click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!

Friday, February 16, 2007

Dumb All Over, February Edition

Yeah, I know, two stupids in one day. Must be 'God's Will", right? Anyways, for a good laugh have a read of this at the Burnt Orange Report, about how Texas congressman and confirmed nutjob (I'm not going to tell you which party - you already know that one, don't you?) Warren Chisum (rhymes with 'jism') has circulated a memo to his anti-evolution buddies from.. hope you're sitting down... a group that not only doesn't believe in evolution, but dismisses Copernicus as well. Yup, the earth doesn't travel around the sun. Who knew? Have a look for yourself, it's called the 'Fair Education Foundation', here's what it says on the front page...

"An electromagnet and computerized sensor hidden in its
display stand cause the Earth to levitate in the air. Could God have engineered something like that for the real Earth? The Bible and all real evidence confirms that this is precisely what He did, and indeed: The Earth is not rotating...nor is it going around the sun. The universe is not one ten trillionth the size we are told.
Today’s cosmology fulfills an anti-Bible religious plan disguised as "science".
The whole scheme from Copernicanism to Big Bangism is a factless lie.
Those lies have planted the Truth-killing virus of evolutionism
in every aspect of man’s "knowledge" about the Universe, the
Earth, and Himself."
Jeez, I'm surprised that they haven't accused Copernicus and Darwin of working for COINTELPRO, which seems to be the paranoid idiot one-size-fits-all excuse nowadays.

Read More...

Terminal case of the stupids...

You may remember Congressman Virgil Goode (R-VA), the GOP blowhard who now leaves his Klan hood at home, but nonetheless wet himself over a freshman congressman, Keith Ellison (D-MN), who was going to be sworn in on the Koran instead of the Bible. Oh, the horror!

Well, just when you thought things couldn't get more ridiculous, as the Iraq war resolution was debated, the stench of xenophobic feces once again permeated the House of Representatives yesterday as Goode once again opened his mouth, as ThinkProgress reports:

When the commentary begins in the Middle East, in no way do I want to comfort and encourage the radical Muslims who want to destroy our country and who want to wipe the so-called infidels like myself and many of you from the face of the Earth. In no way do I want to aid and assist the Islamic jihadists who want the crescent and star to wave over the Capitol of the United States and over the White House of this country. I fear that radical Muslims who want to control the Middle East and ultimately the world would love to see “In God We Trust” stricken from our money and replaced with “In Muhammad We Trust.”
Must be part of that plan we hear from the GOP abut reaching out to minority voters, I guess. I can only imagine what his constituents believe (or, what he thinks they believe).

Read More...

SVR in VT Guardian

Editorial in the VT Guardian about the SVR h00ha.

Read More...

Thursday, February 15, 2007

If you're here for the SVR stuff...

If you've come here because of the Second Vermont Republic stuff, and don't want to wade through silly videos from bands no one listens to and the other political rantings, click here for just the SVR stuff. And thanks for stopping in.

Read More...

Gong - Oily Way

Enough of this seriousness! Some Gong fer ya...

Read More...

Wednesday, February 14, 2007

A word or two about the blogroll...

Maybe you've noticed the blogroll has gotten bigger lately. And if you've clicked around, you might be surprised at the political diversity of views on there, ranging from anarchist communism on one side to Randian objectivism on the other. I pretty much try to put up blogs I read on a regular basis, whether I agree with them or not. For example, 'Two Know It Alls' is run by a pair of objectivists, a philosophy I find in direct opposition to most of what I personally believe, but they're nevertheless two people with an exemplary sense of logic and language, and their commentaries on atheism are excellent. I'm turned off by the Dem-cheerleading of Daily Kos, but there's still a lot of good stuff on there. I disagree with just about everything Charity at 'She's Right' believes, but she's nice and I like debating her.

And of course, there's a few film links where you can find out more about the kinds of films I talk about on here, as well as some links to the somewhat limited-appeal music I like.

So, if you've been popping back in here on a returning basis (40-something percent of you are), take a minute and try something new on the roll there.

Read More...

The SVR controversy: What it's really about.

Odum did an interview on a Brattleboro AM radio station this morning (podcast - here)about the Second Vermont Republic/Neo-Confederate controversy, which is, apparently, finally spreading around. He plugged FBC on the show a few times. For those of you checking in here, I'd like to clarify some things regarding my involvement and motivations in this whole thing, not because in any way I feel the need to defend myself, just simply for the reason of clarity.

Basically, other than picking apart some of the pathetic excuses some are offering in defense of SVR's ties with these groups, and spreading the word about it, that's really the extent of my involvement and interest. I've still got tons of schoolwork to do and shitty movies to review and my snowthrower bit the shit right at the start of this blizzard, so it's not like I don't have other places I'd rather put my energy. Really. Reading the racist garbage of The League of the South is not exactly my idea of how I'd like to spend an evening. The person to see for the factual information is 'Thomas Rowley' over at Vermont Secession, where one can read the facts, verify them themselves if they like, and make their judgment. He's been the one doing all of the digging. Green Mountain Daily, and to a lesser extent, this blog, have merely been trying to make sure the information gets out there, a well as provide a perspective of the complex forces at work here.

I just want to be very clear about something, since one of the main defenses so far coming from SVR/VT Commons has been to 'shoot the messenger'. I have no motivations or desire whatsoever to facilitate the demise of Second Vermont Republic or VT Commons. Up until this story broke, I was a supporter (though not a member) of SVR and a regular reader of VT Commons, and I have a great deal of respect for many of its contributors, such as Bill McKibben and Dan DeWalt, among others. My issue is simply this... if SVR is promoting itself as a peaceful, democratic organization that, among other things, lists in its principles: 'economic solidarity, equal access, tension reduction, and mutuality," but seeks advice from people with well-known ties to people whose xenophobia, free-market fundamentalism, anti-labor and racist views stand in direct opposition to said principles, that's bullshit. It's easy to say that, hey, if you're gonna get involved with and support an organization, it is your responsibility to do the research on them, and there is most definitely truth to that. But generally, when one seeks support from the anti-imperialist, grassroots progressive community, it's usually not a stretch to assume the organization shares the view of the community and would take a forceful stand against the opposing principles, not get into bed with them under the guise of 'advice', and furthermore, say those views are 'none of their business.' It's dishonest, and it stinks. Perhaps SVR's reluctance to take political stances on issues should have been a heads up, I guess.

I'm really surprised that this stayed under wraps for so long, considering the information was readily available for anyone who chose to look for it. I'm even more shocked at the responses and reactions from Jim Hogue and Rob Williams, two extraordinarily intelligent individuals that I've had a great deal of respect for until this happened. They should know better.

The other thing I've taken from all this, is judging from the reactions of some of the defenders posting over at GMD, is that there is a stronger right-wing contingent in SVR than more of us on the left ever imagined. When I see people who are somewhat familiar with the workings of the hate-filled Vanguard News Service ('No Jews, Just Right'), attacking the Southern Poverty Law center, and referring to Pat Buchanan's American Conservative Magazine, The New York Sun, and Free Republic as somehow being representative of 'mainstream media', that sets off some alarm bells to me as to the political leanings of the posters.

And that's fine. SVR is free to be whatever they want to be. There is nothing that says they have to be progressive, egalitarian, whatever. They just need to be on the level about it, and not try to rationalize, obfuscate, attack, parse and bullshit their way around it when some people take it upon themselves to alert the larger progressive community from which they draw their support. That's pretty much it, folks. There's not much more for me to do, and I'm glad about that. It's out there, and people will either stick with it or move on to better things. Maybe it will lay the groundwork for a truly progressive secession movement that the right-wingers would loathe to be involved in. We'll just have to wait and see, I guess.

Read More...

Monibot in the Guardian on 9-11 conspiracies...

I've never been big on the more far-fetched 9-11 conspiracies (like the U.S. Gov't blowing up the Towers, etc. ) I saw 'Loose Change' and although it does ask some questions, much of the 'answers' stretch the limits of credibility. By no means do I buy the 'official story' by any strectch of the imagination, it's just that there are an awful lot of factors that would need to line up to buy some of the more adventurous theories, and when looked at on the macro level, they just don't add up, any more than the official story does. I think the truth lies somewhere in between... BushCo might have very well had prior knowledge, was extremely incompetent or both, saw how they could use it to their advantage (considering that this country reacts like a 4-year old child in these situations), and bam, there you have it. George Monibot in the lefty UK Guardian had this to say:

The next evident flaw is that the plot they propose must have involved tens of thousands of people. It could not have been executed without the help of demolition experts, the security firms guarding the World Trade Centre, Mayor Giuliani (who hastily disposed of the remains), much of the US air force, the Federal Aviation Administration and the North American Aerospace Defence Command, the relatives of the people "killed" in the plane crashes, the rest of the Pentagon's staff, the Los Alamos laboratories, the FBI, the CIA, and the investigators who picked through the rubble.
Now before you jump down my throat and somehow suggest I'm working for COINTELPRO or something, remember, I'm skeptical about everything. I just don't let my Bush hatred get the best of my imagination. There are a bunch of unanswered questions, but there aren't exactly any answers coming to the forefront with any kind of irrefutable proof. I'm not satisfied from the official story any more than I am by the conspiracy theorists, for both explanations leave many more questions than answers.

Read More...

The blizzard...

Not only am I reeling because of the 1 hour and 37 minutes of my life that I won't get back because I watched George Romero's 'Land of the Dead" last night, the snowthrower made a loud knock this morning and started pissing oil all over the place. Not good.

Read More...

Tuesday, February 13, 2007

The First Domino Begins to Fall...

Now this is what 'having principles' looks like. Looks like Second Vermont Republic is about to lose the anarchists. Unless of course, they do a major purge of the advisory board.. Stay tuned.

Read More...

Now Pander Bear McCain's with the Creationists

Think Progress is reporting that John McCain, in his perpetual bend-over for the GOP nomination, is delivering the keynote address to the Discovery Institute, the think-tank most responsible for getting the intelligent design assault on science into the public sphere. Problem is, like just about everything else McCain says nowadays, it's the opposite of what he's said in the past. Today:

McCain has an ambiguous record on whether he supports intelligent design in the science curriculum. In 2005, he said it should be taught:

Daily Star: Should intelligent design be taught in schools?

McCain: I think that there has to be all points of view presented. But they’ve got to be thoroughly presented. So to say that you can only teach one line of thinking I don’t think is - or one belief on how people and the world was created - I think there’s nothing wrong with teaching different schools of thought.

Daily Star: Does it belong in science?

McCain: There’s enough scientists that believe it does. I’m not a scientist. This is something that I think all points of view should be presented.

Last year:
“I think Americans should be exposed to every point of view,” he said. “I happen to believe in evolution…I respect those who think the world was created in seven days. Should it be taught as a science class? Probably not.“
About the only thing he's got going for him at this point is the people he's trying to pander to tend not to pay too much attention to hypocrisy, inconsistency, and fact-checking. Keep digging that hole, John. Gonna play well with the swing voters.

Read More...

Lieberman thinking about jumping the fence?

Let's hope so. Apparently, there is a procedure in place that would not effectively change committee controls and such, should he choose to do so. And he would lose his committee chair position as well. The Dems need to flush Lieberturd. He's not one of them. And when the GOP loses more seats in 2008, he'll be just another insignificant blip on the radar, and he'll be done in CT in 2012 as well.

Read More...

Monday, February 12, 2007

SVR Controversy Gets Blurb on Kos

It's a start. More to come. It's not going away.

Read More...

SVR Responds

Well, Second Vermont Republic has issued a response.

Short summary: it's about secession, not the racism. VT Commons' Rob Williams states :

    "some of our secession scholars - Don Livingston, for example - happen to be southerners. Anyone who has met and talked with Don knows the man is thoughtful and well-studied. Is he a racist? I don't know. And frankly, it is none of my damn business, at a personal level."
He doesn't know, and more importantly, doesn't care.

So, the long and short of it seems to be, 'Yes, there may be some racists on our advisory board but the advice they give in regards to secession is more important than the racism that many of these people associate with." Okay, I wonder how many Jews or people in the gay community involved in SVR feel about that. But, why disclose that information, right? We'll have to see. I don't think this is over yet.

Read More...

Happy Darwin's Birthday!

Considering I've expended a considerable amount of mental energy on the Second Vermont Republic/white supremacist link this weekend, and also have a huge amount of reading to do for school right now, I'm pretty tapped. Maybe if you're nice to me you'll get a movie review in a few days.

Anyways, today is Charles Darwin's birthday. If you haven't already, have a look at the brief but good tribute by Darksyde over at Kos, 'Happy Birthday, Mr. Darwin.'
Also, another piece that gives hope, about 'Evolution Sunday.'

And unlike Christmas, we know this birthday actually happened! Cheers!

Read More...

Things You Won't Be Reading About On FBC

In an unprincipled, blatant shill to increase traffic, here's some things you won't be reading about here on FBC anytime soon...
Obama, dead Anna Nicole Smith, BB gun wielding/diaper-wearing astronauts, Thomas DiLorenzio's black friends (are there any?), Harry Potter, Obama, Obama, Obama (gotta try - this one's a hit getter!), and Hillary Clinton.

Read More...

Sunday, February 11, 2007

Now let's take a breather...

Ok, I promise that this Second Vermont Republic/Neo-Confederate story, as important as it is to Vermonters, will not dominate FBC's content for the upcoming future. I hardly see its appeal to Spaghetti Western fans visiting here from Japan or Spain, or those many people who seem to come here for Sam Harris quotes. And there's still a lot going on in the world of right-wing idiocy too important to be ignored. So as new developments come up, I'll be filling you in on them. Still nothing new to report, still no official statement or explanation from SVR. Vermont Seccession has more info on that nasty Thomas DiLorenzio character here.

Monday can be a whole new ballgame, however, as the news cycle picks up. Seems like Vermonters tend to be interested in things other than diaper-wearing astronauts and dead Anna Nicole Smiths.

Read More...

Saturday, February 10, 2007

And the SVR saga continues...

This whole thing stinks. SVR was one of the first links I added to my blogroll a year ago. Too bad I had to remove it. My issue is not with one of secession, which I am in support of, nor is my issue with the many good people from the progressive community affiliated with SVR.

So, as this story picks up steam on GMD and the word spreads, I don't think it's looking too good for SVR. Last night, SVR co-founder Jim Hogue's head exploded, as he offered a rant of personal attacks, half-baked attacks against the Southern Poverty Law Center, and not much else. Conspicuously absent from his show of indignation was any kind of rebuttal of the charges against SVR. He could have explained why League of the South associate Thomas Dilorenzio is in a position of influence on the advisory board at SVR (more on DiLorenzio from the guy that broke the story in the first place, here). But he didn't.

And if you read through the comments over at GMD, there's a few apologists for the presence of this element in SVR. Apparently, the only 'advice' sought was on matters of secession. Apparently, it must be hard to find advice from anyone NOT affiliated with some sort of neo-Confederacy group. Who knew? Here's what one of the organizations DiLorenzio is affiliated with, the League of the South, (one of the few sites SVR links to), looks like:

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

Now, on this fine site, if you're not blinded by gratuitous appearance of the Stars n' Bars, one can, among other things, purchase fine literary works such as 'Myths of American Slavery', 'The South Was Right', and 'We Sure Pulled a Fast One on Those Vermonters, Didn't We?' Not sure on the release date on that last one.

DiLorenzio' s revisionist history on Abe Lincoln is also a favorite of the Council of Conservative Citizens, another neo-Confederate group, whose manifest, among other things, states:

(1) We believe the United States is a Christian country.

(2) We believe the United States is a European country and that Americans are part of the European people.

(8) Cultural, national, and racial integrity.
We oppose the presence of homosexuals and women in the military services and especially of women in combat roles.We therefore oppose all "sex education" as well as so-called "multiculturalist" and "Afrocentric" curricula, "Outcome-Based Education," and similar radical indoctrination in the schools.We believe in the traditional family as the basic unit of human society and morality, and we oppose all efforts by the state and other powers to weaken the structure of the American family through toleration of sexual licentiousness, homosexuality and other perversions, mixture of the races, pornography in all forms, and subversion of the authority of parents.
Now, of course he didn't write this, he's just affiliated with this group in some tangential way, and seemingly has their respect and admiration. So did Trent Lott and Strom Thurmond. Perhaps DiLorenzio shares this vision in the form of 'advice' to SVR? And who was okay with that? Who knows? How can we tell? SVR's defenders won't give us anything other than vague apologist claptrap, so how can we know? The sound of the crickets is deafening.

UPDATE: Defenders of the SVR-LoS connection continue to do a fantastic job of effectively NOT refuting the charges, while attacking the messenger, saying GMD is 'scared of you thinking outside the box' (what box? the tolerance box?). Okay. Doesn't sound like GMD is the one that's scared, though.

Read More...

Friday, February 9, 2007

Second Vermont Republic has ties to White Supremacists

I've always been interested in the Vermont secession group, The Second Vermont Republic. The idea of leaving a partnership that includes such enlightened places such as Alabama has always been a rather inviting one. They've made some substantial inroads into bridging a gap between the lefty-left crowd and the libertarian right. But something's not right. Although I'm kinda shocked that it's been under the radar for so long, SVR has some serious ties to figures in the white supremacist movement. There's a LOT to this story, so instead of giving you dribbles and drabs. just check out the full story over at Green Mtn. Daily, it's a bombshell.

Read More...

Thursday, February 8, 2007

Free Speech Alert: Something Smells Funny at the U.N.

I'm generally a supporter of the United Nations, and the concept behind it. I also understand why certain conservatives hate it so much. And I'm well aware it's not a perfect institution, understandable, considering the monumental task its purpose serves. I think if our government took it more seriously, we wouldn't be in this pickle we're in right now,and our standing in the world would be much higher than it currently is. Generally, I find most of what they do to be benign, and I'm certainly not afraid of some world government conspiracy horseshit like some wingers are. So, before you read on, know that I come from this as a liberal (if ornery)secular humanist who holds freedom of speech in the highest regard, not as some 'New World Order/black helicopters outside my window' kinda guy.

However, I came across something by science writer Ed Brayton at Dispatches from the Culture Wars that was quite disturbing. Apparently there has been a U.N Resolution proposed, for 'Combating the Defamation of Religions', voted on two years in a row, now (it's the first resolution on the page):

The Commission adopted by a roll-call vote a resolution on combating defamation of religions (E/CN.4/2004/L.5) by 29 in favour, 16 against, with 7 abstentions, by which it welcomed the report of the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of racism entitled “Situation of Muslim and Arab peoples in various parts of the world”; expressed deep concern at negative stereotyping of religions and manifestations of intolerance in some regions of the world; urged States to ensure equal access to education for all in law and in practice; expressed deep concern that Islam was frequently and wrongly associated with human rights violations and terrorism; noted with deep concern the intensification of the campaign of defamation of religions, and the ethnic and religious profiling of Muslim minorities in the aftermath of the tragic events of 11 September 2001; and expressed deep concern at programmes and agendas pursued by extremist organizations and groups aimed at the defamation of religions, in particular when supported by governments.

The Commission also urged all States, in conformity with international human rights instruments, to take all appropriate measures to combat hatred, discrimination, intolerance, and acts of violence motivated by religious intolerance; urged all States to ensure that all public officials in the course of their official duties respected different religions and did not discriminate on grounds of religion; strongly deplored physical attacks and assaults on businesses, cultural centres and places of worship of all religions; called upon the international community to initiate a global dialogue to promote a culture of tolerance based on respect for religious diversity; called upon the High Commissioner for Human Rights to promote and include human rights aspects in the Dialogue among Civilizations; and requested the Special Rapporteur to examine the situation of Muslim and Arab peoples in various parts of the world with special reference to physical assaults and attacks against their places of worship, cultural centres, businesses and properties in the aftermath of the events of 11 September 2001 and to submit a progress report on his findings to the Commission at its sixty-first session.
Now, at first glance it seems like there are some noble aims here, for example, preventing discrimination of religion and such. And it was obviously drafted in part, to concerns from Muslim nations. The Western nations and a few others voted against it. Ironically, many of the nations in support of it have abysmal human rights and tolerance records, as Brayton points out:
All Middle Eastern states except Israel voted for the resolution? Can that be serious? We're going to ask the opinion of Saudi Arabia, where schools routinely teach that Jews and Christians are pigs worthy of death, whether we should pass a law forbidding the defamation of religion? We're going to ask nations full of people who burn down synagogues over cartoons drawn halfway around the world and who believe that someone who converts from Islam to Christianity should be put to death whether religions can be criticized? We're supposed to care what China, a nation that has all but destroyed Tibetan Buddhism and routinely locks up and tortures Christians and Muslims, thinks about our laws on religious freedom?
Now, although I don't necessarily agree with Brayton's sweeping over-generalization of Muslims (much like Sam Harris does), but he does have a point. I couldn't find Israel's name under the yeah, nay, or the abstention, so I'm unclear as to where the notion of where Israel stands on this. Last May, Dr . Robert Freeman wrote some crazy stuff in an op/ed the Jewish Times, shortly after the Danish cartoon controversy:

In order to rectify the situation, and to prevent a future crisis of this type from erupting, what is needed is a "code of conduct" for the newspapers and other media in both the Western and Muslim worlds. All governments must agree that the negative depiction of religion is "out of bounds," and penalties should be imposed on those who violate the code of conduct.

The problem, of course, is to determine the difference between legitimate criticism of someone who acts in the name of a religion, and the negative depiction of that religion.

To solve that problem, I propose the creation of an International Religious Court, composed of Christian, Muslim and Jewish clergymen with one clergyman representing each of the three religions. Anyone feeling that his or her religion was insulted could appeal to the International Religious Court for a ruling on the matter, and the court would then determine whether a penalty should be invoked. It would be the responsibility of the government on whose territory the action took place to impose the penalty.

Now, this is a touchy subject, aside from political correctness issues that some may have with it. This is one of those rare issues that many people on the left and the right are in support of, although for different reasons and different perspectives. You can easily see that in one of the links that he links to... it's a rightie whose opposition comes not only from free speech issues but equally rooted in that right-wing distaste for all things U.N. But he does make a good point:
Prohibiting the dissemination of xenophobic ideas aimed at any religion that constitute incitement to hostility — sounds like a pretty broad proposition. It would cover many atheist criticisms of religion generally; many secularist criticisms of fundamentalist Christianity (or Islam or Judaism); condemnation of religious groups that are alleged to be cults or scams; many theological criticisms of a wide range of religions; many pro-gay-rights or pro-women's-rights condemnations of religions that are seen as hostile to gays or women; and much more.
And that, regardless of where your ideological chips fall, is not a good place for us to be in. And once again it ties into that whole modern, outspoken atheist thing that Harris, Dawkins, and (rather feebly) I keep trying to get out there: why should religion be exempt from criticism? Let me be very clear: as much as I have a distaste for all things religion, I would never support any violence or discrimination in any way against any one because of their religion, any more than I would based on their race, gender, sexual orientation or other things of that nature.

But as you well know, some religious people believe some pretty crazy things, sometimes harmful, sometimes harmless, but nonetheless irritating, They are not immune from being asked to defend their claims and belief, and yes, uncivil as it may seem, they are not immune to criticism or even ridicule. It doesn't say anywhere in the Constitution about having the right not to be offended. It's a really slippery slope to slide down if something like this were to be implemented, and this is one of those instances that I think, although there are good intentions behind it, the U.N. is wrong on this one.

Read More...