click here for the new...
FIVE BEFORE CHAOS HAS OFFICIALLY MOVED TO A BIGGER AND BETTER PLACE! PLEASE CLICK THE ABOVE BANNER TO GET THERE, AND DON'T FORGET TO BOOKMARK THE NEW LOCATION. THANKS FOR STOPPING BY!

Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Now Pander Bear McCain's with the Creationists

Think Progress is reporting that John McCain, in his perpetual bend-over for the GOP nomination, is delivering the keynote address to the Discovery Institute, the think-tank most responsible for getting the intelligent design assault on science into the public sphere. Problem is, like just about everything else McCain says nowadays, it's the opposite of what he's said in the past. Today:

McCain has an ambiguous record on whether he supports intelligent design in the science curriculum. In 2005, he said it should be taught:

Daily Star: Should intelligent design be taught in schools?

McCain: I think that there has to be all points of view presented. But they’ve got to be thoroughly presented. So to say that you can only teach one line of thinking I don’t think is - or one belief on how people and the world was created - I think there’s nothing wrong with teaching different schools of thought.

Daily Star: Does it belong in science?

McCain: There’s enough scientists that believe it does. I’m not a scientist. This is something that I think all points of view should be presented.

Last year:
“I think Americans should be exposed to every point of view,” he said. “I happen to believe in evolution…I respect those who think the world was created in seven days. Should it be taught as a science class? Probably not.“
About the only thing he's got going for him at this point is the people he's trying to pander to tend not to pay too much attention to hypocrisy, inconsistency, and fact-checking. Keep digging that hole, John. Gonna play well with the swing voters.

Read More...

Lieberman thinking about jumping the fence?

Let's hope so. Apparently, there is a procedure in place that would not effectively change committee controls and such, should he choose to do so. And he would lose his committee chair position as well. The Dems need to flush Lieberturd. He's not one of them. And when the GOP loses more seats in 2008, he'll be just another insignificant blip on the radar, and he'll be done in CT in 2012 as well.

Read More...

Monday, February 12, 2007

SVR Controversy Gets Blurb on Kos

It's a start. More to come. It's not going away.

Read More...

SVR Responds

Well, Second Vermont Republic has issued a response.

Short summary: it's about secession, not the racism. VT Commons' Rob Williams states :

    "some of our secession scholars - Don Livingston, for example - happen to be southerners. Anyone who has met and talked with Don knows the man is thoughtful and well-studied. Is he a racist? I don't know. And frankly, it is none of my damn business, at a personal level."
He doesn't know, and more importantly, doesn't care.

So, the long and short of it seems to be, 'Yes, there may be some racists on our advisory board but the advice they give in regards to secession is more important than the racism that many of these people associate with." Okay, I wonder how many Jews or people in the gay community involved in SVR feel about that. But, why disclose that information, right? We'll have to see. I don't think this is over yet.

Read More...

Happy Darwin's Birthday!

Considering I've expended a considerable amount of mental energy on the Second Vermont Republic/white supremacist link this weekend, and also have a huge amount of reading to do for school right now, I'm pretty tapped. Maybe if you're nice to me you'll get a movie review in a few days.

Anyways, today is Charles Darwin's birthday. If you haven't already, have a look at the brief but good tribute by Darksyde over at Kos, 'Happy Birthday, Mr. Darwin.'
Also, another piece that gives hope, about 'Evolution Sunday.'

And unlike Christmas, we know this birthday actually happened! Cheers!

Read More...

Things You Won't Be Reading About On FBC

In an unprincipled, blatant shill to increase traffic, here's some things you won't be reading about here on FBC anytime soon...
Obama, dead Anna Nicole Smith, BB gun wielding/diaper-wearing astronauts, Thomas DiLorenzio's black friends (are there any?), Harry Potter, Obama, Obama, Obama (gotta try - this one's a hit getter!), and Hillary Clinton.

Read More...

Sunday, February 11, 2007

Now let's take a breather...

Ok, I promise that this Second Vermont Republic/Neo-Confederate story, as important as it is to Vermonters, will not dominate FBC's content for the upcoming future. I hardly see its appeal to Spaghetti Western fans visiting here from Japan or Spain, or those many people who seem to come here for Sam Harris quotes. And there's still a lot going on in the world of right-wing idiocy too important to be ignored. So as new developments come up, I'll be filling you in on them. Still nothing new to report, still no official statement or explanation from SVR. Vermont Seccession has more info on that nasty Thomas DiLorenzio character here.

Monday can be a whole new ballgame, however, as the news cycle picks up. Seems like Vermonters tend to be interested in things other than diaper-wearing astronauts and dead Anna Nicole Smiths.

Read More...

Saturday, February 10, 2007

And the SVR saga continues...

This whole thing stinks. SVR was one of the first links I added to my blogroll a year ago. Too bad I had to remove it. My issue is not with one of secession, which I am in support of, nor is my issue with the many good people from the progressive community affiliated with SVR.

So, as this story picks up steam on GMD and the word spreads, I don't think it's looking too good for SVR. Last night, SVR co-founder Jim Hogue's head exploded, as he offered a rant of personal attacks, half-baked attacks against the Southern Poverty Law Center, and not much else. Conspicuously absent from his show of indignation was any kind of rebuttal of the charges against SVR. He could have explained why League of the South associate Thomas Dilorenzio is in a position of influence on the advisory board at SVR (more on DiLorenzio from the guy that broke the story in the first place, here). But he didn't.

And if you read through the comments over at GMD, there's a few apologists for the presence of this element in SVR. Apparently, the only 'advice' sought was on matters of secession. Apparently, it must be hard to find advice from anyone NOT affiliated with some sort of neo-Confederacy group. Who knew? Here's what one of the organizations DiLorenzio is affiliated with, the League of the South, (one of the few sites SVR links to), looks like:

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

Now, on this fine site, if you're not blinded by gratuitous appearance of the Stars n' Bars, one can, among other things, purchase fine literary works such as 'Myths of American Slavery', 'The South Was Right', and 'We Sure Pulled a Fast One on Those Vermonters, Didn't We?' Not sure on the release date on that last one.

DiLorenzio' s revisionist history on Abe Lincoln is also a favorite of the Council of Conservative Citizens, another neo-Confederate group, whose manifest, among other things, states:

(1) We believe the United States is a Christian country.

(2) We believe the United States is a European country and that Americans are part of the European people.

(8) Cultural, national, and racial integrity.
We oppose the presence of homosexuals and women in the military services and especially of women in combat roles.We therefore oppose all "sex education" as well as so-called "multiculturalist" and "Afrocentric" curricula, "Outcome-Based Education," and similar radical indoctrination in the schools.We believe in the traditional family as the basic unit of human society and morality, and we oppose all efforts by the state and other powers to weaken the structure of the American family through toleration of sexual licentiousness, homosexuality and other perversions, mixture of the races, pornography in all forms, and subversion of the authority of parents.
Now, of course he didn't write this, he's just affiliated with this group in some tangential way, and seemingly has their respect and admiration. So did Trent Lott and Strom Thurmond. Perhaps DiLorenzio shares this vision in the form of 'advice' to SVR? And who was okay with that? Who knows? How can we tell? SVR's defenders won't give us anything other than vague apologist claptrap, so how can we know? The sound of the crickets is deafening.

UPDATE: Defenders of the SVR-LoS connection continue to do a fantastic job of effectively NOT refuting the charges, while attacking the messenger, saying GMD is 'scared of you thinking outside the box' (what box? the tolerance box?). Okay. Doesn't sound like GMD is the one that's scared, though.

Read More...

Friday, February 9, 2007

Second Vermont Republic has ties to White Supremacists

I've always been interested in the Vermont secession group, The Second Vermont Republic. The idea of leaving a partnership that includes such enlightened places such as Alabama has always been a rather inviting one. They've made some substantial inroads into bridging a gap between the lefty-left crowd and the libertarian right. But something's not right. Although I'm kinda shocked that it's been under the radar for so long, SVR has some serious ties to figures in the white supremacist movement. There's a LOT to this story, so instead of giving you dribbles and drabs. just check out the full story over at Green Mtn. Daily, it's a bombshell.

Read More...

Thursday, February 8, 2007

Free Speech Alert: Something Smells Funny at the U.N.

I'm generally a supporter of the United Nations, and the concept behind it. I also understand why certain conservatives hate it so much. And I'm well aware it's not a perfect institution, understandable, considering the monumental task its purpose serves. I think if our government took it more seriously, we wouldn't be in this pickle we're in right now,and our standing in the world would be much higher than it currently is. Generally, I find most of what they do to be benign, and I'm certainly not afraid of some world government conspiracy horseshit like some wingers are. So, before you read on, know that I come from this as a liberal (if ornery)secular humanist who holds freedom of speech in the highest regard, not as some 'New World Order/black helicopters outside my window' kinda guy.

However, I came across something by science writer Ed Brayton at Dispatches from the Culture Wars that was quite disturbing. Apparently there has been a U.N Resolution proposed, for 'Combating the Defamation of Religions', voted on two years in a row, now (it's the first resolution on the page):

The Commission adopted by a roll-call vote a resolution on combating defamation of religions (E/CN.4/2004/L.5) by 29 in favour, 16 against, with 7 abstentions, by which it welcomed the report of the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of racism entitled “Situation of Muslim and Arab peoples in various parts of the world”; expressed deep concern at negative stereotyping of religions and manifestations of intolerance in some regions of the world; urged States to ensure equal access to education for all in law and in practice; expressed deep concern that Islam was frequently and wrongly associated with human rights violations and terrorism; noted with deep concern the intensification of the campaign of defamation of religions, and the ethnic and religious profiling of Muslim minorities in the aftermath of the tragic events of 11 September 2001; and expressed deep concern at programmes and agendas pursued by extremist organizations and groups aimed at the defamation of religions, in particular when supported by governments.

The Commission also urged all States, in conformity with international human rights instruments, to take all appropriate measures to combat hatred, discrimination, intolerance, and acts of violence motivated by religious intolerance; urged all States to ensure that all public officials in the course of their official duties respected different religions and did not discriminate on grounds of religion; strongly deplored physical attacks and assaults on businesses, cultural centres and places of worship of all religions; called upon the international community to initiate a global dialogue to promote a culture of tolerance based on respect for religious diversity; called upon the High Commissioner for Human Rights to promote and include human rights aspects in the Dialogue among Civilizations; and requested the Special Rapporteur to examine the situation of Muslim and Arab peoples in various parts of the world with special reference to physical assaults and attacks against their places of worship, cultural centres, businesses and properties in the aftermath of the events of 11 September 2001 and to submit a progress report on his findings to the Commission at its sixty-first session.
Now, at first glance it seems like there are some noble aims here, for example, preventing discrimination of religion and such. And it was obviously drafted in part, to concerns from Muslim nations. The Western nations and a few others voted against it. Ironically, many of the nations in support of it have abysmal human rights and tolerance records, as Brayton points out:
All Middle Eastern states except Israel voted for the resolution? Can that be serious? We're going to ask the opinion of Saudi Arabia, where schools routinely teach that Jews and Christians are pigs worthy of death, whether we should pass a law forbidding the defamation of religion? We're going to ask nations full of people who burn down synagogues over cartoons drawn halfway around the world and who believe that someone who converts from Islam to Christianity should be put to death whether religions can be criticized? We're supposed to care what China, a nation that has all but destroyed Tibetan Buddhism and routinely locks up and tortures Christians and Muslims, thinks about our laws on religious freedom?
Now, although I don't necessarily agree with Brayton's sweeping over-generalization of Muslims (much like Sam Harris does), but he does have a point. I couldn't find Israel's name under the yeah, nay, or the abstention, so I'm unclear as to where the notion of where Israel stands on this. Last May, Dr . Robert Freeman wrote some crazy stuff in an op/ed the Jewish Times, shortly after the Danish cartoon controversy:

In order to rectify the situation, and to prevent a future crisis of this type from erupting, what is needed is a "code of conduct" for the newspapers and other media in both the Western and Muslim worlds. All governments must agree that the negative depiction of religion is "out of bounds," and penalties should be imposed on those who violate the code of conduct.

The problem, of course, is to determine the difference between legitimate criticism of someone who acts in the name of a religion, and the negative depiction of that religion.

To solve that problem, I propose the creation of an International Religious Court, composed of Christian, Muslim and Jewish clergymen with one clergyman representing each of the three religions. Anyone feeling that his or her religion was insulted could appeal to the International Religious Court for a ruling on the matter, and the court would then determine whether a penalty should be invoked. It would be the responsibility of the government on whose territory the action took place to impose the penalty.

Now, this is a touchy subject, aside from political correctness issues that some may have with it. This is one of those rare issues that many people on the left and the right are in support of, although for different reasons and different perspectives. You can easily see that in one of the links that he links to... it's a rightie whose opposition comes not only from free speech issues but equally rooted in that right-wing distaste for all things U.N. But he does make a good point:
Prohibiting the dissemination of xenophobic ideas aimed at any religion that constitute incitement to hostility — sounds like a pretty broad proposition. It would cover many atheist criticisms of religion generally; many secularist criticisms of fundamentalist Christianity (or Islam or Judaism); condemnation of religious groups that are alleged to be cults or scams; many theological criticisms of a wide range of religions; many pro-gay-rights or pro-women's-rights condemnations of religions that are seen as hostile to gays or women; and much more.
And that, regardless of where your ideological chips fall, is not a good place for us to be in. And once again it ties into that whole modern, outspoken atheist thing that Harris, Dawkins, and (rather feebly) I keep trying to get out there: why should religion be exempt from criticism? Let me be very clear: as much as I have a distaste for all things religion, I would never support any violence or discrimination in any way against any one because of their religion, any more than I would based on their race, gender, sexual orientation or other things of that nature.

But as you well know, some religious people believe some pretty crazy things, sometimes harmful, sometimes harmless, but nonetheless irritating, They are not immune from being asked to defend their claims and belief, and yes, uncivil as it may seem, they are not immune to criticism or even ridicule. It doesn't say anywhere in the Constitution about having the right not to be offended. It's a really slippery slope to slide down if something like this were to be implemented, and this is one of those instances that I think, although there are good intentions behind it, the U.N. is wrong on this one.

Read More...

Bush's war on the Poor

No, it's not Iran. George Bush's latest war is another example of his "compassionate conservatism'. This time, it's budget cuts and low-income housing programs. In an article in the SF alt-weekly, BeyondCron:

The Bush budget plan for fiscal year 2008 announced on February 6 slashes key low-income housing programs, while increasing America’s mammoth defense budget by 11%---an increase that does not include funding for the Iraq war.

While the Bush Administration sends public relations staff like Phil Mangano around the country touting plans to end chronic homelessness, the President continues efforts to cut housing programs for the poor. The new Bush budget plan would reduce the vital Project Based Rental Assistance Program, which currently funds about 1.2 million project based subsidies, by $163 million. Public Housing funding would be cut by nearly $400 million.


A glance at the 'Rundown of the FY 2008 Budget' from the National Alliance to End Homelessness shows levels in a few programs staying in place, a few modest increases, and many substantial cuts. I guess the free market's nipped that poverty problem in the bud, right?

A look at the budget proposal shows among other things, an 18% decrease in LIHEAP heating assistance - I guess with the global warming those poor people won't need it as much, right? The Community Services Block Grant (CSBG), which funds job training and
other services in low-income communities, would be eliminated completely. Housing for the Elderly, cut $160 million. Housing for People with Disabilities cut $112 million. Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention program ,eliminated. There are also cuts to the Emergency Food and Shelter Program and for Health Care for the Homeless.

Now, before the trolls accuse me of just pointing out the negative, yes, as I said before, there are a few modest increases, such as a 10% increase in Homeless Assistance Grants, and 4% increase in operating subsidies for public housing. Maybe they'll hand out some cardboard refrigerator boxes as a gesture of good faith, perhaps? By and large, looking at the budget, there's mostly huge cuts. Gotta pay for this stupid war right?

Some of us can remember a time when another president, although severely misguided like our current one in matters of foreign policy, declared a 'War on Poverty'. That's a war that I could actually support, as could most of us on here.

Now, where does Welch stand on this particular issue? His latest press release does address the recklessness of the newest budget, but with emphasis on the war.
"The budget released by the President today is both fiscally reckless and demonstrates upside-down priorities at odds with the needs of Vermonters. Through rosy economic revenue projections and a failure to account properly for the war in Iraq, the President creates the mirage of a balanced budget.

"In November, voters in Vermont and across the country told the President that it was time for a new direction. Yet the President’s budget contains nothing but more of the same. The President continues to insist on the extension of trillions of dollars in tax breaks for the wealthiest Americans. He continues to incorporate into the budget his misguided plan to privatize Social Security. And, instead of expanding access to health care, he cuts programs for the elderly and children and proposes increasing costs for veterans.


Welch's positions on the war lately have been encouraging, as most of you know. But it is really important for him to take a bold stand and, apart from the war - important as it is, to speak out forcefully on the actual impact this reckless budget is going to have on our nation's most vulnerable citizens.

Read More...

Wednesday, February 7, 2007

Bone love.

Reuters photo

Interesting Neolithic archaeological find in Italy...

Read More...

Tuesday, February 6, 2007

Manuel Gottsching/Ashra

One of the more influential artists I've come across in the last few years is Manuel Gottsching, an electronic music pioneer from Germany, who has also recorded under the group monkiers Ash Ra Tempel and later Ashra. His mid-70's album 'Blackouts', an album of entrancing synthesizer and guitar loop contributions had a profound effect on my own musical sensibilities. His later work, 'E2-E4' is considered a groundbreaking album in the world of electronica. What I like about his stuff is that it is quite entrancing, and his use of the guitar adds a human element to an too-often emotionless genre of music.

Unfortunately, I can't find any film footage from the 70's Ashra years, arguably my favorite period. I did find a few clips from a recent festival, however, something with Manuel and a Japanese visual artist. It's not everyone's cup of tea, but perhaps it might further your curiosity about this important and underappreciated artist. You can find great sound clips from his 30+ year career and tons of other information at his official homepage, here.

Saint and Sinner:


Sunrain:

Read More...

Why the hell does anyone waste ink/oxygen on John McLaughry?

As most of you know, one of the best things about Vermont is that it's not exactly an ideal place to live if one is a conservative. And often, as in other places, outspoken conservatives in their slavish devotion to free-market fundamentalism (and in VT, sometimes-but-thankfully-rarely Bible-based social conservatism), they tend to play a bit loose with the facts. Outspoken conservatives up here are so rare that it's not hard to get attention by opening one's mouth and letting the drivel fly - there's not a lot of competition. Hence, the John McLaughry experience.

McLaughry heads the VT-based think tank called the Ethan Allen Institute:

The Ethan Allen Institute is Vermont's independent, nonpartisan, free-market-oriented public policy think tank. The Institute offers "Ideas for Vermont's Future" built upon a libertarian, decentralist, community-based philosophy. It is one of some 48 similar but independent state organizations associated with the State Policy Network.

Mission Statement:

The Mission of the Ethan Allen Institute is to influence public policy in Vermont by helping its people to better understand and put into practice the fundamentals of a free society: individual liberty, private property, competitive free enterprise, limited and frugal government, strong local communities, personal responsibility, and expanded opportunity for human endeavor.

It's your typical 'let the markets decide the fate of the human race; it knows what's best' organization. McClaughry's got that William-Buckley-wannabe vibe going on, and is the public face of the E.A. Institute. Come to think of it, he's pretty much the only face I ever seem to see from the institute. The board of directors includes such heavyweights(snicker) as Jack McMullen, the guy who ran against Senator Leahy a few years back and lost the primary to farmer Fred Tuttle.

McLaughry himself has a rather impressive resume, having worked in the Reagan administration, served on four presidential commissions, held office in the Vermont House and Senate, as well as has an unsuccessful run for governor under his belt. You can hear his commentaries on Vermont's contribution to the right-wing noise machine, True North Radio. And to his credit, McLaughry hasn't ever framed his positions from the theocratic angle (he is an intellectual, after all). So, all in all, he's a pretty smart guy, and I say that sincerely. So you could imagine the cognitive dissonance I was having after reading his's op-ed piece on global warming in the Times Argus a few weeks back entitled 'Warming Hysteria is Out of Whack' (subscription or payment required to view), that stated:

Virtually unnoticed by the news media, over 17,000 scientists and engineers - nearly 2,000 of them with degrees in meteorology and climatology - signed the 1997 Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine Kyoto Petition. Its punch line read: "There is no convincing scientific evidence that human release of carbon dioxide, methane or other greenhouse gases is causing or will, in the foreseeable future, cause catastrophic heating of the Earth's atmosphere and disruption of the Earth's climate."

...The post-1979 lower troposphere satellite microwave data corroborated by radiosonde balloons shows no alarming global warming trend.

See, there's a problem here, folks. McLaughry, in his fetish-like obsession with free-market fundamentalism, knows that Americans, and particularly right-wingers, are kind of lazy with checking the facts. Many see something that confirms their preconceptions, see it coming from some blowhard the represents an 'institute' (giving it an air of credibility), and then accept the premises, case closed. Too bad he's wrong, not to mention that quoting 30 year old studies on a modern, quickly-evolving problem is pretty friggin' lazy. Might as well use the Bible for a reference.

In this last Sunday's Times Argus, Dr. Alan K. Betts, a real scientist (unlike McLaughry, the political scientist) who is the president of Vermont Academy of Science and Engineering in Pittsford, contributed an article that completely demolished McLaughry's wishful thinking piece. Here are the major points:

1. McClaughry quotes "evidence" that the lower tropospheric satellite microwave data do not show an "alarming global warming trend." This is a dishonest fudge of the real scientific evidence. The data in question from Spencer and Christie (Science, 1990, and other papers that followed) were for many years inconsistent with the surface warming record, and this was widely repeated as "evidence" that warming was not occurring. A U.S. Climate Change Science Program panel was specifically set up and funded by the (skeptical) U.S. government to resolve the issue. They found the errors in the Spencer and Christie analyses, and now the data agree; and all show the warming that has occurred in the last 30 years (during which we have had satellite as well as surface data). Read their 2006 report at http://www.climatescience.gov/Library/sap/sap1-1/finalreport/sap1-1-final-execsum.pdf. Sadly, this definitive report is deliberately ignored by McClaughry, because of course the scientific evidence inconveniently disagrees with his political agenda. The repetition of false information is a well-known tool of propaganda, not science.

2. The argument that only a few percent of the greenhouse gases are from our industrial society is totally misleading. Water vapor is the biggest contributor to the greenhouse effect. Together all of the greenhouse gases warm the Earth to an average of 60 degrees Fahrenheit, which means the oceans don't freeze Fahrenheit, making life as we know it on this planet possible. It is what we are doing to this balance that matters. Although carbon dioxide contributes a smaller amount than water vapor to the greenhouse warming, carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is rising very rapidly (about 100 parts per million over the last century; and now rising at about 2 parts per million per year) driven by fossil fuel burning. The growth of other industrial gases in the atmosphere is also contributing to the greenhouse effect. The presence of water vapor, coupled with the earth's temperature, amplifies the effects of these additional greenhouse gases. McClaughry is implying that a few more degrees of warming isn't much to worry about (because he does not want carbon dioxide emissions to be regulated).

3. McClaughry points out that in 1997 thousands of scientists signed an anti-Kyoto petition (starting "We urge the United States government to reject the global warming agreement that was written in Kyoto") as part of a successful campaign by business-funded interests to stop the United States from agreeing to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions. Ten years have passed and it is now clear that we need reductions in greenhouse gases far greater than those of the Kyoto agreement, if we are to avoid huge economic costs, as recently outlined in the Stern Review by the British government.

Ouch. Perhaps McLaughry really believes those words of his anointed savior, Ronald Reagan: 'Facts are stupid things.' But it doesn't even take a scientist to see how McLaughry is piling on the bull, it just takes a little fact-checking, as evidenced by these letters to the editor in response to McLaughry's diatribe. R.D. Eno from Cabot:

Snarling and foaming, McClaughry as much as calls any climatologist who contends that manmade emissions are tilting the climate toward rapid and unnatural warming a liar. But the only evidence McClaughry cites in his surly little scree is a "petition" circulated in 1998 by the Oregon Institute of Science and Medicin that disputes the evidence for global warming, signed, says McClaughry, by 17,000 scientists, of whom 2,000 were meteriologists or climatologists. This "petition" is a hoary old hoax.

OISM is a one-man operation, much like the Ethan Allen Institute, run by Arthur Robinson, a biochemist with a sideline in books about how to survive a nuclear war. The study that the "petition" supposedly supports was written by Robinson, his son and a couple of astrophysicists, none of them climatologists. (One of the authors, Sallie L. Baliunas, is affiliated with nine ExxonMobil-funded groups, according to New Scientist.) Robinson formatted the study to mimic a National Academy of Science article and then flooded university mailboxes with copies and a card to be signed as an endorsement. But the study was never peer reviewed and has been discredited by the academy. The number of legitimate endorsements of Robinson's "petition" cannot be determined because credentials were not listed, but Scientific American, randomly sampling the signatories, estimated that "petition" supporters included only about 200 climate researchers. The OISM paper and "petition" represent flat-earth science at its worst. Trying to pass off this baloney as filet mignon might be called, to paraphrase McClaughry's bluster, ethically repellent dishonesty, but that would dignify it.

Ya' know, it takes more than the word 'institute' to have some credibility, John. How is anyone supposed to take you seriously when your cherry-picked sources are about as reliable as Dick Cheney's were for Iraq? If McLaughry's sloppily researched op-eds are the best the conservatives of Vermont have to offer, it's no wonder they're an endangered species in Vermont. But I'm not complaining.

Read More...

Monday, February 5, 2007

Well, then... Welch signs on to H.R. 508

Well, then... Peter Welch has signed on to the anti-Iraq war bill H.R. 508, which I've been talking about all week, here and here. From Welch's office (via Green Mountain Daily):

"What is clear is the financial impact of the President's failed policy in Iraq. The President requests an additional $245 billion in funding for operations in Iraq and Afghanistan for the fiscal year 2007 and 2008 budgets and projects $50 billion more to be spent in fiscal year 2009.

"Pressing needs are going unmet because of a failed Iraq policy. There will be no more blank checks for the war.

"To that end, I am working closely with my colleagues on tough legislation that demands an end to this war:

I am an original cosponsor of H.R. 508, sponsored by Representatives Lynn Woolsey and H.R. 746, sponsored by Rep. James McGovern, both call for the redeployment of all U.S. forces from Iraq within a six month period and the turnover of all U.S. bases to the Iraqis.

I have co-sponsored a resolution with Rep. John Murtha, H.J.Res. 18, calling for an immediate redeployment of our troops.
Finally, I have co-sponsored H.R. 353, legislation introduced by Rep. Markey to prohibit the President from spending funds to escalate the troop presence in Iraq without specific Congressional approval."

Now, there's a bit of a discrepancy here in that I couldn't find Welch on the original list of co-sponsors, but I'm reserving judgment until I get more details.

So, this is good, no? I'll be posting more on this as I get more info... Thanks to my fellow bloggers who spread the word about this last week. Who knows, maybe it had an impact, maybe not... and I did see the U.S. House of Representatives pop up on my sitemeter a few days ago, so someone down there is paying attention to this. Or at least curious. But, hey, if it ended up in 50 phone calls to his office, then it had its part.

Now, be sure to call Welch's office and thank him. And now that that's out of the way, have a look at Welch's global-warming proposal, the Carbon Neutral Initiative, something that has gotten lost in the shuffle this last week.

UPDATE: Although, in typical predictable fashion, some in the batshit-insane VT right-blogosphere are already trying to make hay over the discrepancy, it turns out the mistake was that Welch was the original co-sponsor of H.R. 746, not H.R. 508. So don't buy into the hype, these people are desperate at this point (considering Welch has only been there less than a month, maybe if they waited a little longer, they'd actually find something of substance).

Read More...

Saturday, February 3, 2007

More KC - Discipline

More math rock. This one can put you into a trance... Enjoy.

Read More...

Is This What Democracy Looks Like?

(Note from J.D. -- I've posted this account of last week's Washington protests from two of my friends (Lee Light and Robin Taylor) who were there. Hope you enjoy.)


These are some observations of two 60+ year old women, veterans of civil rights, women's rights and anti-Vietnam movements returning to the demonstration circuit. Because the actions of this administration are so disastrous, we decided that we needed to participate in the anti-war rally and march in Washington, D.C. on Saturday, January 27. Many friends and community members that we told thanked us for taking the trip and said that they were with us in spirit. It was a very cold night on Friday at 10pm when we boarded one of six buses that Peace and Justice Center had chartered to take folks down to Washington. We got on the Montpelier bus and knew only four people out of the 55. Some of the others seemed to be new to the anti-war movement. There were some families and also a church group. Everyone was eager and proud to be representing the anti-war voice in Vermont. We heard of estimates of 500-750 Vermonters in total that went to Washington. We were a proud bunch wearing our "Vermont Says No to War" banners and stickers.

On Saturday under a bright sun and temperatures in the 50's we listened first to church leaders, then politicians, political activists, ex-soldiers, and celebrities. For about two hours we listened and cheered. The main themes of the speakers were to bring the troops home now and not fund the escalation and the occupation. The bounty of caring for the troops, their safety, and care when they returned home came through loud and clear, as well as concern for the suffering of their families. Speakers also mourned the lost lives of Iraqis and their children who have been caught up in a useless and unending war. But there was an underlying message coming through loud and clear through signs and chants that these Americans wanted Bush and Cheney impeached. Several signs read Pelosi in 2007!

But we would like to mention some of what the media didn't cover in reporting this event. There were people from all over the country: Washington, Oregon, California, Iowa, Texas, Michigan, Minnesota, Wisconsin, to name a few. The AP story in the Sunday Times-Argus implied that the organizers, United for Peace and Justice, hoped for 100,000 people and were disappointed. We strongly disagree. At the rally and march we believe we were about 500,000. The park police on orders from the White House no longer give estimates of the size of protest marches and rallies. There was also no mention in the AP story of the `Impeach Bush/Cheney' signs that were everywhere.

After the rally, demonstrators expected to march down Pennsylvania Ave. As folks were moving forward to start the march, people were being corralled through a passage way to the parade route that funneled the 6 lane boulevard down to three, creating a tremendous bottleneck. People slowly edged forward to get in line. Once we were on Pennsylvania Ave. we were allowed to march 2-3 blocks up toward the Capitol and then the crowd was dispersed because we were blocked from going further. This action of police manipulation of the crowd successfully defused the momentum of the marchers. It was virtually impossible to see how great a number of people there were. While we weren't herded into corrals like protestors in other demonstrations in New York City, our effort to send our message to the rest of the United States and the world was definitely thwarted.

Eventually the "march" which really wasn't a march was over. We wondered why we didn't parade down Pennsylvania Avenue toward the White House. We believe we had been allowed to demonstrate under the control of a government that had absolutely no intention of listening to the people. If Congress allows the Bush/Cheney administration to continue to ignore the vote of the American people then we are only living under the illusion of a democracy.

Did the media minimize the rally by underestimating the crowd? Did they forget to mention the outcry for impeachment? Was the coverage of the rally and march downplayed by only minimally reporting the event in the press? Looks that way to us!

Lee Light farms with her husband in Marshfield.
Robin Taylor is also a farmer in Marshfield.

Read More...

Gov't Links Added

I put a new link section beneath the music links, for U.S. Government links, such as the House, Senate, the VT delegation and a few other things. They're useful for contacting gov't officials and doing research, as well. Use 'em.

Read More...

More on the Woolsey Iraq Bill

I've finally gotten some time to actually read the 'Bring Our Troops Home and Sovereignty of Iraq Restoration Act of 2007' (H.R. 508) by Congresswoman Woolsey. As I see it, this is the ONLY bill that House Dems should be talking about, no more of this 'nonbinding resolution' crap, which are basically methods of acting like you're doing something while doing nothing. You can read the entire text of the bill here. Some things in the bill worth noting:

"The occupation of Iraq has made the United States economically and militarily weaker, has made the United States less safe because it has enhanced the recruitment of terrorists, and has diminished America’s prestige and influence in the world.

The civilian leadership at the Department of Defense has failed to adequately support United States Armed Forces in Iraq, which were not trained to carry out an occupation and did not receive the proper equipment to achieve their stated mission.

Congress declares that it is the policy of the United States—
(1) to end the occupation of Iraq on the basis of the findings specified in section 101;
(2) to accelerate the training and equipping ofthe military and security forces of the Government of Iraq;
(3) to pursue security and stability in Iraq through diplomacy;
(4) to help preserve the territorial integrity of Iraq as a nation state;
(5) to take all appropriate measures to account for any missing members of the United States
Armed Forces or United States citizens in Iraq; and
(6) to turn over all internal security activities and military operations in Iraq to the elected Government of Iraq not later than the end of the six month period beginning on the date of the enactment of this Act"
And I love this one here...
SEC. 109. PROHIBITION ON PRODUCTION SHARING AGREEMENTS FOR IRAQI PETROLEUM RESOURCES.
(a) PROHIBITION.—On or after the date of the enactment of this Act, no department, agency, or other entity of the Government of the United States and no national of the United States may enter into a contract for the development, production, or marketing of petroleum resources in Iraq.
Kinda defeats the purpose of why we went in there, huh? Now, maybe I'm repeating myself here, but it's time for Vermonters to take Peter Welch to the mat on this, especially considering that he based a good portion of his campaign on ending the war and bringing the troops home. The nonbinding resolutions Welch supports do nothing. Zip. Nada. So, once again, nicely call his VT office at 888-605-7270 or his Washington office at 202-225-4115, and ask Welch's office why he hasn't signed on as cosponsor to the Woolsey bill, if he is really serious about ending the war in Iraq. And remember, be nice.

Another thing... if Welch does sign on, let's give him props for actually doing what he was elected to do. But if he doesn't, it's time to start calling for his head. I've already got the spike ready.

Read More...

BREAKING: Bush visits local diner in Peoria!

... and no one gives a shit.

Read More...