien as Cassidy also wants the gold. Who doesn't?

Ok, as far as the Sollima westerns, although by no means a bad film, this is definitely the weakest of the three. Milian plays Cuchillo a lot lighter than he did in The Big Gundown. It never reaches the slapstick stupidity of the "Trinity' films, however. It's just that the edginess he had in the first film is missed in this one. After
watching several B-grade spag westerns since the last time I watched a Sollima film, I can most definitely say that his are definitely in the upper echelon as far as quality, although still not within the range of the Sergio Leone films.

Bush Administration Interrogation technique, circa 1913

I will say this - Sollima most certainly has a great eye for filling up the frame, as you can see in the reviews of the last two films, as well as this one. Whether it be the placement of the characters in the landscape...


Or the landscape itself...


all of his films are visually spectacular in that regard. He makes the most of the familiar Almerian landscape, as well as some shots in some snowy montains in central Italy. My only complaint in this regard is the town set has a very movie set/theme park to it. It looks too new and clean. Overall, the acting was pretty good, Milian plays it light but not venturing into the overacting he is often known for. The soundtrack is listed as being by Bruno Nicolai, but was actually by Ennio Morricone.

The widescreen release from Blue Underground looks and sounds great, with English and Italian language tracks. I watched it in English because the sound was a bit better and the voiceovers were good. It had some great extras, featuring trailers, an old late '60's documentary (38 min) on Italian westerns that shows them filming a few great films, as well as another 18 minute piece featuring present day interviews with Sollima and Milian. As usual, like in every other interview I've ever seen with him, Milian is arrogant as hell, emphatically letting us know how 'fucking talented' he is. Okay.

Overall, not a bad film as far as the genre goes, and it's great looking but if you're going to watch a Sollima western, I'd start with The Big Gundown or Face to Face (if you can find them), then check this one out.


Read More...

More runaround from Shumlin and Symington on impeachment

The impeachment meeting at the Statehouse that I mentioned earlier in the week happened yesterday. No surprises, just more of the usual runaround from Pete Shumlin (who walked out) and Gaye Symington. I couldn't make it, but if you're interested in what happened, check out coverage from The VT Guardian, Snarky Boy and Peter Freyne, and Blazing Indiscretions.

Read More...

Tuesday, April 17, 2007

China will not follow U.S. energy consumption model

Now, it' s off of a Chinese newswire, so like our own propaganda, I would take it with a grain of salt, but there was some encouraging news coming out of China in regards to the future of their energy policies. In a nutshell, they say they are not going to follow the U.S. model, for it would be disastrous:

Xu pointed out that westerners account for only 15 percent of the world's population but used the lion's share of the world's energy to power their industrial processes.

China cannot follow the wasteful western model, said Xu, but would have to invent a cleaner, more effective energy consumption model of its own.

Let's hope that this is actually true. If it is, even the commies are ahead of Bush on this one.

Read More...

Fingers in the Pot: the exploitation of the VA Tech Massacre

Now, not trying to diminish this tragedy of immense proportions because of the loss of so many innocent human lives, but as this tragedy unfolds, I wanna ask my readers to witness the other tragedy here - exploitation from all sides of the political spectrum.

First, there's the obvious - the news networks running this 24-7 for the next few weeks, as they put all sorts of sensationalist spin on it and rake in the bucks, while failing to ask even one important question. Bush will use this one to try to curry favor for him and his sinking ship, and quite possibly use it as an excuse for more infringements on civil liberties. And of course, the media will not even question how a few contrived words from a president who is knee-deep in the blood of innocents in violence and is less popular than dogshit will somehow make anything better.The gun-control crowd will once again use it to advance their agenda (which IMO, the problem lies with our fetish-like obsession with guns and violence more than the guns themselves) and some jerkoff in the NRA will talk about how this might have been prevented if some of the students were packing heat (they can't use the 'stop illegal gun sales' angle because it seems at this point they were obtained legally). The racists will obsess over the fact that the shooter was an Asian (while conveniently overlooking the fact that he was a legal immigrant). We'll hear tons of talk about 'prayer' in the media, yet not one person will question either if perhaps this was 'God's will' or the silliness in praying to a God who enabled it to happen in the first place (kind of like asking your dad to forgive you after he beat the living shit out of you for no reason). And of course, the Religious Right will once again blame this on our increasingly secular culture, perhaps throwing another dig at the gay community like they did on 9-11.

And very few Americans will even bother to ask why this kind of thing seems to happen so much here. Our culture is sick, and there doesn't seem to be a doctor who wants to look at the illness itself... they can't seem to see past the symptoms.

Read More...

Monday, April 16, 2007

Some housecleaning...

I wrote quite a bit today and realized how daunting it must be to show up here and scroll through all of this text. So I added a blogger widget that will allow you to just read a few paragraphs of the long posts, and then read more if you click 'Read More...", all with the convenience of not having to reload the entire page.

Also added Blazing Indiscretions to the Vermont blogroll. Enjoy.

Read More...

Paul Krugman and a lesson for the dysfunctional VT Dem legislature

crossposted at Green Mountain Daily.

There was another great article today by the NYT's voice of reason, Paul Krugman, called 'Way Off Base'. It's basically addressing something that's been on our minds for quite a while, the notion that the public is way ahead of the curve on the issues that Dems are cautiously supporting, yet the Dems still fail to get that, as if they're really afraid of some political liability in challenging a president less popular than recently thawed dog-poop in the snowmelt on a Hubbard Park trail.

Democrats don’t have the same problem. There’s no conflict between catering to the Democratic base and staking out positions that can win in the 2008 election, because the things the base wants — an end to the Iraq war, a guarantee of health insurance for all — are also things that the country as a whole supports. The only risk the party now faces is excessive caution on the part of its politicians. Or, to coin a phrase, the only thing Democrats have to fear is fear itself.
Exactly. I've said this before, especially when dealing with DLC types who preach moderation and accomplish nothing but enabling the president and his allies. They need to stop behaving like it's October of 2001. The GOP has nowhere to go but backwards:
Normally, politicians face a difficult tradeoff between taking positions that satisfy their party’s base and appealing to the broader public. You can see that happening right now to the Republicans: to have a chance of winning the party’s nomination, Republican presidential hopefuls have to take far-right positions on Iraq and social issues that will cost them a lot of votes in the general election...

Republicans will, for a while at least, be trapped in unpopular positions by a base that’s living in the past. Rudy Giuliani’s surge into front-runner status for the Republican nomination says more about the party than about the candidate. As The Onion put it with deadly accuracy, Mr. Giuliani is running for "President of 9/11.”
And that brings me to my second part. The stunning lack of any accomplishment from this veto-proof Democratic VT legislature. Impeachment gets scuttled. Nothing but a meager proposal for property tax reform. We were lucky to get the anti-war resolution. Last session's Catamount healthcare was like a band-aid that still fails to address the larger problem. What the hell are they doing up there?

Is it laziness? Timidity? Do some Democrats apparently not realize what having a large majority means? Apparently Washington County Senator Anne Cummings doesn't have a clue. When not busy knitting in committee meetings, she shared this nugget (on VPR) in regards to the greenhouse gas tax bill that would put a surcharge on fuel oil:
(Dillon) Cummings says the goal is two-fold: First get something the governor can sign.

(Cummings) "There's a great deal of concern that a tax of that kind would be vetoed, and we would then end up with nothing."
First, get something the governor can sign. Great place to start the negotiation, huh? What exactly does Douglas have to concede when presented with that sort of position?

Now, personally I think this particular bill, although well-intentioned, was a bad idea and should not have been introduced in the first place, considering how many Vermonters are already struggling to pay their fuel bill. But I use it because Cummings' response is really emblematic of the problem, most notably in regards to some of the other matters in the legislature.

Considering the current makeup of the legislature, it's Governor Douglas who is the one that should be asking for concessions here, not the other way around. Regardless of the issue, the Dems should be forceful and put forth the best possible legislation, and then have the Governor do the negotiating so he won't have his veto overridden. Not the other way around. It's all about the positioning, and to get back to Krugman's point, if the Dems decided to push through a BOLD proposal for universal healthcare, for example, and they just might find that they're not really being extreme at all. Sure, they're going to piss off corporate apologists like John McLaughry, Big Insurance/Pharma and a few conservatives, but by and large they'd be lauded for the courage and as an added bonus, if they frame it correctly, could paint the gov as a tool for corporate interests, which he most certainly is. Most importantly, they'll have taken action on an important issue and worked towards a solution instead of just perpetual hand-wringing.

And the Dems' inaction does not let you or I off of the hook, either. So many of us talk a good game when it comes to democracy, but we need to not just 'practice' it, we need to get good at it. Go to these committee meetings. Talk to your legislator and look him/her in the eye and tell them to show some courage and that you will support them strongly when they do. And that you will make a stink when they don't.

Having a supermajority shouldn't mean sitting on ones ass and not doing anything. It doesn't mean being drunk with power either, as the national nightmare of Republican rule exemplified. It means taking action. It's time to start putting Douglas on the ropes. Now.

Read More...

Under the radar: "Teaching the Bible"

Another thing worth drawing your attention to, in regards to our beloved culture war against the Religious Right. If you saw Time mag a few weeks ago, there was an article about how Biblically illiterate many Americans are. Anyways, there are increasing calls for the teaching of the Bible in a strictly historical, non-religious context, under the pretense that religion aside, it is an important historical book that should be taught as part of a well-rounded education.

See, the problem is finding teachers that are able to do that, for most that are willing to seem to be unable to inject the subtle or not-so-subtle proselytizing, as this LA Times article suggests, which is part of a larger article about the not-so-enlightened folks in Texas who are considering requiring Texas schools to offer this as an elective:

"When teachers don't have solid training in biblical studies and 1st Amendment issues, then they fall back on what they know from prior knowledge," Chancey told state legislators last week. "Courses end up being sectarian, often despite their best intentions."
He said one teacher showed students a PowerPoint presentation titled "God's Road Map for Your Life." Included was a slide called "Jesus Christ Is the One and Only Way." Another teacher taught students that NASA had found a missing day and time that corresponded to a biblical story of the sun standing still. One school showed "VeggieTales" videos, which feature computer-animated Christian vegetables that talk.
And interestingly enough, to get a better mindset of who is behind this, it's Texas state congressman Warren Chisum (rhymes with 'jism'). You might remember him as the nut who was passing around anti-evolution propaganda to his colleagues authored by an organization that believes that Copernicus was wrong, and the earth really is the center of the universe.

What's really struck me is how many of the Religious Right really want this class taught. It doesn't make sense, simply because nothing makes an atheist easier than when one analyzes and studies the Bible strictly from a historical context. It's what sealed the deal for me. When one sees all of the glaring inconsistencies and the dubious nature of the circumstances of its authorship, it suddenly becomes a lot harder to take seriously, other than a work of historical fiction. That is not to say one cannot still find it inspiring, or that their religion is somehow invalidated (unless, of course, it's one that takes the Bible literally, as many do). So those who say they want this in there for reasons other than subtle proselytizing are full of shit.

At least WorldNutDaily columnist and action star has-been Chuck Norris is honest about the agenda. He describes it as "your first step to getting God back into public school", and the big problem he has with it right now are these 'five unnecessary changes' that a mainstream liberal Christian group are proposing:
  • Mandate that teachers have appropriate academic qualifications and sufficient training on legal and constitutional issues surrounding instruction about the Bible in public schools.
  • Require rigorous, scholarly reviewed textbooks and other curriculum materials for all courses.
  • Include strong and specific language that protects the religious freedom of students and their families by barring the use of Bible classes to evangelize or promote personal religious perspectives.
  • Require the Texas Education Agency to regularly monitor and report on the content of public school Bible courses to ensure that they are academically and legally appropriate.
  • Continue to allow districts the option to offer – or not offer – such courses.
  • Funny, because those are all the things that would actually insure that it is taught in an academic, non-religious context. It's like the 'Intelligent Design' non-debate. They think that your kids should all think like theirs do, and they know what they advocate does not pass academic scrutiny whatsoever, so they try to put it under the radar. Makes me proud and relieved to live in the state with the second highest percentage of citizens with no religious affiliation (21%). And it is important to always remember that when these people accuse you of objecting because you fear that they may be right, make sure you correct them and let them know you fear them because they are wrong. Keep an eye out.

    Read More...

    Vermont: Let's kick it up about impeachment.

    For those of you following the Vermont impeachment matter, you probably know that the two people in the legislature that could make it a reality, Senate Pro Tempore Peter Shumlin and House Speaker Gaye Symington, are dragging their asses in order to not make it happen, citing other priorities and such. When considering how little the legislature has actually accomplished this year, one seriously has to wonder what those other priorities can be. And this is rubbed in even worse, considering that Shumlin time and time again expresses support of the impeachment measure, yet refuses to back it up with words. Now, Green Mountain Daily and VT Impeach have been covering this quite a bit, so you can get more background on it over there, but I do want to draw your attention to this message from Dan DeWalt, one of the pivotal citizens adding the impeachment, another call to arms, of sorts:

    We are looking at at least 40 citizens coming to Montpelier to demand impeachment action next Tuesday. You folks could turn that 40 into 100, and an interesting news day could be changed into a sea of change. Folks just need to show up at the statehouse cafeteria this Tuesday April 17 at 10 am, (if they come later, it will work too). They will be given information about what they can accomplish there, talking points and assistance in getting an appointment with a rep, and in general everything they will need to be comfortable and effective. they can email letsgoflyakite@yahoo.com for more info.

    Read More...

    Rude Pundit on why the religious right will continue to tank.

    The Rude Pundit takes on Tony Perkins and his hate-group, the Family Research Council:

    With one exception, for Perkins and the FRC, it's all about the fucking. Same song, next verse with these people, all the time.

    "It is a wonder that educated men and women, ambitious to serve their country, can be blind about issues like the sanctity of human life, marriage and the family, the Islamist and homosexual threats," Perkins whines. "This is an hour in which God-fearing Americans must be extremely alert and stay very close to the Lord." The headlines have been against conservative Christians lately, with the public deciding, in large numbers, that the shit evangelicals care about is worthless, and Perkins is goin' hardball: "Our nation is in serious jeopardy. God will separate the sheep from the goats on Judgment Day, but here and now each of us is called to be a lover and advocate of Truth." And then Perkins gives the Super-Duper Prayer Team a good reacharound: "Your ministry as a prayer warrior could not be more important."

    Read More...

    Wal-Mart abandoning organics PR campaign

    Wal-Mart has been trying really hard to get some more upscale customers, not an easy task considering they're in the news just about every other day for some hideous display of corporate abuse. And one of the things they've tried is to start selling organic produce in their supermarkets. Of course, anyone who truly follows food issues just saw it for what it was - another greenwashing PR stunt. Much of the organic stuff was big agribusiness 'organics' and some were even from China, where who the hell knows what passes for organics there.

    Well, apparently it's not working. MSNBC is reporting that Wal-Mart is scaling back on its organic plans, in some instances cutting them out completely. And it seems to be failing for several reasons. First, the average organic buyer isn't falling for it, and aren't going to be lured into Wal-mart just to save a few bucks. I think it's because many people who actually take the time to learn about organic foods are well aware that it's also about the scale of the operation, and don't trust foods from China or from Dole Corporation. Social and corporate responsibility do matter to many of these consumers.

    There's a ton of info on Dole out there, but this one from 'Coop-America' sums up why many organics fans aren't buying what Wal-Mart is selling:

    It may follow Chiquita in banana sales, but Dole is the reigning world leader in fresh fruit and vegetable production. Dole's image revolves around the health and nutrition of its food, but nowhere does the company mention the poverty and ill health suffered by agricultural workers to bring Dole goods to the world. In Central America Dole's reputation for destruction derives from the poisoning of thousands of workers by the dangerous pesticide dibromochloropropane, also known by the brand names Nemagon and Fumazone. In 1979 the chemical was banned in the US when it was suspected of causing sterility, miscarriages, birth defects, and cancer when inhaled or absorbed throught the skin. Dole and other companies allowed workers in Central America to continue using the pesticide without warning of the devastating effects. Fruit and vegetable producers suffer from low prices dictated by multinationals, and banana producers have been especially hard-hit by what is perceived as a "race to the bottom." When it comes to Dole and agriculture, Co-op America says workers and the environment need your support.

    Another corporate predator. And as the MSNBC article points out, the economy of scale of many organic farms isn't fitting in with Wal-Mart's economy of scale for the cheapest possible products:
    Consider the case of Organic Valley Family of Farms in La Farge, Wis., one of the country's largest cooperatives of organic farmers. When demand for organic milk soared two years ago, rival Horizon Organic Dairy offered to sell to Wal-Mart for 15% below Organic Valley's price. Wal-Mart expected a similar reduction from Organic Valley, but instead the cooperative pulled out. "Looking for ever-lower costs comes at a real cost to sustainability," says George Siemon, Organic Valley's chief executive. "To have consistent supply, you have to change the paradigm of thinking and think about long-term partnerships."
    Wal-Mart is never going to get the socially conscious consumer, upscale or not, because those consumers are well aware that Wal-Mart by its very nature is not a good corpoate citizen, and in order for it to continue to exist, it never can be. But perhaps if the 'Left Behind' books, NASCAR everything and the other low points of American culture weren't so achingly prominent in a visit to Wal-Mart, some of the less socially conscious upscale buyers would have a reason not to go to Target. But then Wal-Mart would lose its main demographic. So it's probably best for them to just stick with that already huge part of the pie. And I'm not saying this from some liberal elite horseshit angle, although it may sound that way. It's the very real fact that these consumers inhabit two very different worlds, and are not exactly compatible with each other from a marketing sense. It's brie vs. Velveeta.

    Read More...

    Sunday, April 15, 2007

    Interesting Piece on Evangelicals

    Wanna point you to a good piece I just read in the International Herald Tribune about evangelicals, "Letter from Washington: Evengelical Christians feared, but multifaceted". It's a pretty balanced piece that looks at two faces of the American evangelical movement, the homophobic, hateful James Dobson faction and the somewhat more compassionate Rick Warren side.

    Not surprisingly, the word 'evangelical' conjures up a negative image for most Europeans who, for the most part, have outgrown religion in many parts, especially the rather immature, irrational kind practiced by most evangelicals. And negative for more than a few Americans, too. Interesting tidbit:

    A Bloomberg/Los Angeles Times poll last year found that more than one-fifth of Americans would not vote for an evangelical Christian for president, far more than those who ruled out a Jew or a Catholic.
    Well, that's promising, but remember.. almost nobody would vote for an atheist, so we have a ways to go on that one. Aside from that, the article does lay out the stark differences between the two factions:
    Warren and Dobson are a microcosm of the controversy and confusion over the role evangelical Christians play in American social and political life. Warren is about inclusion and hope. Dobson is about exclusion and polarization.
    And they're both still fundamentally wrong from where I'm standing, although if the Dobsons would give way to the Warrens, we undoubtedly would have a kinder (if not necessarily wiser) nation. Have a read, it's a good one, it's not a hit piece or anything.

    Read More...

    Friday, April 13, 2007

    Brattleboro Reformer: Worst president ever.

    As a contrast to the droolin' fools who write the editorial page at the Caledonian Record, the Brattleboro Reformer came out with both guns 'a blazin' today: stating the obvious, that Bush is the worst president ever. And they're not letting any of the the players in Vermont off of the hook, either:

    History will not look kindly on House Speaker Gaye Symington for her insistence that her chamber must focus on "important matters" and that the House "does not have the time" to deal with impeachment.

    History will not look kindly on Senate President Pro Tem Peter Shumlin, who has talked loudly about impeaching Bush and Cheney, but won't pursue the issue as long Symington says no.

    History will not look kindly on Sen. Bernard Sanders, and his successor in the House, Peter Welch, as well as Sen. Patrick Leahy, for treating impeachment as if it were a barrel of toxic waste. Short-term political considerations apparently are more important than the Constitution, which they took an oath to uphold and defend.
    Hear, hear! And of course, the editorial ends with the important question still as of yet unresolved:
    Does Vermont want to go down in the history books as standing up to the worst president ever? We, the people of Vermont, have the chance to affect the outcome of this story. We must seize this opportunity.

    Read More...

    Krugman on the Theocrats

    It's often been said that the Religious Right does indeed have an agenda to install a theocratic government. This is often met with the response along the lines of it is a crazy conspiracy theory and all they really want is more recognition of religion in public life. And then they continue to peddle the bullshit line that our (mostly deist) Founding Fathers intended this to be a 'Christian nation'. Yeah, right.

    Paul Krugman's got a great piece on how deep those theocratic tentacles really go into the government. And this is the money quote:

    The infiltration of the federal government by large numbers of people seeking to impose a religious agenda — which is very different from simply being people of faith — is one of the most important stories of the last six years. It’s also a story that tends to go underreported, perhaps because journalists are afraid of sounding like conspiracy theorists.

    But this conspiracy is no theory. The official platform of the Texas Republican Party pledges to “dispel the myth of the separation of church and state.” And the Texas Republicans now running the country are doing their best to fulfill that pledge.


    And for those that still think it's a crazy liberal conspiracy theory, let me quote you the darling of the right and one of the most corrupt, sleazy politicians of the modern era, (who also typifies the male, white, Christian, victimized crybaby archetype) Texas Republican Tom DeLay:
    Ahead of the 2000 presidential race, he outlined a vision where "we march forward with a biblical worldview, a worldview that says God is our Creator, that man is a sinner, and that we will save this country by changing the hearts and minds of Americans.
    And don't forget this nugget:
    "Ladies and gentlemen, Christianity offers the only viable, reasonable, definitive answer to the questions of 'Where did I come from?' 'Why am I here?' 'Where am I going?' 'Does life have any meaningful purpose?' " DeLay said. "Only Christianity offers a way to understand that physical and moral border. Only Christianity offers a comprehensive worldview that covers all areas of life and thought, every aspect of creation. Only Christianity offers a way to live in response to the realities that we find in this world -- only Christianity."
    Gee, doesn't sound like there's any agenda there, does it? I'm optimistic that normal rational people, secularists and liberal/moderate religious types are finally waking up to this fact. Anybody that truly takes seriously the notion of 'liberty' should be concerned, regardless of where they are on the political spectrum.

    Read More...

    The Secret: New Age Stupidity and the 'Law' of Attraction

    As I've lamented before, even though living in VT spares me the frustration of living with the sheer idiocy so prevalent in the Bible Belt, and the luxury of being to be an outspoken atheist and not having to hear people constantly ramble on about their beloved Sky Fairy, the downside is that there's a ton of hokey New Age b.s. up that is quite prominent up here. Astrology, 'energy healing', homeopathy and a host of other pseudoscientific garbage seem to be widely accepted by parts of the culture. Granted, it's not as harmful as having a bunch of dominionists running around, but it's still frustrating.

    Speaking with some of these people is sometimes like speaking to a small child who hasn't developed a sense of reasoning yet. One of the common things I've heard is the power of positive vibes and thinking. Now, I don't mean metaphorically. I mean there are people that believe if you think positively about something, even something completely detached in any way from you, if enough people have those groovy thoughts, it will affect the outcome. Sure.

    So I got an email today form the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry talking about some bestselling book that Oprah is plugging now, called 'Secrets', by Lisa Nichols. The article is called 'Secrets and Lies':

    The problem is that neither the film nor the book has any basis in scientific reality. The Secret, Byrne states, lies in a New Age idea called the “Law of Attraction”: that similar things attract each other, so positive thoughts bring positive things and negative ones bring negative things. Of course, in physics, it is opposites that attract, but never mind that: according to Byrne, our thoughts send out vibrations that the universe (or some unspecified power) can somehow decipher and respond to. Therefore, goes the dubious logic, we have only to think very hard about the things we want, and we will get them. If you want to lose weight, Byrne writes, you’ll first have to accept that “food is not responsible for putting on weight. It is your thought that food is responsible for putting on weight that actually has food put on weight.”

    If that example leaves you scratching your head, author Lisa Nichols, featured in the film, explains that “Every time you look inside your mail expecting to see a bill, guess what? It will be there. You’re expecting debt, so debt must show up. . . . Every day you confirm your thoughts. Debt is there because of the Law of Attraction. Do yourself a favor: Expect a check!” Doesn’t that make sense? According to The Secret’s economic insights, the problem is not our bills or debt; the problem is that we are expecting those pesky bills! One wonders how much time Oprah spent skimming the book before agreeing to promote this half-baked twaddle.

    There’s also an ugly flipside: if you have an accident or disease, it’s your fault. There is of course a grain of truth to this: if a drunk wanders onto a highway and is hit, it’s likely his fault; if a lifelong smoker gets lung cancer, it’s likely her fault. But is everything we experience of our own making? If an airplane crashes, does that mean that one or more of the passengers brought that on himself? Do soldiers killed in Iraq simply not think enough positive thoughts?

    It's crazy how these people make up their own 'laws' that usually run in direct contradiction to how scientific laws really work. Homeopathy is based on the same thing, the false notion that 'like cures like'. If a particular substance gives you hemorrhoids, ingesting a tiny, subatomic amount of it (often referred to as a 'ghost' molecule), will cure the ailment. Of course when you point this out, people just talk about some experience they had where the homeopathy 'cured' some ailment of theirs and completely disregard the placebo effect or the very distinct possibility that the symptom just went away on its own, as is the case with many ailments. Then they accuse you of working for the AMA.

    The fact that this is a bestseller isn't surprising. Critical thinking skills are not really taught in the schools, and many people have an astounding lack of understanding of cause and effect, as well as the high occurrence of coincidence in our everyday lives. Instead of being aware of these things, we're stuck with people who insist that 'God must have done it/was speaking to me' or 'the positive/negative vibrations I sent out made it happen.' Looking at this really reveals why this country is in such a sorry state of existence. We have huge swaths of 13th century thinking in a 21st century universe.

    Read More...

    Thursday, April 12, 2007

    Buh-bye, Imus

    CBS to Imus: Yer Done. Now that wasn't too hard, considering Imus' hateful comments are well-documented. Now if they can just do something about Glen Beck...

    Watch the LGF crowd piss and moan about this again, because white men are soooo persecuted in this fine country of ours, right? Poor Imus was just a victim. And also watch them try to make this about Sharpton (who I don't like either). Black people are apparently only responsible for the actions of other black people. And all those nasty rappers. Problem is, Sharpton and 50-cent didn't say those words. Imus did. Of course they're gonna be pissed. He's one of them. And Sharpton now says he's got his sites trained on the hip-hop scene. We'll see where that goes.

    I'm sure FOX will hire Imus, or perhaps he can be Malkin's monkey sidekick now.

    UPDATE: After sleeping on this whole Imus thing, I have to say, to be honest I'm sort of torn because of the free speech issue at hand here. I feel no sympathy for Don Imus whatsoever, any more than I would for George Wallace. It is also made more complex by the notion that part of why he got the axe was because people of color who worked at NBC and CBS actually expressed their concerns about it. I can't say that I'm upset at the idea of one less raving bigot on the air, but there's still something about this that doesn't sit right with me. I think the Rude Pundit really sums up the same thing I'm feeling about this, more or less.

    The really messed up thing which is much harder to address is the fact that this idiot has such a huge audience. That's where the real problem is.

    Read More...

    More on the coming evangelical split

    crossposted at Green Mountain Daily.

    I'd like to point you to a great piece by Paul over at Alien and Sedition today, called 'It's Not the Liberals Who Should Worry About Evangelicals'. I think that Alien and Sedition is one of those great blogs that really excels at serious, thoughtful analysis of the conservative movement from many angles, and I encourage you to add it to your list of daily reads.

    Now, if you follow these kinds of issues like I do, you may have noticed in recent months a bit of a rift in the evangelical camp, between the war-mongering, xenophobic, sex-obsessed faction and the quieter faction who actually take Jesus' philosophy regarding social justice seriously. Their side encompasses many things that many of us on the lefty side hold dear: environmental stewardship, world peace, and eliminating poverty. Granted, there are still fundamental differences, but there is at least some common ground.

    Taking much from an article in the N.Y. Review of Books, Paul seems to believe that there is a coming rise of moderates from the evangelical side, who are not necessarily nutso fundamentalists. And, as someone pointed out in the comments of the Kos cross-posting of this article, if the Dems are able to appeal to those common ground issues, the Republicans truly have a lot to fear, because they are left with nothing but the extreme right-wing base, which is not exactly a sustainable way of keeping power. The key is for the Dems to not go overboard with the God talk, because then they're going to lose the support of those who hold secularism and rational inquiry in highest regard.

    It just goes to show how screwed up some of these people are when talking about the GOP '08 roster, it still seems like a pro-choice candidate has no chance in hell of getting the nomination. With all the serious problems in the world that affect every single person, this obsession with holy wars, the well-being of pre-humans, and which orifice a penis ends up in may eventually do them in. Although they're not dead and buried yet, and I still am not convinced the Dems are going to turn everything around (especially as long as the DLC types have any kind of influence, which, thankfully is also on the decline), I think what we are witnessing now is the beginning of another long trek into the political wilderness for the GOP, and the next time they come out of it, it's going to be harder to pull this kind of stuff off. One can only hope.

    Read More...

    Breaking: Idiot Townhall Pundit has irrefutable proof of zombie Jesus!

    Well, not really. Heck, not at all. It's just when an article starts off with such an idiotic sentence such as : "Liberals detest the historical fact that Jesus Christ arose from the dead," what else could I say? Now putting aside the fact the existence of no real 'evidence' whatsoever (and the author offers no real evidence either, just the usual faith-based b.s.), and conflicting, inconsistent accounts within the Gospels, let this 'liberal' respond. I don't detest the 'historical fact' of Zombie Jesus' existence any more than I detest the 'scientific fact' that the earth was created 10,000 years ago in seven days, with man in its present form.

    I detest the fact that there are a ton of people stupid enough to believe these things uncritically or unquestionably. Gives all of us humans a bad rap.

    Read More...

    Wednesday, April 11, 2007

    Name that Movie

    Ok, Bill Simmon is now 5 for 5, which makes me think he's the only one coming here and doing this. Nevertheless, I am a glutton for punishment.

    Last week's movie was Bruce Beresford's 'Black Robe', a 1991 film about a French missionary's journey up the St Lawrence River to go and convert the Huron Indians. It is a truly top notch film, with amazing scenery, incredible story, and first rate acting, probably in my top-10 films of all time. I'd highly recommend it. The Obligatory Stupid Trivia Question about the Vermont connection? Well, the guy in the phoo is explorer Samuel de Champlain, he who our famous lake is named after.

    Ok, here's this weeks movie:


    Name, year, and director, please. Now, I've finally figured out that my Obligatory Stupid Trivia Question more often than not ends up being a hint. That hopefully stops today. The only thing is to just remember the connections in these questions are often very tangential. What is the connection between this movie and Weather Report? Take that, Bill.

    Read More...